Drowned in Sound

Search



CD pile

DiS's albums of 2007: reader voting is now open!

335 votes
?
by Mike Diver

- - -
VOTING HAS CLOSED.
PLEASE CHECK THE RESULTS ON DECEMBER 14, 2007.
THANKS FOR ALL YOUR VOTES!

- - -

What a year. Granted, 2007 may not quite be over yet, but the DiS office has been flooded with releases enough – releases of incredible quality – to fill its 12 months dozens of times over. Suffice to say that cutting our favourite albums of 2007 down to just 50 took days – nay, weeks – of arguments and hissy fits.

Below is our top 50 in A-Z order, for you to vote for. A reader-voted top ten will run the week beginning December 10, and one lucky voter will receive the DiS editorial team’s top 25 records of the year as a nifty prize for taking the time to click on the buttons below. The DiS top 50 – i.e. our ordering of the below records – will run the week beginning December 3, with the top 25 analysed by our team of writers.

How the voting works

One: you must be registered with the site to place a vote. Please sign up using the link on the left.
Two: please vote for up to FIVE albums.
Three: comment below and tell us what we’ve missed, but bear in mind that we know ourselves that a number of great albums have missed the cut here… only just, too.

To read reviews of the albums below ahead of voting, just click the artist/title to link through to the assessment in question. Happy voting!

- - -
- - -

And a selection of artists whose albums really did only fall at the final hurdle: The Dillinger Escape Plan, Bruce Springsteen, Neil Young, The White Stripes, Interpol, Queens of the Stone Age, Machine Head, Biffy Clyro, Do Make Say Think, Dizzee Rascal, Iron & Wine, Wooden Wand, Wooden Shjips, Robert Wyatt, Cornelius, Super Furry Animals, Lucky Pierre, Explosions In The Sky, Spoon, Six Organs Of Admittance, Meet Me In St Louis, Stars, Trans Am, Shady Bard, The Icarus Line, Holy Fuck, The Besnard Lakes, Simian Mobile Disco, El-P, A Sunny Day In Glasgow, The Field, Shellac, Kevin Drew, Patrick Wolf, The Pyramids…

Basically, coming to this 50 was hella tough. So be careful what you click for!



You left off Bearsuit!!!

Apart from that, good list


^Report This^


LOOKS LIKE NEXT YEAR'S Q AWARDS LINE-UP....really.

it's been the best year in as long as i can remember for music....something special for everyone...just one small point though...it's a shame that !!!, aesop rock, animal collective, Arcade Fire, Beirut, Bloc Party, Dälek, Efterklang, Liars, Modest Mouse, PJ Harvey, Prefuse 73 and Radiohead are on your list when they've all made much better lps in the past, yet A Sunny day in Glasgow, the Field (and not even an apology to) High on Fire, Big Business, Eluvium, Jesu, Julian Fane, Akon/Family, OddNosdam, Pissed Jeans, Stars of the Lid, Port Royal, Frog Pocket and Angels of Light made much fresher, relevant sounding music this year ...
not moaning, it just shows how spoilt and fortunate we've been this year.
...here's my 2 cents worth...
1. Panda Bear
2. the National
3. Big Business
4. Stars of the Lid
5. The Field
and yeah, the Clipse lp is mega, but it came out last year, no ?
apologises if someone's already stated this...
p.s Klaxons….ha ha ha ha…this era’s Ned’s Atomic DustBin....


who are Akon/Family?

Avant-folk rappers?
;o)


aye...

have you not seen their shaggy-arsed paws gang-bang-dry-humping that 14- year old Ewok on YouTube ?
;o)
he he...keep up the mega-work Mike.
XxxX


..............

I didn't vote for anything.
I own the Bloc Party, Modest Mouse and Twilight Sad albums but I haven't heard enough to vote, really.

I would of liked to of seen:
Citrus- Asobi Seksu
Planet Of Ice- Minus The Bear

I couldn't understand:
A Weekend In The City- Bloc Party
Neon Bible- Arcade Fire
Favourite Worst Nightmare- Arctic Monkeys

The 1st two were probablly put in there for their debut albums, (sub-conscience love for their previous efforts got them in there).

Also I think the FOTL album is so over-rated.

Only my opinion though.


OOPS

My post went in the wrong place, oh well.


Pretty good list that:

Would have added:

Trembling Blue Stars: The Last Holy Writer (don't think it was reviewed)

Low: Drums & Guns

Grinderman: Grinderman

2007 has been a very good year for albums, apart from the UK, which has been a tad lacklustre


Grinderman's

there


Oops


TBS certainly

The Last Holy Writer is possibly their best album - it's worth making the 50 for A Statue To Wilde alone.
Also missing are:

Bearsuit - Oh:Io
Napoleon IIIrd - In Debt To
Bjork - Volta

Oh, and loads of others.


Good list

Just missing Asobi Seksu, Bright Eyes & The Decemberists (although, I suppose, technically, it did come out last year).


Bright Eyes

Yes!!


ditto

Cassadaga is a great album.


Bit disappointed by the lack of

Marnie Stern - In Advance Of The Broken Arm but still a decent decent list chaps.


^ This

no Pre, Eric Copeland or Black Dice either!


yes marnie stern

was my favourite album of the year.

and the racoo-oo-oon album should be there...


racoo-oo-oon

Was long-listed.


I think someone at DiS

has something against her. It's the only explanation. Her album came out in February, and it still hasn't been reviewed. Easily amongst the best of the year...


no El-P?

DiS is dead to me


^^^^ this

x3


I Agree

I'll sleep when your dead needs to be on that list


NO JETPLANE?

:'''''(


I would have added

The Field
Blitzen Trapper
Matthew Dear

as well...


:(

Where is The Field?


no review

no qualify


thats silly


I can't believe...

you haven't included The Twang... I'm well pissed off now, and on a Friday of all days.


Bltzen Trapper is good...

but probably not album of the year status? review coming soon though!

Im sad for the lack of Super Furry Animals, Bruce Springsteen and a few others - but, what can you do?

Excellent list... x


Wanted to see...

Kevin Drew up there. Oh well.
Others maybe Idealistic from Digitalism?


I'll

secong Kevin Drew. But Jens Lekman FTW!


lol^

Man I dislike the Twang


the Besnard Lakes and Low are the only 2 obvious album missing for me.

In my list, there would be :
Rumskib
Orion Rigel Dommisse
Remate
Port-Royal
Hearts of Black Science
Angels of light
Young Galaxy
Marissa Nadler
Fury of the headteachers


I only voted for two

I own three, but I'm not voting for Maccabees.

Anyhoo, I'd have liked to have voted for Good Shoes, Willy Mason, Brand New and Dive Dive. Still, who cares, eh?


^^

Brand New yes please


Brand New

Was last year.


I agree

Maccabees should be replaced with Good Shoes as the lists jangle-indie-pop representative. I really love their album.


What!!!!????

No El-Producto, No Burial?
Review Burial!!!


pfft

the lack of epic45 on this list makes it redundant. kinda surprised given that you gave it a 9/10!


8/10


wowzers

DIVERSE


yeah

for including mathew sawyer


Hawk and a Hacksaw..

And the Hun Hangar Ensemble????

There are some excellent albums on the didn't make it list, and a whole bunch of albums I didn't yet hear on the vote for list, makes it very hard!


is it really bad

that i've listened to a grand total of 6 of the albums on that list?


Some good stuff

in the list although I'd have probably swapped Air Formation, Kubichek and Shady Bard's albums for The Cribs, Bloc Party and Modest Mouse efforts.


I could quite easily pick 5

from the nearly list. As it is I rate only about 2 of the chosen albums


Passion / poisson

etc.


I'm with

dom on the lack of Kubichek. Also, the lack of Maximo Park, even in the nearly list, is disappointing.


That 'nearly list'

Can be super expanded - we had about 200 albums to work down from, suggested by the entire DiS writing team.

Kubicheck was on it, FYI.


As pointed out already

Low should definitely be on there. Got most of the rest though.


I voted for 4

But I am also musing on the missingness of the ace LPs by Charlotte Hatherley and yourcodenameis;milo

Bugger!


Charlotte Hatherley

+1

That hidden track (“Lost in Time”) is smashing.


Quite a chore picking

5 from that list as there is no Biffy and no Kings of Leon. Which is a shame.


The Field?

Big miss that one. There was also Lucky Soul, The Shot Heard Around the World, Bill Callahan and Loney, Dear to consider. I'm quite amazed how Tunng seemed to have become such pariahs as well - is it because the Guardian suddenly like them?


Tunng were in the running

I like it, a lot.
Good Arrows made it through to our second-to-last stage of filtering the 50 down.
But there's only room for so many. And some have gotta be missed off.


i

was gonna say tunng


I'm surprised at the lack of:

Drums & Guns (Low)
You, you're a history in rust (Do Make Say Think)

Personally, I might also have added-
Les Ondes Silencieues (Colleen)
North Star Deserter (Vic Chesnutt)
Tears of the Valedictorian (Frog Eyes)
Go go smear the poison ivy (Mum)
Vox Humana (The Monroe Transfer) (tee hee)

...but I also might not have.


argh.

i can't remember what i have voted for! :)


Napoleon IIIrd!?

I thought that would have been there. Oh and Paul Marshall too ;p


.

your missing 65dos!

other than that good list, prefer the end of year lists where you dont know many of the albums, gives you something to spend the inevitable HMV vouchers on after christmas


no LONEY DEAR

cah!


GAH!

Another album I feel should have been on there. Loney, noir has not been off my rotation of music since I got it on release.


no low??

how strange..


Again, Low was suggested...

...and made it through to the last few steps of the selection process. There's no doubt it's a good record, but it's not even nearly their best.


What, really?

By my reckoning, Dragonfly and Murderer are two of the best songs in the entire world ever, let alone in Low's back catalogue. Hmm. This must be this "opinion" thing I'm hearing so much about...


Ha ha, yeah...

But a pair of songs an album do not make.

(Be fair: all of Low's songs are beautiful.)


Oh, I'm not denying that all their songs are awesome

Drums & Guns is still clearly a nine-out-of-tenner, if you ask me. Oh, you didn't?

I grant you, it's marred only slightly by the forgettable Dust on the window and Hatchet (which, I reckon, would sound out of place on any Low album). I still listen to it about twice a week, though.

By contrast, less than a month after its release, I'd actually forgotten Radiohead had released anything recently. Hmm.


yes to this

drums and guns is unbelievable. belarus would make me weep if i wasnt so fuckin hard.


El-P!?!?!?!

Aesop Rock but no El-P? Madness!


some odd choices in there

Not talking about the more leftfield stuff, but there are quite a few albums in the main list that are pretty average: Maccabes, Cribs, fiest, Bloc party.

But you miss off the likes of the white stripes and Bjork!


Sunset Rubdown

Didn't evan make the final hurdle! Ouch