Sign In:
42926
Type: Album Release date: 06/10/2008
Your Rating:

Starting an album with feedback and a brooding stumbling of drums before lurching into a rhythmic onslaught of grating (dis)chords is a rather good plan, isn't it? Well, I think so - and the opening of Popular Workshop's debut album, We're Alive and We're Not Alone, is a rather fine example of the technique.

You would, of course, be justified in pointing out that it's not exactly a new trick; and that quibble could, in all fairness, be applied to much about this album. The jerkily crashing guitars tempered with scratchily clean-sounding rising chords; the reverberating disco-tinted basslines lifting the whole and adding an extra layer of energy behind the already pretty vital tunes; the yelled vocals with occasional whoops and howls and extra-stylised pronunciation to add texture; the sharp and pointed production adding an extra layer of aggression... It's all a little bit post-punk, with a hint of darker Brit-pop; there's a definite hint of Josef K in there, and some Fall, and a bit of Ikara Colt...

In short, you've probably heard most of the ingredients before; but it seems a tad churlish to complain about a certain lack of originality when said ingredients are this well put together. The jumps between different levels of sound are placed exactly where they should be, while still being sufficiently extreme or laced with oddity to maintain a surprising air. Those vocal acrobatics are timed just right to lift the sound; the wails of noise and feedback add just the right amount of depth to the sound; the rhythmic thuds and bounding basslines are played with the conviction necessary to allow the industrial forcefulness not to sound clunky or overdone. And the odd deviation from template - the alien siren wailings or piano played with an out-of-control randomness - fits the genre well enough to complement it while still adding just enough variation to keep things interesting.

Some songs, of course, work better than others. Funkier basslines are one of PopShop's strong points, and the less jerky, more guitar-focused songs sometimes tend to fall down as there's not enough momentum in what you're hearing to sweep you along and let you forget that it all sounds a tad... well... familiar. But on many of the higher speed songs with more life and momentum, the sound is so forcefully gleeful as it pours out of the speakers, that the old tricks come across as fresh and new again and it's a pleasure to listen to it and be reminded of exactly what's so fine about quirky post-punk indie jerkiness.

7/10

Bought this on Tuesday ....... love it!!

Reptilians

I'd say Reptilians is a great song, with a wonderfully Boo Radleys-esque chorus, but I'd agree that the album as a whole is probably a 6/10.

Dissapointed.

Dissapointed

Have to say i'm disapointed with the album having followed their progress for the last couple of years. In comparision to their previous recordings the album sounds dull, Albini seems to have he's taken the edge off they're sound. 'Sean', 'Channels' (EP version) and 'William, It Was Really Something' remain their best work.

Shame.

Gets better and better

with repeated listens, although I was initially slightly disappointed. The main problem is that PopShop usually produce themselves and are brilliant at it - Steve Albini just does his "Steve Albini Anti-Production TM" thang, regardless of who he's working with. To be fair, I'm not a fan at all of Albini's production on anything Albini does, but that's a personal thing, and it doesn't overshadow the fact that the songs here are pretty much all great. It does seem a bit baffling that they've left so many of their best songs off (Sean, Sunday Morning 10AM, William...) but the new ones are growers.

Perhaps an iTunes-only demos album would appease such grumbles? Certainly the self-produced recordings are all uniformly brilliant and would stand up to proper release, licensing issues notwithstanding...

POPPYCOCK!

Out off all the bands I have played with over the last 4 years, Popular Workshop still remain the most thrilling and original without selling out to anyone.

If Popular Workshop did have those 'old songs' on this album, people would have complained that they hadn't written or recorded any new material. It's a catch 22 and nobody wins when it comes to music snubbing. Especially if big industry cunts decide on weather your album should be considered important or not based on if your label have the right funds in the bank or the right favors owed by other industry toss pots.

There are plenty more 'good' songs on this record that can fulfill the average popshop fan - My favs are Villains, Her Birthday and Radical for sure.

<3

note to self...

...don't write when drinking.

Er...

to be fair, you did seem to miss the bit where I said I like the songs but not Albini's production. You of all people should know how much I love PopShop!

...and...

the only reason it's a shame those older songs aren't on the album is that I think more people should hear them!

Maybe the one about my band, yes.

:P

and, sunday morning 10am is a tune!

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon