- Artists:
- Feeder »
- Label:
- Echo Records »
Hands up all those who stopped caring about Feeder once the ‘90s ended. Both 2002's Comfort In Sound and 2005’s Pushing The Senses collections seemed to confirm the band had joined the pipe-and-slippers Snowplay generation, less than a decade after initially emerging as – don’t laugh – one of British rock's serious threats to the stateside domination enjoyed by the likes of Foo Fighters.
They may have chosen to "drink cider from a lemon" later on in their career, but at its outset Feeder were one of those bands that never quite managed to fit in with the zeitgeist of the time, and were all the more cherished for it. It’s unlikely they’ve ever been anyone's truly favourite band, but they were virtually impossible to be offended by at the same time, and even during the late ‘90s when Liam, Damon and Jarvis dominated the alternative section of the mainstream, Feeder were busily making their own waves via a clutch of impressive singles that would pave the way for bands like Muse, who supported the trio on a number of dates.
While Muse’s star continues to ascend, Feeder have always seemed quite content to shun the limelight. It was only by the time of 1999's Yesterday Went Too Soon - one of the most underrated albums of its decade - that people realised here was a band that had to be taken seriously in their own right, rather than as a well-travelled support act. Previously seen as too pop-orientated for the rock market but too loud for the Britpop circuit, Yesterday... mixed the two like peaches and cream. Anyone who can’t admit to having a soft spot for the title track or the frenetic Therapy?-baiting 'Insomnia' needs to book an appointment with their otologist.
Fast forward into another decade, past the tragic suicide of original drummer Jon Lee, and you find a band in turmoil. Vocalist and guitarist Grant Nicholas and bass player Taka Hirose had lost their way, but who else can honestly say they wouldn't have been similarly affected by the death of a bandmate and friend. Skipping the forgettable material of that opening paragraph, their recent live shows, featuring the re-introduction of early-period material, suggested that they would soon trace a path back to their roots, to the good old days and all that.
Nearly two years in the making, Silent Cry is the result of a few steps backwards in the name of progression. Gone are the clumsily worded, maudlin semi-acoustic ballads that punctuated Pushing The Senses. Also absent are big-name producers like Ken Nelson, Stephen Street and Gil Norton. Instead, Nicholas has pretty much single-handedly taken on the recording process for the first time since their Swim EP days, and as a result Silent Cry sounds all the more charming, naturally flowing, and resurgent for it.
Make no mistake about it, this is a return to form for an outfit long written off by fans and critics alike, and rather than chasing the tails of insignificant others or fulfilling contractual obligations, the majority of Silent Cry feels like a record that was made with a huge weight lifted from its shoulders; that weight being one of expectation.
No longer at a stage where they have to impress record industry tastemakers or fickle, scene-hungry punters, Feeder have created a record here that Nicholas said back in 2006 they were going to do all along. It does feature a "heavier sound" that probably won't sit well with daytime radio pluggers, but ensures their relevance remains despite a turbulent decade to date.
Opener and lead single, and possibly the album's weakest track, 'We Are The People' is an overwrought statement of worthiness that doesn’t make the best first impression, but even in its fading coda of "Let's step it up again", the impending sense of urgency never wanes. What comes next is a dynamic brace many thought Feeder had dispensed with many moons ago: 'Itsumo' and 'I Miss You' both kick ass in a way many people had forgotten this band were ever capable of, and added to the aggressive pomp of 'Who's The Enemy' ("Running away, losing our way, we're fighting with ourselves but who's the enemy?") and the white noise of 'Guided By A Voice' ("It's our time so think about it"), Feeder have unleashed their most incisive, pogo-friendly statements of intent since the halcyon days of _'Insomnia' and 'Seven Days In The Sun'.
Silent Cry isn't perfect, and given their past efforts no one could have expected it to be. But it is light years ahead of the dreary sludge their material after Lee’s suicide had come to represent, and in the closing, Black Holes And Revelations-styled 'Sonorous' contains their most audacious four minutes to date. A remarkable turnaround then, and although not quite a 360 degree shift, this is a damn fine record that Feeder should be proud of.
- Leeds Festival 2012: Drowned In Sound's Sunday blog
- In Photos: Feeder @ The Leadmill, Sheffield
- Feeder - Generation Freakshow
- "Guitar music's dead? I think that's absolute bollocks!": DiS meets Feeder
- In Photos: Jersey Live Festival 2011 @ Royal Jersey Showground
- Splendour 2011: The DiS review
- In Photos: Chester Rocks Festival 2011 @ Chester Racecourse
- In Photos: V Festival 2010 @ Hylands park, Chelmsford
so everyone stopped caring about feeder at the end of the 90s?
but people began to take them seriously with the release of an album in 1999?
How many times do they use the metaphor of
"bringing me down"
"pulling me down"
"pushing me down"
"holding me down"
"forcing me down"
"pulling me under"
?
Average per album is like 8. Literally.
I think you've misread that.
The post-2000 material, new decade stuff is the forgettable, give-a-fuck crap.
BAT FOR LASHES IS ON HOLLYOAKS.
Yeah its a bit odd that review.
I like how he's made an effort to completely overlook their 'commercial' album, even though that was probably their best.
Polythene?
Straight-up banger.
this is
really better that the new My Morning Jacket album? I think not.
i will never ever bad mouth feeder..
they were like my favourite band in the world when i was about 13. i even vaguely recall penning a letter to the singer at the time, but i don't think i ever sent it.
the track 'yesterday went too soon' was fucking immense.
probably.
i am really looking forward to hearing this.
itsuomo is a cracker.
^^
same. they were the first 'proper' band that i liked, and i love them for it. this review made me smile from ear to ear. thanks.
"It’s unlikely they’ve ever been anyone's truly favourite band"
um, they're mine!
this album is a real return to form and it sounds SO GOOD live!
Swim EP.
Lots of shit.
The end.
Never cared for the band
But I like the suggestion that they are no longer a sub-"Snowplay"-type act with this album. I may give it a listen.
I once saw Grant and Som from My Vitriol at the same gig. Tiny little fuckers the both of them.
hhhhmmmm
ever more tempted to get my hands on a leaked copy. I really hated the last album which is seriously putting me off this, maybe I should just put my teen love of Feeder on the shelf and leave it to wither and die completely? maybe.
seriously
buy this album, it will restore all faith!
if this is true then
wub wub wub for feeder.
i think im the only person who thinks echo park is rubbash and comfort in sound is ok.
swim, polythene and yesterday are bestest though.
i ignored this download
when i saw it last night. i might now give it a whirl. New year's eve 1997/1998, Polythene was on the stereo all night. I lost a few friends that night, but remains a highlight of my youth. Fuck, i'm going to download that too! and YWTS!
I never got Feeder
My mates loved them, but I always felt they were disposable, limp wristed pap. Nothing they've offered has ever really contested that opinion.
Why
don't people buy albums anymore, instead of openly discussing how they're going to steal them?
yes it is
much better
I stopped caring after Polythene and I bought that on the day it was released
do I win the thread?
rent and food
usually comes first, and then records get bought later. we dont all have mumsie and sweet old papa buying us flats and haircuts.
plus
if you think it might not be great better to download it than waste money on it, plus I've bought all their other albums, been to several gigs blah blah - i think i've more than covered one stolen album
Oh
Fuck off will you?
intrigued
agree with the sentiments of them losing their way with FM friendly rock. However i do want to listen to this to see if they have recaptured the energy of their earlier material.
This was a huge surprise.
I thought they'd lost it after Pushing The Senses, but this might be their best album.
Should have gone all the way and given it an 8
Brilliant album, rousing stuff.
Nor do I mate
Funnily enough my rent and food come first too. Then if I can afford it I'll buy albums. My point is I disagree with downloading music.
I was tempted to go one higher
to be honest, but like someone touched on earlier, the predictable nature of some of the lyrics brought it down a notch. Only one though mind...
Musically it's a fantastic album.
Lyrically it's an average album.
Still, music is more important than lyrics for me, so it's still a very good album overall.
7.8.
True
I wonder if Pitchfork will be as courteous?
4.8?!
I doubt they'd lavish it with that much praise.
I haven't listened to this album, or any Feeder albums for that matter,
I always presumed that like me, everyone thought they were the worst band of all time.
good review dom
kudos for not unfairly slagging them off like many others would :)
my ultimate favourite band when i was 13/14.
dont do it then
theres lots of things i disagree with, so i dont do them.
Tremendous
Nice to see a balanced review of something that could easily have gone into "it aint hip and cool so it's shit" territory. They were a good band, they did a few good albums followed by a few bad albums, seems like this one gets them back to what they were good at.
...
Horrible voice and shit lyrics, they just write sub foo fighters guff. Their music is cliche ridden drivel. When I was 15 i thought they were shit and now I'm 25 I think they are possibly even shitter.
I like the voice and the lyrics some of the time.
We differ in opinion.
Echo Park IS rubbish
And I think Comfort in Sound is probably their best album, for diversity, but if you just like pogoing then Yesterday Went Too Soon. But lets be honest, Feeder aren't really a 'good band', they're an average band you can listen to once in a while. And their lyrics are really cringing.
Wow, great review
I haven't heard this album yet but will take a listen now, and the chronology hits the nail on the head with regard to how they have declined.
Pushing the Senses was an awful album and clearly Feeder are no longer a defining act - look at the price of their signed stuff on ebay. Good to hear they're somehow carving their own way.
Also
Yeah, people seem to love them when they're 13/14 (saw them twice at that age) and then...well, nothing.



Feeder
Drowned in Manchester #15 – May 2013
armchair dancefloor 39: Mount Kimbie interview, Bobby Browser, Powell, Move D, Leon Vynehall...
DiS meets John Lydon - Part 1: The Man
DiS Does Singles 20.05.13: Paramore, Laura Marling, The Replacements
DiS joins the Music Alliance Pact + May 2013's global MAP compilation
Drowned in Bristol #12
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article