Sign In:

DiS's albums of 2007: reader voting is now open!

 

VOTING HAS CLOSED.
PLEASE CHECK THE RESULTS ON DECEMBER 14, 2007.
THANKS FOR ALL YOUR VOTES!

 

What a year. Granted, 2007 may not quite be over yet, but the DiS office has been flooded with releases enough – releases of incredible quality – to fill its 12 months dozens of times over. Suffice to say that cutting our favourite albums of 2007 down to just 50 took days – nay, weeks – of arguments and hissy fits.

Below is our top 50 in A-Z order, for you to vote for. A reader-voted top ten will run the week beginning December 10, and one lucky voter will receive the DiS editorial team’s top 25 records of the year as a nifty prize for taking the time to click on the buttons below. The DiS top 50 – i.e. our ordering of the below records – will run the week beginning December 3, with the top 25 analysed by our team of writers.

How the voting works

One: you must be registered with the site to place a vote. Please sign up using the link on the left.
Two: please vote for up to FIVE albums.
Three: comment below and tell us what we’ve missed, but bear in mind that we know ourselves that a number of great albums have missed the cut here… only just, too.

To read reviews of the albums below ahead of voting, just click the artist/title to link through to the assessment in question. Happy voting!

 
 

And a selection of artists whose albums really did only fall at the final hurdle: The Dillinger Escape Plan, Bruce Springsteen, Neil Young, The White Stripes, Interpol, Queens of the Stone Age, Machine Head, Biffy Clyro, Do Make Say Think, Dizzee Rascal, Iron & Wine, Wooden Wand, Wooden Shjips, Robert Wyatt, Cornelius, Super Furry Animals, Lucky Pierre, Explosions In The Sky, Spoon, Six Organs Of Admittance, Meet Me In St Louis, Stars, Trans Am, Shady Bard, The Icarus Line, Holy Fuck, The Besnard Lakes, Simian Mobile Disco, El-P, A Sunny Day In Glasgow, The Field, Shellac, Kevin Drew, Patrick Wolf, The Pyramids…

Basically, coming to this 50 was hella tough. So be careful what you click for!

You left off Bearsuit!!!

Apart from that, good list

Pretty good list that:

Would have added:

Trembling Blue Stars: The Last Holy Writer (don't think it was reviewed)

Low: Drums & Guns

Grinderman: Grinderman

2007 has been a very good year for albums, apart from the UK, which has been a tad lacklustre

Grinderman's

there

Good list

Just missing Asobi Seksu, Bright Eyes & The Decemberists (although, I suppose, technically, it did come out last year).

Bit disappointed by the lack of

Marnie Stern - In Advance Of The Broken Arm but still a decent decent list chaps.

no El-P?

DiS is dead to me

NO JETPLANE?

:'''''(

I would have added

The Field
Blitzen Trapper
Matthew Dear

as well...

:(

Where is The Field?

I can't believe...

you haven't included The Twang... I'm well pissed off now, and on a Friday of all days.

the Besnard Lakes and Low are the only 2 obvious album missing for me.

In my list, there would be :
Rumskib
Orion Rigel Dommisse
Remate
Port-Royal
Hearts of Black Science
Angels of light
Young Galaxy
Marissa Nadler
Fury of the headteachers

I only voted for two

I own three, but I'm not voting for Maccabees.

Anyhoo, I'd have liked to have voted for Good Shoes, Willy Mason, Brand New and Dive Dive. Still, who cares, eh?

Bltzen Trapper is good...

but probably not album of the year status? review coming soon though!

Im sad for the lack of Super Furry Animals, Bruce Springsteen and a few others - but, what can you do?

Excellent list... x

What!!!!????

No El-Producto, No Burial?
Review Burial!!!

Wanted to see...

Kevin Drew up there. Oh well.
Others maybe Idealistic from Digitalism?

pfft

the lack of epic45 on this list makes it redundant. kinda surprised given that you gave it a 9/10!

^^

Brand New yes please

8/10

wowzers

DIVERSE

yeah

for including mathew sawyer

Hawk and a Hacksaw..

And the Hun Hangar Ensemble????

There are some excellent albums on the didn't make it list, and a whole bunch of albums I didn't yet hear on the vote for list, makes it very hard!

is it really bad

that i've listened to a grand total of 6 of the albums on that list?

^ This

no Pre, Eric Copeland or Black Dice either!

Some good stuff

in the list although I'd have probably swapped Air Formation, Kubichek and Shady Bard's albums for The Cribs, Bloc Party and Modest Mouse efforts.

I could quite easily pick 5

from the nearly list. As it is I rate only about 2 of the chosen albums

Passion / poisson

etc.

As pointed out already

Low should definitely be on there. Got most of the rest though.

I'm with

dom on the lack of Kubichek. Also, the lack of Maximo Park, even in the nearly list, is disappointing.

The Field?

Big miss that one. There was also Lucky Soul, The Shot Heard Around the World, Bill Callahan and Loney, Dear to consider. I'm quite amazed how Tunng seemed to have become such pariahs as well - is it because the Guardian suddenly like them?

I voted for 4

But I am also musing on the missingness of the ace LPs by Charlotte Hatherley and yourcodenameis;milo

Bugger!

I'm surprised at the lack of:

Drums & Guns (Low)
You, you're a history in rust (Do Make Say Think)

Personally, I might also have added-
Les Ondes Silencieues (Colleen)
North Star Deserter (Vic Chesnutt)
Tears of the Valedictorian (Frog Eyes)
Go go smear the poison ivy (Mum)
Vox Humana (The Monroe Transfer) (tee hee)

...but I also might not have.

Tunng were in the running

I like it, a lot.
Good Arrows made it through to our second-to-last stage of filtering the 50 down.
But there's only room for so many. And some have gotta be missed off.

argh.

i can't remember what i have voted for! :)

Quite a chore picking

5 from that list as there is no Biffy and no Kings of Leon. Which is a shame.

Napoleon IIIrd!?

I thought that would have been there. Oh and Paul Marshall too ;p

.

your missing 65dos!

other than that good list, prefer the end of year lists where you dont know many of the albums, gives you something to spend the inevitable HMV vouchers on after christmas

That 'nearly list'

Can be super expanded - we had about 200 albums to work down from, suggested by the entire DiS writing team.

Kubicheck was on it, FYI.

no low??

how strange..

^^^^ this

x3

no LONEY DEAR

cah!

Again, Low was suggested...

...and made it through to the last few steps of the selection process. There's no doubt it's a good record, but it's not even nearly their best.

What, really?

By my reckoning, Dragonfly and Murderer are two of the best songs in the entire world ever, let alone in Low's back catalogue. Hmm. This must be this "opinion" thing I'm hearing so much about...

El-P!?!?!?!

Aesop Rock but no El-P? Madness!

Ha ha, yeah...

But a pair of songs an album do not make.

(Be fair: all of Low's songs are beautiful.)

this is great

a really good feature. when do we find out the results?

...

"A reader-voted top ten will run the week beginning December 10"

some odd choices in there

Not talking about the more leftfield stuff, but there are quite a few albums in the main list that are pretty average: Maccabes, Cribs, fiest, Bloc party.

But you miss off the likes of the white stripes and Bjork!

Oh, I'm not denying that all their songs are awesome

Drums & Guns is still clearly a nine-out-of-tenner, if you ask me. Oh, you didn't?

I grant you, it's marred only slightly by the forgettable Dust on the window and Hatchet (which, I reckon, would sound out of place on any Low album). I still listen to it about twice a week, though.

By contrast, less than a month after its release, I'd actually forgotten Radiohead had released anything recently. Hmm.

no review

no qualify

Sunset Rubdown

Didn't evan make the final hurdle! Ouch

This list upsets because I've heard basically all of them

But am in love with none of them. Rubbish.

I think I'd have voted Patrick Wolf, had he been an option.

I own a total ONE of these albums

and it's definitely not my album of the year (Mirrored). Where's ETID? That got 9/10! Where's Brand New? Where's all the interesting albums that aren't Bloc Party or Arcade Fire?

Idlewild, White Stripes and Interpol

and maybe Biffy would've got voted from me.
Probably The Cooper Temple Clause as well.

But other than that, I've voted for Arcade Fire, radiohead and The Cribs.

I like most of the list

I voted for my 5, it was pretty hard to choose... wasn't the list choosen by members in a topic a while back?

OMG

you missed Architecture in Helsinki. Criminal!

own 12 of these

but would only consider !!! or Battles to be in my top 5. would've voted for 65Dos mind. enjoy the list (Y).

It's Britney, bitch

Wot, no 'Blackout'? Clearly album of the year. You're clearly fules.

It's Britney, bitch

Wot, no 'Blackout'?

Great albums missed:

Ruby Throat - The Ventriloquist
Soulsavers - It not how far you fall, it's the way that you land
White Stripes - Icky Thump
Amiina - Kurr

...not a bad list though.

Gimme more

In fact, 'Blackout' is so good, I felt the need to comment on its absence twice.

It has indeed been a great year, but you criminally missed...

Low, Bill Callahan, Kings of Leon, The White Stripes, CocoRosie, Bjork, Patrick Wolf and The Field.

Was Burial 2006?

yes marnie stern

was my favourite album of the year.

and the racoo-oo-oon album should be there...

Menomena - Friend and Foe

Not on either list - did you forget to include it? Apart from that all my favourites are up there, good to see Eugene McGuiness!

no okkervil river?!?!?

what the hell?

this too!

such an amazing album.

WHAT!

Sorry but Good shoes???? Great album, kicks ass over the ear splittingly rubbishly average and annoying CRIBS! Hecksville. The five o'clock heroes! totally breathtakingly fantastically stupendous in every way, tune after tune after tune.
Well its not my call but 80% of the albums there don't even ring a bell let alone make me wanna vote for em! I just did PJ Harvey, Radiohead, Arcade fire and some other stuff. Am i ignorant? Or is everybody else pretending they've got 90% of these albums?

KINGS of Leon

Kings of leon's album was so good it turned me back onto American rock for the first time since Weezer....how can that not be included, forget the main stream stereo type its just too a album to exclude...........surely! I'm still in shock over Good shoes! Didn't Quo bring out an album this year, probably better than the Cribs.

hm

Funny how EITS barely missed the cut but Low didn't even make it that far.

Shame on you!

'a selection'

No Au Revoir Simone!!!!

... hello???

(and broken family band, trembling blue stars and yes boss would be on my list too)

nowhere

near as good as Stylus' list

Alela Diane

could've done with a mention

and Sir Richard Bishop

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

j.u.s.t.i.c.e.

y.e.a.h. you know it makes sense

wot?

no bat for lashes?

NOT ENOUGH P-O-P

should have included more ace albums from the POP end of the music spectrum...

ROISIN MURPHY - OVERPOWERED
GO! TEAM - PROOF OF YOUTH
PATRICK WOLF - THE MAGIC POSITION

as well as...

LUKE HAINES - OFF MY ROCKER...
CARIBOU - ANDORRA
MAPS - WE CAN CREATE

you people

are LOW!

LOL

frank turner?

i'd have that

No

Britney?!?!?!

Seriously though where is Modest Mouse?

Oh

there it is.

lol! like Mathew and the Ghosts, Furniture of the left and Grinderman

beat Shellac! get a grip you feeble eared freaks.
Lekman is the only decent one here. MIA and the sea and cake are in my worst of the year so far.

i have 17 of them

and not the harvey or radiohead. but most of them are discussed a lot on here so a lot of people will have heard a lot of them. and if you havent, you arent going to vote for them!

kubichek ...

i hav to say that for me its not enough night by kubichek...

criminal that its not on the list, but if the list was compiled by the reviewers on here it doesnt suprise me

craigx

but from thst list

its gotta be twilight sad album...

its fuckin delightful

craigx

Sunset Rubdown

Is it actually out in this country? I don't know, but it should be up there. The Field too- they're the two biggest misses. Would have been nice to see Frog Eyes at least in the top 50 as well.

Charlotte Hatherley

+1

That hidden track (“Lost in Time”) is smashing.

I own a grand total of zero of these, though I did buy The Reminder for my mum's birthday

It was £6.97 in Woolworths :imsocool:

Tones of Town and White Chalk are on the the to-buy list though.

where is 'Excellent Italian Greyhound' ?

the Cribs, Battles, Arctic Monkeys & M.I.A. but no Shellac this is just wrong. I'm not bothered who wins as long as it is not that piece of shit Radiohead LP

?

point

Good List

However, I think KOL's Because of the Times should be there also. Caribou's Andorra too.

.

I vote for MMISL 5 times, even though they didnt make the 50.

I refuse to vote for anything else.

OK then

I love the album top50 from DIS always gets me trawling the net and never fails to open my eyes to new music - so thank you for that drowned team.
However, a few albums got in there I just dont rate - The Liars album is total cack & Field music is just plain annoying. Just an opinion!!

Oops

Bright Eyes

and Fionn Regan missing.

I've just voted

but I'm still going to do my traditional end of year poll on the music forum where I let people vote for whatever they want. Non of this restricted selection malarkey.

TBS certainly

The Last Holy Writer is possibly their best album - it's worth making the 50 for A Statue To Wilde alone.
Also missing are:

Bearsuit - Oh:Io
Napoleon IIIrd - In Debt To
Bjork - Volta

Oh, and loads of others.

racoo-oo-oon

Was long-listed.

^

the new Marx

SHADY BARD

their album was immense, YOU GAVE IT A 9! why is it not here?!?

No Biffy????

What about:

Blitzen Trapper
Parts and Labor
Caribou

Otherwise spot on I think! wish I could've voted for 6 then Field Music's Tones of Town would've got me vote!

SHIT

How did I forget Variations on Swing? That's definitely my album of the year.

i

was gonna say tunng

Good year for the Ds

Deerhoof, Deerhunter, Dan Deacon, Dirty Projectors, Do Make Say Think. How weird...

Sorry...

I don't want to be one of those people who says 'I'm too cool to vote for any of the commercial shit on this list' - because I'm not that cool - but my five would have definitely included Yndi Halda's 'Enjoy Eternal Bliss', Amiina's 'Kurr' and 65 Days Of Static's 'The Destruction Of Small Ideas'.

That said, The National and Arcade Fire would definitely have made the list regardless.

Album wasn't great, but single of the year is definitely 'All My Friends' by LCD Soundsystem... in my mind, I'm still in a muddy Scottish festival field dancing to that

no asobi?

they fell before the first hurdle? or were there steroids involved?

i have 24 of this

list!?! definitely a shame asobi seksu doesn't make it. or menomena.

my 5

panda bear
blonde redhead
les savy fav
of montreal
animal collective

even that was hard

maps and caribou??

and 9 off the

also rans. i am SO SUPER cool. but also it's criminal that the besnard lakes and do make say think didn't get to the last 50

I Agree

I'll sleep when your dead needs to be on that list

Brand New

Was last year.

I would have added:

Biffy Clyro - Puzzle
Circa Survive - On Letting Go
Dartz! - This Is My Ship
Die! Die! Die! - Promises Promises
The Fall Of Troy - Manipulator
The Go! Team - Proof Of Youth
Hell Is For Heroes - Hell Is For Heroes
Jimmy Eat World - Chase This Light
Meet Me In St Louis - Variations On Swing
Oceansize - Frames
Reuben - In Nothing We Trust
Tellison - Contact! Contact!

:)

Wasn't that

Last year?

...

i would have voted for digitalism and explosions in the sky... if they were there

i have...

17 of the main list
and 6 of the off-cuts

There are always going to be albums that didn't make it...

...same with any piece like this, but we have to draw a line somewhere. Fifty seems neat enough.

It's what you DO vote for that's important. If people can't find records in that 50 that they like enough to vote for then something is seriously wrong with them... or, rather, I'd at least question what they're doing on this site ;o)

mx

What about..

...Pissed Jeans, Wooden Shjips?

Thanks

(I think)

what about this, what about that...

what about them?
both are great albums.
so are all 50 of the above, and tens more.

now i know i've not been paying much attention

to music this year.

i have heard a total of 9 of these albums. and there's only one i've played enough to get into. there are even 3 i've never heard of...

i probably shouldnt vote until i've listened to more of them. or just vote for lcd soundsystem and nothing else...

Most of them are there but ...

iLiLETRAiNS is missing! I think they deserved to be on the list!

Poor selection

I had to go for Klaxons but only by default because nothing else was there.

No Rakes?

No Puressence?

No BRMC?

No Enemey?

No NYPC?

No CSS?

No Hawley?

Poor effort compilers.

css

was released july 2006.
the rakes album is nothing special.
and the enemy? hahahahahhaaa.

What a really uninspiring list

It looks like an NME end of year list - Klaxons, Cribs, Arctic Monkeys, a few token hip-hop and slightly left field albums and hey presto. Any top 50 that ignores Robert Wyatt isn't worth printing. Shambles.

kubichek!

easily one of the top 50 albums of the year.
and DiS gave it 9/10.

amazing album

i agree.

...

No Okkervil River? Really?
I would have put Iron & Wine in for sure aswell.

NO!!!

Why no sunset rubdown?>???????

Where's Wilco?

Sorry to see Wilco not on the list. And to omit Spoon's Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga is just wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong.

^Report This^

Omissions

Low
No Age
Dan Deacon
Dragon Or Emperor
Stars Of The Lid
John Wiese
Scout Niblett
James Blackshaw

Hmm.

oh

and Gowns.

I have just the five from this list:

Arcade Fire, Beirut, Efterklang, The National, Jens Lekman.
So unsurprisingly them chaps get my votes.
I've got about 40 albums from this year, so that's impressive that I could amost compile my own top 50 (which, other than the five above, wouldn't be from this list).

Loney, Dear and Múm are the only two others that I like that I could have hoped this site would have chosen also.

Slaraffenland, Motifs, Bowerbirds, Breathe Owl Breathe, Shugo Tokumaru, Gareth S. Brown, Paul Duncan, Benni Hemm Hemm, Bodies Of Water, and The Real Tuesday Weld are ten more great albums that I loved lots this year, and probably weren't even in DiS's top 100/200, which is a shame.

Still, I guess I should be happy that I love 5 of the albums here (well, 4, am undecided about Jens Lekman still), any of which I'd like to win, for all being pretty darn cool.

sorry DiS peeps

but naming klaxons after they won the mercury prize is not really indie.
OUT KLAXONS AND BLOC PARTY in
ASOBI SEKSU and DEERHOOF.

Wrong.

But where is the Scouting For Girls album? Jo Wiley hasnt said any of the artists you wierdos are talking about are good; therefore they aren't. Losers.

LOOKS LIKE NEXT YEAR'S Q AWARDS LINE-UP....really.

it's been the best year in as long as i can remember for music....something special for everyone...just one small point though...it's a shame that !!!, aesop rock, animal collective, Arcade Fire, Beirut, Bloc Party, Dälek, Efterklang, Liars, Modest Mouse, PJ Harvey, Prefuse 73 and Radiohead are on your list when they've all made much better lps in the past, yet A Sunny day in Glasgow, the Field (and not even an apology to) High on Fire, Big Business, Eluvium, Jesu, Julian Fane, Akon/Family, OddNosdam, Pissed Jeans, Stars of the Lid, Port Royal, Frog Pocket and Angels of Light made much fresher, relevant sounding music this year ...
not moaning, it just shows how spoilt and fortunate we've been this year.
...here's my 2 cents worth...
1. Panda Bear
2. the National
3. Big Business
4. Stars of the Lid
5. The Field
and yeah, the Clipse lp is mega, but it came out last year, no ?
apologises if someone's already stated this...
p.s Klaxons….ha ha ha ha…this era’s Ned’s Atomic DustBin....

cool list, but...

I think Biffy and Interpol should have made this list. Also, Ryan Adams new full length is fantastic.

oh, and i voted for

Bloc Party
Deerhunter
The Twilight Sad
Thurston Moore
Field Music

....as did 'Hell Hath No Fury' Mike....

.....................................

I'll

secong Kevin Drew. But Jens Lekman FTW!

GAH!

Another album I feel should have been on there. Loney, noir has not been off my rotation of music since I got it on release.

It

was fucking awful.

^ genuinely great list

MUCH better than this sappy indie uberscene bollocks of a list that we have to chose from (bar Field Music).

no ten new messages

its good. honest.

22? Really?

REALLY?

What about...

Explosions In The Sky?

Well,

Meneguar
Damezumari/Fire Team Charlie split
Daniel Striped Tiger
Funeral Diner
Goldmund
By The End of Tonight/Tera Melos split
The Drift

Probably more.

Burial

Burial - Untrue

.

Its my album of the year so far by an absolute country mile!

I think someone at DiS

has something against her. It's the only explanation. Her album came out in February, and it still hasn't been reviewed. Easily amongst the best of the year...

overrated

ah

No Age IS there.

My bad :-P

*votes*

Menomena, Parts & Labor

Menomena's 'Friend or Foe' is definitely a top album of 2007. Parts & Labor has to be on the list. Efterklang's 'Parades' is outstanding, a continuation that started with the shockingly great EP 'Under Giant Trees' early in the year.

No Reuben?

Their album was fantastic.

Also..erm...Bright Eyes? I thought DiS loved them. And anyway, Cassadaga is one of my albums of the year.

good work JohnM

be interesting to see just how different the two lists are

I've voted for 7!

Just thought I'd see what happened answer was not much!

eh?

no Okkervil river? my favourite of the year and dis has been pushing them like crazy the las t few weeks
no wilco - granted its not their best
no iron & wine?

any way everyone will probably vote for radiohead anyway

Napoleon IIIrd, dweebs!

Then Jeffrey Lewis.
Then Devendra Banhart.

MYTH TAKES??????????????????

S'okay list but..

Where are all the fantastic bands who split up this year despite making stunning albums?
- Aereogramme
- The cooper temple clause
- Yourcodenameis:milo

Plus, it'd be nice to see iLiKETRAiNS on the list!

i know you had to cut shitloads

as you were only doing 50, but why only do 50 then?

My Top 5 is probably

Battles
Of Montreal
Aereogramme
Tellison
!!!

with honourable mentions to Biffy, 65, Holy Fuck, MMISL, Dartz and The Go! Team.

there'll be a more democratic DiS users top 50 though i'm sure. there always is!

err

decent list but;
Dungen - Tio Bitar
Sunset Rubdown - Random Spirit Lover
Spoon - Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga
Menomena - Friend and Foe

All GLARING omissions.

Dirty Projectors

weres the new Dirty Projectors cd????

??????????????????????????????????????????

Love/Hate

Ah, wow, I love/hate this sort of decision. It's so hard..! There are loads of wonderful albums in this list, and painfully loads I'd love to have heard but never did, but if I had, I'd never leave the house..! I'm trying to just judge albums on their merit, and not be swayed by which bands I've seen live too. I'm not telling you what I've voted for but others that I would have included in the 50 are:

David Dondero
Iron and Wine
Maps
Mice Parade

...

Apart from DALEK, BATTLES and THE NATIONAL, I would add DILLINGER ESCAPE PLAN (which you put on your bottom list) and El-P

!!!

!!!

!

you totally missed

Daddy's Hands. was that even considered at all, at the start???????

NO MENOMENA?

And Biffy should have made that shortlist, fantastic album.

No.

No Fog.
No Low.
No Burial.

=> No vote.

Spoon

Low, John Vanderslice and Dinosaur Jr are four albums I loved that that I can think of off the top of my head not on there...

Ok,

One: No Nine Inch Nails? Reznor's best since The Downward Spiral gets no mention at all? Fuck that.

Two: PJ Harvey's White Chalk is an experiment in seeing what shit die-hard fans will put up with. It's unlistenable, unmemorable demo-fodder bullshit.

Three: Did Fields' album come out last year? I forget. It was good though - despite the critical backlash at their audacity for embracing production values. Either way, it's not on the list.

This isn't terribly conducive to voting, DIS chaps.

Shame about Low

I thought Drums & Guns by Low was a fantastic album. Also a shame that The Besnard Lakes didn't make it to the final 50. And did the Band of Horses album just come out at an akward time?

missing albums

and what about Maps and maybe even Ulrich Schnauss?

does jamie t's 10 out of 10

seem even more rediculous now - looking at albums that have been clearly better this year alone!

Brand New

should be on there, I know it was last year

thiss is a cruddy way

to do it isn't it? It's not a representative vote at all because a lot of people will only have 5 records they even like on that list, which they will vote for all of, receiving equal weight.

Peh.

.

i'm going to pay more attention to the results of the music board album poll.

No Bearsuit!
No Menomena!
etc.

I agree

Maccabees should be replaced with Good Shoes as the lists jangle-indie-pop representative. I really love their album.

the national

boxer would have been in my top 5

oh

its under T. i forgive you.

NO NO NO

NO Robert Wyatt
NO Bjork
NO Loney Dear
NO New Pornographers
NO Burial
NO Menomena
NO Iron and Wine
NO Sunset Rubdown...

These should all have been in the list...

My top 5 would prob be

1. Robert Wyatt- Comicopera
2. Panda Bear-Person Pitch
3. The National- Boxer
4. Andrew Bird
5. Bjork....

Any list of 50 best albums without wyatt is so wrong it isnt even funny....Album of the year by a country mile

It is a DAMN shame that Dillinger wasn't seen as good enough to make the list...

...because its a mile better than some of the tripe that did.

hah trust DiS to put a bloc party video on the voting page.

saying that, a weekend in the city was my fav album of the year.
shame that patrick wolf was left out. ans the dykeenies.

ahem

epic45
burial

and anything made by black people generally.

A Travesty

Where the hell is maps and kubichek? seriously, thats a disgrace.

eeehhhh...

would have voted white stripes & UNCLE.. and maybe BRMC

Nope

January was its UK release.

hmpf.

no bright eyes. no kings of leon. i cannot vote without these (even tho it is a good list on the whole).
pleeeeease put above 2 on the list.

^ this ^

Just stupid.
As are many of these other comments.
Yes, we're acutely aware that there are dozens of albums not available for voting.
Yes, we understand that you disagree with some of the shortlisted albums.
Fact is: all 50 got great reviews here.
All 50 were loved enough, passionately, but enough of the DiS team to make the cut.
A lot of these 'blah blah is missing' posts forgets that we have to strike a degree of balance between the obscure (just how many people, REALLY, would have voted for Marnie Stern? That album is festering wank anyhoooo) and the mainstream=bothering obvious.
SO: We have some from A and some from B.
And a few middle grounders.
We have to choose our niche t'ings carefully so as not to imbalance the whole thing: Justice over SMD, etc.
If you compare this shortlist to any other year's, it's the most diverse yet. Comments about Q and NME, as much as I'd like for them to be true (i.e. that both publications were as open minded as we are), it simply is not. You think NME are gonna have dalek as one of their albums of the year? Sheeesh!

If you can't find owt to vote for: sorry. If you can: bravo, into our competition you go.

There will be an editorial ranking soon.
There will be the result of this.
You wanna open it up to any album released in 2007 and make the time to add up all the votes (time we certainly do not have!), please feel free to do it. Happens every year anyway so quit moaning.

(PS: I love this list. Although I'd have squeezed in El-P and Dillinger, and maybe MMISL too, if circumstances allowed...)

but enough?

BY ENOUGH.

We don't actually control what ads run when...

...BP just happen to have a single out next week.

UNCLE?

Or UNKLE?

who are Akon/Family?

Avant-folk rappers?
;o)

And, thanks to everyone who is voting

As there are many votes already cst and the so-far top ten is pretty intere... predicta.... GOOD.

It is

very difficult to choose 5 albums from the above list as the majority do simply not represent the given artists best work (Sea & Cake, Blonde Redhead, Electrelane and Liars have all recorded much better albums in the past) or indie MOR representations (Jamie T, Bloc Party, Klaxons et al), while at the same time so many really good records released in 2007 have been left off. Without even thinking very hard about it Marissa Nadler, Tom Brosseau, Barr, Shannon Wright, Great Lake Swimmers, Thee Stranded Horse and Enon spring to mind, as well as many others mentioned in the comments above.

Andrew Bird, Battles, Grinderman, No Age and Panda Bear get the vote but properly only 2 of these would end up in my personal top 10 for 2007.

Good Shoes

My album of 07, by far. :-(

therefore

the national, battles, lcd soundsystem, the shins and arctic monkeys get my vote

YES!

The stage names is the best lbum to have come out this year. Bar none.

Bjork isnt even mentioned in the ones that fell at the final hurdle...

i'm just suprised

I myself am actually struggling with the album at the moment, and am listening to 'Debut' and 'Post' alot due to this.

Deerhoof...

...are already in there.

prinzhorn dance school

prinzhorns debut album should be on there! good to see grinderman on there though...

aye...

have you not seen their shaggy-arsed paws gang-bang-dry-humping that 14- year old Ewok on YouTube ?
;o)
he he...keep up the mega-work Mike.
XxxX

Is this Pitchfork?

The Cribs - Kubichek!?

Justice - Simian Mobile Disco?

Klaxons - A Sunny Day in Glasgow?

Jamie T - Kevin Drew?

idiots

the best album of the year is from here we go sublime by the field

where is it?

Sean stated that From Here We Go Sublime

has not been included because no review from the album exists on this site.

No scrobble, no look in apparently.

It's still my number one. Is it entirely out of the question to throw up a late addition (review wise) for the purpose of the voting system?

should

have added:

Maps - We Can Create
Jimmy Eat World - Chase This Light

That's probably why it's not on the list

2007 has been a year of disappointments from my favourite artists but Bjork is right up at the top. Having said that a bad Bjork album is still significantly better than most albums so it should be in the top 50. Tricky one.

...Are The Dark Horse

The Besnard Lakes should have been on this list, no question.

The Good, The Bad & The Queen as well!

three words

MINUS THE BEAR!?

gunge

the clap your hands say yeah album was a crime against music.

and this

is exactly why such polls are always compromised from the beginning. Making concessions to the mainstream (making any concessions) is not about excellence and leads to a watering down the field, so to speak. It's the same logic that leads to record companies pouring so much money into Coldplay and Keane.

Whilst I appreciate that dubstep's not primarily an album genre, the fact that it's one of the big musical successes of the last year (even Observer Music
Monthly's been writing about it)

I have, of course, been a little contradictory here. If compilers shouldn't make a concession to the mainstream then they shouldn't make any concession to 'political correctness', should you want to call it that, and include albums by black artists if they don't feel they're good enough. That said, I'm adamant that there are enough incredible albums by black artists this year- which would appeal to DiS' readership- which have been overlooked, and that's a crying shame.

Nice exercise this...

Helped sort out my thoughts on the years ears. IMO -
!!!, Panda Bear, Dalek, Grinderman and Animal Collective!

Good job on the list, I've 16 on there and twas daunting enough sorting those out.

Reformation

Where is the last fall album?

the hold steady

did their latest album come out this year?
just a thought.

No

it's a 2006 album.

*thought

been mentioned before but..

sunset rubdown
bright eyes
maps

this is hard

i own 33 of the ones in the main list and 12 in the 'nearly included' list so this is really difficult. i think joanna newsom and the ys street band should be allowed in even though it is only an ep just because it was so amazing.and 65dos and el-p should definitely be there but you cant have everything.im voting:

arcade fire
battles
blonde redhead
m.i.a.
of montreal

although i really want to vote andrew bird aswell

Close enuff

I own 17 of the 50. Found 5 I could get behind as damn good if maybe not the year's best.

Found a few I would proclaim as absolute crap(Pinback, Thurston Moore, of Montreal) if I were the kind of person who complained about lists on websites.

Shed a tear for:
Menomena
Icky Thump
Iron & Wine
Interpol
MAPS

Will quit crying when DiS informs me I have won the prize.

Fan equivalent of selling out. :)

yes

yes it was last year, but they should get an honorable mention every year because they kick ass with big sticks

Huh?

Arcade Fire, Feist, and Radiohead???

I thought I joined DrownedinSound, not Pitchfork Media???

2007 - a vintage year?

Either I've been putting more effort in or 2007 has been a year of some great albums, here's my top 12....

[1] - LCD Soundsystem - Sounds of silver
[2] - Radiohead - In Rainbows
[3] - The Field - From here we go sublime
[4] - Battles - Mirrored
[5] - Animal Collective - Strawberry Jam
[6] - Gui Boratto - Chromophobia
[7] - Arctic Monkeys - Favorite Worst Nightmare
[8] - Arcade Fire - Neon Bible
[9] - QOTSA - Era Vulgaris
[10] - Modeselektor - Happy Birthday!
[11] - Deerhunter - Cryptograms
[12] - M.I.A. - Kala

^ what? ^

Aren't all of those acts well-liked by the reviewing team here? I think it goes 8/10, 9/10, 9/10 for this year's releases.

This list is not changing. At all.

Thanks.

Every year, every list - this same discussion about black artists

I can't see a way out of it, 'less we're adding token albums by black acts. dälek is great, Clipse is great; but look at some other comments here: White Stripes WTF, Queens of the Stone Age WTF, Biffy Clyro WTF... seems that many a reader wants this list to be dull white-boy MOR rawk.

I'd agree with nearly all of that list

Though I'd slide !!!, FOTL and Rihanna in there...

Missing

Two Gallants
Gallun Drunk
Nick Cave & Warren Ellis

Jeff Lewis

12 Crass Songs.

Gallon Drunk

An obvious error, like you leaving them out.

;o)

Oooo err.

Checks URL..., As I suspected, this is not NME.com. Why does this list read as such?

I see a distinct lack of Reuben, Melt-Banana, 65dos, Jesu etc.

Carry on though =\

Malcolm Middleton

Aeroegramme, Emma Pollock or basically anyone Scottish! (I'm not Scottish by the way)

Also, I enjoyed albums by Mick Harvey, Unkle, Go! Team this year. And lots of others too.

Decent list of 50 though I thought.

Cribs

The cribs was best by far track by track flawless.
Done

i would have added...

... shut the fook up you whinging cocklords.

This list is nice and warm.

Do Make Say Think

Should have been on the shortlist I think, along with Low. Jeffrey Lewis, Bjork and Okkervil River as well.

It's been an amazing year for albums in general though.

cynicism

i was quite excited about this list and then a little perturbed to find both andrew bird and efterklang are currently on DIS sponsored tours...

and whilst it is a very good list

It needs more rock. The Bloc Party album should have been cut in favour of Icarus Line or Big business or something MEATY.

That said- No Age, Black Lips and The Twilight Sad, FOTL & !!! all got my very happy vote.

yes to this

drums and guns is unbelievable. belarus would make me weep if i wasnt so fuckin hard.

MENOMENA!

why why why?
album of the year by a stretch.

The shins for me

I have only heard cuts from some of the others and otherwise not at all.

Grails put out the best album this year I reckon

Menomena and Marnie Stern should be there too I reckon.
I own five of those albums so I suppose my vote would be LSF as it is the one I have listened to most.

friend and foe

would have got my vote too :(

i

just voted for 6 of them. how did that work?

Not even to fit The Field on it?

On a sheer statistical front, metacritic states it to be on average the best reviewed album of the year, i find it silly that it is not on there. Amongst a few others, but yeah, mainly the field. Ridic.

snazzy

thats silly

I wonder...

... Why Patrick Wolf didn't make the cut. And Sunset Rubdown

...

i'd forgotten how much good stuff had come out this year til i read this, i have 16 of the main list, still intend to pick up a few of the others, and found myself agreeing with a large number of the should've-been-there's: shellac, DMST, bjork, menomena, interpol, enon, spoon, mice parade, dirty projectors, akron/family, pissed jeans...
so, yeah. a lot of good albums in 2007!

sorry, but...

no Dartz? no Frank Turner? no Au Revoir Simone?

pfft...

Needs moar Shellac

Also David Kilgour and Caribou

OH MY GOD!!!

Where's butt-spangler and the shoe horns??!!!???

Jesus people, some of the names you're coming up with.. Have you actually listened to the Au Revoir Simone album?
It's quite simple, obviously the top three albums of the year were 1) Von Sudenfed 2) Field Music & 3) Panda Bear.
and they're all here.

avett brothers

avett brothers - emotionalism - album of the year 2007 hands bloody down

cheers

Maximo Park

Am I allowed to say this here? Maximo Park is missing. Would have made my Top5.

modeselektor

yes indeed. probably in my top 3, is "happy birthday."

But they did it anyway

cuz they luv a bit of fun.

Sorry, couldn't stop myself.

Broken Social Scene!

Suprised that was left out, its a top album!also, cassadaga by bright eyes is good and fionn regan too!

okay

I'll rescind on the Au Revoir Simone album, but Dartz and Frank Turner I thought would have automatically made the cut.

As for Field Music producing the second best album of the year, that's more laughable than Au Revoir Simone making one of the fiftieth best albums of the year!

Pretty awesome list

would have liked to have seen...
Parts + Labor
Matthew Dear
Scout Niblett

but otherwise it's cool. Strawberry Jam gets my vote.

Interpol

Our Love to Admire

you missed out:

thrice- the alchemy index vol's one and two,

bjork- volta,

the smashing pumpkins- zeitgeist,

air- pocket symphony,

nine inch nails- year zero,

tegan and sara- the con,

NO AGE!!

Pleased to see Weirdo Rippers in this list. Easily my top record of the year!

SHADY BARD!!!

Why the devil are Shady Bard not on there?!!!

Come On!!!!

I am losing faith in DIS. This list is awful. There are sooooo many great albums completely overlooked....

where are...

Lightning Dust, Johnny Boy, Miracle Fortress, *shels, Aereogramme, Oceansize, Shady Bard, UNKLE, White Rabbits, Porcupine Tree, Jetplane Landing, Reuben, Okkervil River....to name a few????

grinderman!

Respect!

Grinderman everyone vote

missing!!

no bjork or prinzhorn???? come on! it's a list for boys who like computers too much xx

My bests definitely include...

Miracle Fortress
Holy Fuck
Royal We

Nice list

And I like the way the voting thing works. I reckon next year though if you increased it to 100 albums then you'd put an end to most of this hilarious moaning

That said, I would've had The Field, Digitalism and Maps in there ;)

Top 10 albums you missed

1. The Bees : Octopus
2. Tapes 'N Tapes : The Loon
3. White Rabbits : Fort Nightly
4. Robert Plant & Allison Krausse : Raising Sand
5. Architecture In Helsinki : Places Like This
6. The Rosebuds : Night of the Furries
7. Camp Lo : In Black Hollywood
8. Aliens : Astronomy for Dogs
9. Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings : 100 Days, 100 Nights
10. Common : Finding Forever

you missed

david vandervelde
cold war kids
caribou
arthur & yu
felice brothers
soulsavers

albums of 2007

good list but you missed the first free internet album of the year. Crimea - Tragedy Rocks.

Missing Albums

Queens of the Stone Age - Era Vulgaris (arguably their second best album)

Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - Baby 81 (Personally, I think it's their best along with Howl)

Ween - La Cucaracha (Another great addition to their consistent discography)

Spoon - Ga ga ga ga ga (Just as good as Girls Can Tell, which is saying alot)

.

mmisl, minus the bear??

lolz, drama

OMG why is the DiS top 50 not exactly the same as my personal top 50??!?1 IT'S A TRAVESTY. i mean, it's like the list is based on SUBJECTIVE OPINION or something ridiculous like that. seriously DiS, WTF.
also, i think the voting system may be a bit screwed up, as yesterday it was letting me vote for things multiple times :D

Gripes and such

Actually, this is a pretty good list of what's come out this year that was rather stellar. I would have also included Low's Drums & Guns, but that album probably put off a lot of the older fans without winning over too many new fans. So it goes.

It doesn't seem like this includes EPs, but if it did:
Grizzly Bear - Friend
Deerhunter - Fluorescent Grey
Portugal. The Man - It's Complicated Being a Wizard

Missing

Sunset Rubdown, Menomena, The Apples In Stereo, Frog Eyes and Okkervil River.

off the top of my head

my favourites of this year have been:
reuben - in nothing we trust
the new pornographers - challengers
art brut - it's a bit complicated
None of which are on the list! Oh well!

album of the year

where is,

kings of leon - "because of the times"
shout out louds - "our ill wills"
the thrills - "teenager"
figurines - "when the deer wore blue"
taken by trees - "open field"

???

Where are...?

Kubichek!,Asobi Seksu, would have been on my list, plus Digitalism for sure. Bloc Party = great band, AWITC = weak album. Glad to see the Cribs up there though. All in all, good list I guess. Slightly surprised by Jamie T, that album isn't exactly solid now, is it? Also pleased CYHSY got in there, despite the shoddy production...

I have to say

I prefer Arular to Kala. But M.I.A. is fucking amazing. I really like All My Friends but can't really get into the rest of Sound of Silence. And the Simian Mobile Disco album is superior to Justice's, by a mile.

Smashing Pumpkins?

Come on, really? even the most one eyed SP fan has to admit Zeitgeist is not even their 1st, 2nd, 3rd or even 4th best SP album, I'm not convinced it deserves to be gracing any end of year lists. sorry galante.

Can you reveal who voted for what?

I'll prepare he witch-hunt

M.I.A = winner.

Done.

Also possibly Skream 'Skream', genre defining album, but it doesn't appear to get a mention here.

Bright Eyes

Yes!!

DINOSAUR JR.

Not a bad list, leaving Dinosaur Jr. is a shame.
Some Others I would include:
Marnie Stern, Parts & Labor, Video Hippos, Okkervil River, Shocking Pinks,
Shellac, Spoon, El-P, Boris & Michio Kurihara, Caribou, Kevin Drew.
Best Record nobody has heard yet:
Creeping Weeds: We Are All Part Of a Dream You Are Having

..............

I didn't vote for anything.
I own the Bloc Party, Modest Mouse and Twilight Sad albums but I haven't heard enough to vote, really.

I would of liked to of seen:
Citrus- Asobi Seksu
Planet Of Ice- Minus The Bear

I couldn't understand:
A Weekend In The City- Bloc Party
Neon Bible- Arcade Fire
Favourite Worst Nightmare- Arctic Monkeys

The 1st two were probablly put in there for their debut albums, (sub-conscience love for their previous efforts got them in there).

Also I think the FOTL album is so over-rated.

Only my opinion though.

OOPS

My post went in the wrong place, oh well.

overall

i like this list, nice balance of hoodoo from every which where, nothing really seems to be blatantly missing, apart from one thing which niggles my mind

New Moon by elliott smith has to be one the albums of the year, yet it isn't here, and he really should be, but he isn't.

i heard talk about clipse's album only being included in this list because it had a january uk release date. why isn't new moon included? is it because said album is a b-sides and rarities and demos compilation, and thus doesn't really qualify as an album? or is it because he's dead?

of course i respect that you lot must have had a difficult time narrowing down the list, but i do genuinely believe that Elliott Smith should be up there somewhere on that list. any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

I voted for Clipse, but

I wanted to vote for El-P. Sort it out.

Also I reckon either M.I.A., !!! or Battles will win and rightly so to be honest.

None of the albums on the list...

...beats this year's Spoon, Kevin Drew, Portugal. The Man or even Interpol. Damn, you've made me vote for Klaxons.

oh twilight sad!

i know they probably won't win, but twilight sad's album is my favorite record of this year, which is saying a lot since radiohead are my favorite band.

My 5

5. Panda Bear
4. Radiohead
3. Battles
2. Of Montreal
1. LCD Soundsystem

Would have voted for:
Frog Eyes!!!

Dungen?

Where the fuck is Dungen's Tio Bitar album? That's one of the best I've heard all year?

Tomahawk?

Tomahawk's Anonymous album should be on this list.

Bjork?

why not

Hmm

Where's fucking Burial...clearly album of the year...

And you missed out:

The Fall of Troy - Manipulator
White Rabbits - Fort Nightly
Saul Williams - Niggy Tardust
Portugal. The Man - Church Mouth

Meshell Ndegeocello "The World Has Made Me The Man Of My Dreams"

- Bjork's "Volta"
- Saul Williams "Niggy Tardust"

No

Burial?
Eh?

'Tis a hard thing to produce such a list though.

I would've voted for MMISL.

Burial

Was released just after this list. Maybe that qualifies it for next years?

no

actually, album of the year
well
maybe
...
so i'm voting klaxons, just for that

they're all

in the skip round t'back

Good Shoes

Good Shoes,baby, Good Shoes!

Not much on there for me

Pretty much all my favourite albums this year failed to make the list...Patrick Wolf, Interpol, iLiKETRAiNS etc. Alas.

A fairly predictable list

not to say that there is not some good stuff on it.

My own end of year would also include
Yacht - I Believe In You, Your Magic Is Real
Marnie Stern - In Advance Of The Broken Arm
Kaiser Chiefs - Yours Truly, Angry Mob
The Mighty Roars - Swine & Cockrel
White Stripes - Icky Thump
Wir Sind Helden - Soundso
Jeffrey Lewis - 12 Crass Songs

and Britney's 'Blackout'

obviously.

I've liked quite a few of these albums...

... but I've only loved 3, so I voted for them.

1.) Deerhunter - Cryptograms
2.) Blonde Redhead - 23
3.) Electrelane - No Shouts, No Calls

Magik Markers

Boss is my dark horse for album of the year.

tiny bit gutted..

..no Okkervil or Wilco on there...The Stage Names: mmmMMmmm. The equal of Black Sheep Boy, I reckon... And guess no review Cassadaga = no qualify, although a few months down the line it really ain't ranking with Lifted, Fevers and Wide Awake, so that's fine, actually. Though I Must Belong Somewhere and Four Winds kick massive ass. And Coat Check Dream Song. Hmmm.

but overall great list, and a struggle to pick five. Battles, MIA, Beirut, Radiohead, Feist, Prefuse, Animal Collective, Neon Bible is actually wicked and I'm still whacking on We Were Dead obscenely loud.

2007: yessss.

I would

have put Dream Theater's Systematic Chaos on the short list but I suppose irony-free prog metal isnt everyone's cup of tea.

messy

those vote buttons are all over the place near the bottom, i hope i've clicked on the right choices!

BURIAL!!!!

Where is it??? You bloody fools!!
Also The Field is not only good enough to make the Top 50, it's good enough to make the Top 3!
The Cribs??? Thou art having a laugh. Why not put Mika in there while you're at it?
x

Missing my favorites

Dungen - Tio Bitar and The Besnard Lakes are the Dark Horse would be my 2nd and 3rd vote, so I guess I vote for 1 album on this poll.

burial

burial, burial, burial, burial.

clipse was in my 2006 list.

.

A good list. Theres a few i wouldnt have included. Panic Prevention isnt THAT good.

Drums and Guns by Low would have been nice to see. Once again they remain overlooked and underappreciated.

asobi seksu

would have been good

Patrick Watson

Close to Paradise is clearly missing and is a great great album, true in canada came out in 2006 but I doubt anyone listened to it that time in UK.

check him on stage here

http://liveon35mm.wordpress.com

ciao
Vale
www.liveon35mm.com

errr

why is there not a single rock album in this 'list'?

this list is so meh

Define 'rock'

It's a fair shortlist, but...

...no The Good, The Bad & The Queen, no Caribou, no DJ Mehdi, no BRMC? They're definitely all worthy of their place in the final fifty.

At least BOTH Panda Bear and Animal Collective were included, a lot of these end-of-year polls would rule one of them out.

No Windmill?

I loved the Plane album, too.

was Menomena 2007?

It should be there

my five

01.Battles
02.Radiohead
03.Holy Fuck
04.Go!Team
05.iLiketrains

Boss-eyed whilst voting anyone?

Is it just me, or did anyone else go boss-eyed whilst voting. Several of the voting keys didn't seem to be alligned properly. Hope I voted for the right albums.
Sad to see Kristin Hersh- Learn to sing like a star, was not even an also ran. Okkervil River and Iron & Wine would also have been in my top 5. Great year for music though! There sadly seems to be a lack of original British talent coming through, which is a shame.

Scottish stuff ?

I believe there'll be a poll at jockrock.org and/or isthismusic.com so you can maybe right things there - yeah, to leave out all of Malcolm M, Emma P, King Creosote, Frightened Rabbit, Swimmer One, Magnificents, quite surprising. Or even Biffy Clyro (which I don't like).
Still, the Twilight Sad is in there, grateful for small mercies, eh?

My Favourite

My favourite album of the year was without a doubt
PICTURES OF THE OTHER SIDE, GARETH GATES but I fear that the only tracks on this album heard by the general public are Angel on my shoulder and Changes. Not a true reflection of the album as there are a lot of upbeat numbers on there. Without radio aire play an album cannot get in the top 10

missing

no fiery furnaces 'widow city'
no super furry animals, not even gruffs solo record
and no patrick wolf

in spite of that it is a decent list

2007 and the circles of sound

To choose the twenty records that followed us the most during 2007 wasn`t an easy task. To make things even more scarry, there were knowledges that pass right through us, parties for wich we weren`t invited, circles of sound that we didn`t have the luck to devour with our imagination. Anyway, Fusco reveals the twenty goodfellas of a year made of good surprises.

http://fusco-lusco.blogspot.com

where is Brett Anderson

Why did you leave Brett Anderson out of the list? He even published under DiS!

"Where's Brand New?"

^ was last year

^^^

because his album was wank and everybody at DIS knows it. Shame on them.

NINA NASTASIA & JIM WHITE

lots of people have mentioned Okkervil River, The Besnard Lakes and Marissa Nadler and i agree, so i won't mention them again, oh sorry just did, but i cannot believe that nobody, nobody mentioned the genuinely incredible Nina Nastasia & Jim White album 'You Follow Me'. it is really beautiful, awesome drumming, great talents, sadly forgotten again. oh well. nice to see someone mention another oft-ignored fav of mine Kristin Hersh, another fine album dismissed, thats the price she pays for consistantly putting out great albums, she's completely taken for granted.

bullllllll

where is spooooonnnnnnnn!?!?!?!?

a tuff one, but...

I went for The Shins. Notable albums of the year for me are The Maccabees, St Vincent, The Argonauts and Of Montreal

Wilco

Good call, I forgot how much I like that album!

Agreed

The DiS readership appears to be focused on mostly 'white' artists. And, no - it's important for no-one to not be tokenistic under any circumstances whatsoever.

So I voted for MIA, Arctic Monks and LCD. If Dizzee and QOTSA had made it in - they would've got me other 2 votes.

On the plus side, at least the list gives me the opportunity to explore som artists that I might, as yet, not have time to hear.

Heres my top 5 from your list

1) Radiohead - In Rainbows
2) The Cribs - MNWNW
3) Justice - Cross
4) The Maccabees - Colour It In
5) MIA - Kala

idiot

The Cribs - MNWNW is a fantastic album and the Jarman brothers have clearly stepped up their game musically and lyrically. I can almost guarantee you haven't heard the album because that seems to be the ignorant thing to do lately, hear about a band, realise the NME like them, claim they're shit etc. Be Safe alone is the best song of 2007.

agreed

i agree! where the hell IS dinosur jr?!

...

love maps :)

Where are Seventeen Evergreen?

I'm just wondering.

Band Of Horses and Menomena probably will be in my top 5 as well.

This, this and thrice

this.

Yeah...

I gotta throw Menomena out there, too. Any album which has 3 of the best songs of the year deserves a mention for sure.

...

Man, half of these are on by hype alone.
Modest Mouse got a 7---on the list.
Spoon got a 9---not on the list. hmmm...

Other omissions:
Menomena
St. Vincent
Besnard Lakes
Iron & Wine
Robert Plant & Alison Krauss

'hype alone'

...

WTF...

No Queens of The Stone Age or Nine Inch Nails?

still haven't answered bout Menomena

how is not on this list? that, Deerhunter and The National are my favourites. Friend and Foe is exceptional!

Top 200 Tracks of 2007

I know this is an albums list, but here's my favourite tracks of the year:

Top 200 Tracks 2007: Part 1
01) Black Kids - I’m Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How To Dance Wth You
02) Art Brut - Direct Hit
03) Les Savy Fav - Patty Lee
04) Virgins - Rich Girls
05) Gruff Rhys - Gyrru, Gyrru, Gyrru
06) Future Of The Left - Small Bones Small Bodies
07) Field Music - Closer At Hand
08) Japanther - River Phoenix
09) Jens Lekman - The Opposite Of Hallelujah
10) Wombats - Backfire At The Disco
11) Von Sudenfed - The Rhinohead
12) Super Furry Animals - Neo Consumer
13) Lionheart Brothers - Hero Anthem
14) Pterodactyl - Astros
15) Nicole Willis & The Soul Investigators - If This Ain’t Love
16) Animal Collective - Winter Wonder Land
17) Battles - Ddiamondd
18) The Go Team - Doing It Right
19) Digitalism - Pogo
20) Dizzee Rascal – Pussyhole
21) 1990s - You're Supposed To Be My Friend
22) A Place to Bury Strangers - To Fix the Gash In Your Head
23) Aesop Rock - Bring Back Pluto
24) Andrew Bird - Heretics
25) Antelope - Wandering Ghost
26) Apostle Of Hustle - National Anthem Of Nowhere
27) Architecture In Helsinki - Heart It Races
28) Band Of Horses - Is There a Ghost
29) Big Face - Drink Juice Like
30) Billy Childish & The Musicians of the British Empire - Joe Strummers Grave
31) Bishop Allen - Rain
32) Bjork - Declare Independence
33) Black Lips - Cold Hands
34) Black Moth Super Rainbow - They Live In The Meadow
35) Blood Red Shoes - It's Getting Boring By The Sea
36) Bombay Bicycle Club - The Hill
37) Bright Eyes - Four Winds
38) Clone Quartet - Carousel
39) Connan and the Moccasins - Sneaky Dog Friend
40) Cribs - Mens Needs
41) Cut Copy - So Haunted
42) Deerhoof - 81
43) Detroit Cobras - Leave My Kitten alone
44) Devendra Banhart - Tonada Yanomaminista
45) Dr.Dog - Worst Trip
46) Elle S'apple - Little Flame
47) Enon - Peace Of Mind
48) Envelopes - I Like To C U
49) Euros Childs - Bore Da
50) The Fall - Reformation
51) Figurines - Bee Dee
52) Film School - Letric
53) Foals - Hummer
54) Four or Five Magicians - Forever on the Edge
55) Fujiya & Miyagi - Uh
56) The Futureheads - Broke Up The Time
57) Grinderman - Honey Bee
58) Hot Chip - Shake A Fist
59) Infesticons - God Bless The Infesticons
60) Justice - Dance
61) King Khan & His Shrines - No Regrets
62) Lcd Soundsystem - Time To Get Away
63) Liars - Plaster Casts Of Everything
64) Love Like Fire - Unlighted Shadow
65) The Loyal Trooper - Nothing To Say
66) Mat and Kim - Yeah Yeah Yeah
67) Mistys Big Adventure - I Can't Bring The Time Back
68) Modest Mouse - Florida
69) MSTRKRFT - Work On You
70) No Age - Everybody’s Down
71) Office - The Big Bang Jump
72) Wry - Sister
73) Pains Of Being Pure At Heart - This Love Is Fucking Right
74) Parts and Labor - Fractured Sky’s
75) Pinback - From Nothing to Nowhere
76) Plugs - That Number
77) Popular Workshop - Channels
78) Pre - Drool
79) Prefuse 73 - Smoking Red Featuring: John Stanier
80) Radiohead - Bodysnatchers
81) The Raveonettes - Aly Walk With Me
82) Relay - Driver
83) The Shins - Split Needles
84) Sky Larkin - Summit
85) Spotlight Kid - Million Ways
86) Stop Starts - Dimondless
87) Stranger Son Of Wb - Hot Bannana Wave
88) Ted Leo & The Pharmacists - A Bottle Of Buckie
89) These New Puritans - C16
90) They Might Be Giants - Take Out The Trash
91) Tiny Master Of Today - Hologram World
92) Vampire Weekend - Cape God Kwassa Kwassa
93) Voxtrot - Kid Gloves
94) We Are Wolves - Fight & Kiss
95) White Denim - Darksided Computer Mouth
96) White Rabbits - Kid on My Shoulders
97) White Williams - New Violence
98) Yacht - It’s Coming To Get You
99) Yeasayer - Sunrise
100) The Young Knives - Terra Firma

Part 2:
01) !!! - Heart of Hearts
02) Amy Whinehouse - Rehab
03) Angels Of Light - Black River Song
04) The Answering Machine - Silent Hotels
05) Apples In Stereo - Sunndal Song
06) Arcade Fire - Keep The Car Running
07) Arctic Monkeys - Teddy Picker
08) Bat For Lashes - Precilla
09) Bitchee Bitchee Ya Ya Ya - Before
10) Black Kids - Hit The Heartbrakes
11) Blitzen Trapper - Miss Spiritual Tramp
12) Bodies Of Water - These Are The Eyes
13) Brazos - Mary Jo
14) The Broken Family Band - Leaps
15) Broken Social Scene - Backed Out On The…
16) The Broken West - Down In The Valley
17) Buttonhead - Boys In The Ballpool
18) Cadence Weapon - Sharks
19) Caribou - Melody Day
20) The Cave Singers - Dancing On Our Graves
21) Chow Chow - Skeleton With Hair
22) The Clientele - Winter On Victoria Street
23) Club 8 - Heaven
24) Conan and the Mockasins - There Goes Tiny
25) Correcto - Jonie
26) Damn Shames - Sex and Scenery
27) Deer Tick - Art Isn't Real
28) Deerhunter - Cryptograms
29) Dega Breaks - Wake Up
30) Dinosaur Jr - Almost Ready
31) Dirty Projectors - No More
32) Dog Day - Oh Dead Life
33) The Earlies - Burn The Liars
34) Efterklang - Caravan
35) Elk City - Cherries In The Snow
36) Fanfarlo - You Are One Of The Few Outsiders Who Really Understands Us
37) Favours For Sailors - Erode My Empire
38) Foxface - Monster Seas
39) Frances - Lighthouse
40) Gay Against You - Bicentennial Nuggets
41) Giant Robot And The City Of Tokyo - The Good Ship
42) Good Shoes - Small Town Girl
43) The Gresham Flyers - Cricket Bat
44) Honeytrap - Let's Do Naked Dancing
45) Illinois - Alone Again
46) The Indelicates - Julia, we don't live in the 60s
47) Interpol - Mammoth
48) Jakobinarina - My Television
49) Jeffery Lewis - I Ain't Thick
50) Joe Gideon and The Shark – Civilisation
51) Josh Ritter - To The Dogs Or Whoever
52) Jukebox the Ghost - Hold It In
53) Juliana Hatfield & Frank Smith - A Beer and A Shot
54) Jupiter Watts - Nothing At All
55) Kate Tucker & the Sons of Sweden - Faster Than Cars
56) Kay Kay and His Weathered Underground - Hey Momma
57) Kid Canaveral - Smash Hits
57) Kings Of Leon - My Party
59) Kings Of Prussia - Misadventures Of The Campaign Kid
60) Klaxons – Totem On The Timeline
61) Luminous Orange - Every Single Child
62) Mahogany - Supervitesse
63) Married To The Sea lion - Great Now I'm In Love
64) The Mary Onettes - Void
65) Mary Timony Band - Sharpshooter
66) Meneguar - Hurry Up
67) My Teenage Stride - Reversal
68) The New Royal Family - Anyone fancy A Chocolate Digestive
69) Noon - Underwater
70) Northern Portrait - Crazy
71) One More Grain - Having A Ball
72) The Patty Winters Show - You Are Wrong
73) Panda Bear - Comfy In Nautica
74) Piskie Sits - Big Fat Mouth
75) The Poems - I'm A Believer
76) Preacher and the Knife - The Cross
77) Ra Ra Riot - Each Year
78) Rumble Strips - Alaram Clock
79) Saint Bernadette - I Own The City
80) Sam champion - Like A Secret
81) The Scottish Enlightenment - Blue, Green & Yellow
82) Secret Shine - You are inside
83) The Silver Seas - Imaginary Girl
84) St. Vincent - Paris Is Burning
85) Taxi Taxi - Shoot The Dog, Chop The Tree
86) The Teeth - Walk Like A Clown
87) The Linn Youki Project - No Eres T A Quien Busco
88) The Total Drop - Nuit Americaine
89) Threatmantics - Don't Care
90) Thurston Moore - Fri/Emd
91) Trans Am - Obscene Strategies
92) Trolleyvox - Jean Jacket
93) Ulterior - Fifteen
94) Velcro stars - Distraction
95) The Whigs - Violet Furs
96) The White Stripes - Icky Thump
97) Wilco - Walken
98) William - Playground
99) Willy Mason - Save Myself
100) Wojtek Godzisz - The Moon And The Yew Tree

Missing

LCD Soundystem - All My Friends

Number 1 song in my book! Very extensive list though. I would also have Animal Collective's Fireworks in top 5, I thought Winter Wonderland was the weakest track on that album.

re

hmmm, that's odd...i think it's the best track on the album, although it's all pretty awesome if u ask me !!! All My Friends is a killer track to !!!

I'd vote for Bjork-Volta

you missed

frightened rabbit, sing the greys. its great!

!!

oh come on, why is biffy NOT on that list.

lol^

Man I dislike the Twang

Efterklang

I'm hoping Efterklang do well in your Poll. Great LP, and ever better live. Amiina's Kurr LP was also very good this year.

Your albums of the year

Efterklang rule your list and my personal list. And live- genius! But where are Fields? And Go!Team? Major omissions!

I've listened to most

and I could only vote for 4.
And where is New Moon by Elliott Smith?

SLGTM

Saturday Looks Good To Me - Fill Up The Room

Easy!

Yeah!

73) Pains Of Being Pure At Heart - This Love Is Fucking Right

Seconded on Malcolm Middleton

And also on Jeff Lewis, from up there ^

The most missed

These albums are definitelly in my personal top10 and they're not even nominated :/

A Place To Bury Strangers
Minus The Bear
They Might Be Giants
Dinosaur Jr.
Spoon

....

No Menomena = no vote.

At least Yeasayer is on there.

ditto

Cassadaga is a great album.

^ this ^

is very good. agreed.

reuben

BSS was lucky to qualify for the 2006 list

(and Kevin Drew was in the Nearly pile).

A few of my favourites

are in your "just missed out" list:

The Icarus Line, Six Organs, Besnard Lakes.

Also, a couple of late ones too, the Dillinger is awesome and the Yeasayer album I heard the other day, fuck me that's a cracker.

The only one you missed out that I'd definitely put in was the Magik Markers album, totally fried my brain that one.

I'll think of others (as I'm sure you have) but I think it's a pretty fair list you've made.

Where the fuck is Jetplane Landing!!???

Jamie T? Really????? I mean, seriously? Jamie Fucking T????!!!!

I'll get my tit out like Janet, coz she's unavailable...

Also, Buck 65

has released what is probably his best album to date, and it hasn't even earned a DiS review, let alone inclusion in the top 50 shortlist. I really still can't get over the Jamie T thing though, I'm sorry but that just aint cricket.

top5

1- LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
2- Clipse - Hell Hath No Fury
3- Panda Bear - Person Pitch
4- M.I.A. - Kala
5- Battles - Mirrored

>O

You also forgot Kevin Drew. WTF.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon