- Artists:
- Cat Power »
- Label:
- Matador Records »
Context, sometimes, is everything. Knowing that Chan Marshall finished recording Sun as her relationship with Giovanni Ribisi reached a tortured end will inevitably colour the way that some folk hear and interpret this album. Some of the first words that you hear (on ‘Cherokee’) cut painfully through the anticipation: “I never knew love like this / wind, moon, the earth and sky / I never knew pain like this… I never knew pain, I never knew shame and now I know why.” Marshall’s words are double-weighted with emotion but ‘Cherokee’ manages, somehow, to be uplifting; through all the drama comes a sense of resolution and stability.
Sun is the most rounded and accomplished album of Cat Power’s career. It seemed that she may have reached a creative peak with The Greatest, which signified a definitive leap in her musical evolution. That wheel kept on turning though and Sun marks an even bolder step forward; the songs sound light and layered with space and sound, where The Greatest was dense in comparison and played to an era, toying with the sound of Memphis soul. Sun, though, is rich with an air of experimentation, with none of the pitfalls of amateurism that often accompany such forays into musical exploration. The electronic bedding of the tracks act as a buoyancy aid for her rich vocals and even when ‘Silent Machine’ descends into a deliberate mess of auto-tune and cut‘n’spliced vocals, it’s considered and fitting to the song, rather than simply serving as gratuitous sound-fuckery.
One track to stand out from this, though, is ‘Ruin’. Featuring Jim White (The Dirty Three) on drums and Judah Bauer (Jon Spencer Blues Explosion) on guitar, it’s a driving, keyboard-led song (keys courtesy of Gregg Foreman), with a different vibe to the rest of the album. “Bitchin’, complainin’ / when some folks ain’t got shit to eat,” Marshall purrs disdainfully in her beautifully dusty voice. It’s a learned expose of modern greed, picked up from a life on the road. The song itself fades in and out, nagging at your conscience and your ears, a paean to the disappointment of human nature – something that Chan Marshall is pretty skilled at picking apart and filtering into structured and inspired song-craft.
‘Human Being’ and ‘Nothing But Time’ are also musings on the strength of the human spirit, throwing up all of its fragilities and all of its wonderment in equal measure. “you’ve got your own voice, so sing / you’ve got two hands, so let’s go make anything,” she sings on ‘Human Being.’ Lyrically, Chan has often been reflective and powerful but never more so than now. These words hit so hard because they seem to come from a place of confidence and perspective. When she tells you “never give away, never give away your body / never, never give away your friends / never, never give what you always wanted,” it’s like the best advice your mother never thought to give you, the vital clues to living a happy life. And of course, if Iggy Pop is crooning in the background when your mother decides to impart some worldly advice to you - as indeed happens here - then you’re probably more inclined to take it on board, right?
Sun is the sound of an artist underscoring the drag of modern life, rather than exploring its mysteries. Over time, Marshall seems to have evolved from tortured pupil, to worldly teacher and her artistry has matured with her mind-set. Even peering through the gauze of the back-story, Cat Power’s ninth album is a feat of musical and emotional maturity. Sometimes, context means very little at all.
- Drowned in Sound's Favourite Albums of 2012: 25-6
- DiS Staff: #1 Albums of 2012
- 50 Musicians To Follow On Instagram
- Corona Capital Festival: DiS does Mexico City
- September 2012: Editor's 10 Favourite Streams + Spotify playlist
- Weekend Listening: Gwilym Gold, Jens Lekman, Erol Alkan, Patrick Wolf + lots more
- Weekend Listening: Gwilym Gold, Jens Lekman, Erol Alkan, Patrick Wolf + lots more
- Cat Power - Sun
Bit confused by this
I agree it's a brilliant 9/10-worthy album ('Manhattan' is my new favourite Cat Power song), but I'm baffled by your premise. Especially the slightly throwaway and a little bit patronising notion of 'maturity', which so many journalists seem to be obsessed with.
Since the first time I heard What Would the Community think, I've felt Chan has such an old soul that right from the off you could hear a life's worth of heartache and sadness in her music. There's also this emotional intelligence permeating from her music that feels like 1000s of years of previous generations arguing in her mind and haunting her heart. It's this sense of being anchored in history - evident throughout her career - that goes so much deeper than any relationship that happened in the past six years while making this record... Maybe you're right, but for me this doesn't feel like a reactive record from someone with fresh heart wound, rather the work of someone whose spent a career refining how to translate the human heart and soul into music, and masterfully leaving a few clues about existence sewn into the seams. Chan Marshall has always done this, and although the droptop-friendly 'sound' of this record is a playful progression from what's come before, I'm not sure this review really nails it, but then that's part of Chan's charm, that she's a mystical being and impossible to pin down... and there's no 'right' answer.
I'm sorry Sean, I've got to take a bit of issue with this
I've not listened to the record yet so I don't have much of an opinion on Hayley's premise in itself. It was, as usual for her, an entertaining and thoughtful dissection, as proved by you feeling moved enough to reply below positing an alternative angle - that's all part of the fun of reviews of course, the debate and discussion of art and opening yourself up to new interpretations of a work that you'd otherwise not considered.
However, 'Especially the slightly throwaway and a little bit patronising notion of 'maturity', which so many journalists seem to be obsessed with' Really irks me.
As editor of this site I'm not sure why you'd choose to so openly disparage one of your writers on a piece that she's written for you, for your website. I know that the continual drive of discussion by both the site’s users and contributors is what is key to its success and, of course, you should be able to partake in that as much as anybody else. However, to say something like that in the public domain to one of your writers, something that’s been written which sounds like it’s been done so with a shit-eating grin forming across your mouth, is pretty insulting to both the writer in question and, I imagine, plenty of others here who slog their guts out to produce quality content for you free of charge. As editor you’ve the power to discuss grievances with copy behind closed doors, choosing to do so out in the open like this shows a disregard for the efforts the writer has put in for you, and indeed, a general dismissal of the quality of their work (and Hayley is one of the finer writers out there). I’m sure you will come back enjoying the fact that you’ve trolled me or whatever, or you’ll point out that to make it as a writer you’ve got to take a good shoeing from time to time, but in this instance and in this way I think it was misplaced, and sends a pretty bad message to any contributors and would-be contributors about the value you place in the work they do for you.
Tl;dr
Cripes
at the risk of this all being a bit DiS's dirty laundry, I think Sean was writing as a music fan first and foremost and I hope Hayley doesn't take the above as anything more than a fan with strong feelings about the record wading in with his tuppence.
We actually had some behind the scenes discussion of this, and while I won't bore you with the entirety of it, I've not been blown away by this album and actually find the context here helpful, as it's the emotions I've been having problem finding beneath all the studio slickness...
^ get a room!
Sun, for me, is a super fantastic record. (And I didn't even know about ex-bf, mental hospital, etc until Amanda PF's excellent article the other day) But not everything is quite as strong as Cherokee and Ruin, so I'd have dropped the score one notch, but hey.
Although Cat Power does stellar jobs with covers, I'm thrilled she's finally back to original material.
Agreed.
Thought Sean's comment more than a little 'proprietary'... a WTF? moment.
Andrzej's kinda said what I wanted to say
I'm a fan of Cat Power and this album, and this was a point of debate, rather than some ogre stomping in and attempting to destroy something. Life in which you can't debate opinions on opinions and interpretations of interpretations, is not a world I want to live in.
Plus, as you know, Andrzej is our reviews editor, so I have no say in the reviews and rarely (unless there's an issue) see them until they go live.
This is a dumb thing to say, but I'm a little annoyed at how
Pretty much every article/review about Cat Power says "Chan Marshall" within 2 seconds. It's almost as bad as "Lana Del Rey... AKA LIZZY GRANT!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
It's like, shit. Yeah. We know her real name is Chan Marshall. We've known for over 15 years.
Dumb comment, but it is starting to bug me. Hah.
but how else do you refer to her?
Lana Del Rey is a pseudonym, so I guess it doesn't feel that odd using it, but it'd just read really strangely if you only referred to Chan Marshall as 'Cat Power', it's the name of the project, not her stage name.
It's like every review of Carson McCullers' books...
begin with "At the age of 23..."
sean's really crossed the line here.
we're going to have to get rid of him. it's in the site's best interests, i think we all appreciate that.



Cat Power
"More bands should split up" - Brett Anderson opens up to DiS about the return of Suede
Drowned in Manchester #15 – May 2013
armchair dancefloor 39: Mount Kimbie interview, Bobby Browser, Powell, Move D, Leon Vynehall...
DiS meets John Lydon - Part 1: The Man
DiS Does Singles 20.05.13: Paramore, Laura Marling, The Replacements
DiS joins the Music Alliance Pact + May 2013's global MAP compilation
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article