Sign In:
Login with Facebook
6822
Type: Album Release date: 18/10/2004
Your Rating:

I just read the greatest thing ever: the Earth makes a noise. A low, droning sound is naturally emitted by the interaction of atmosphere, the oceans and the seabed. It's undetectable to us aurally challenged humans, but just think: the world sings. It breathes in, and exhales, just like you. Fantastic, isn't it? And it'd be appropriate, too, if this review was of Isis' last album, the titanic 'Oceanic'. I could make some smart-arsed comment about how the record sings like the very world in which it exists. But it's not. So I can’t. Dang.

Rather less in tune with Mother Nature, a panapticon is a type of prison, designed way back in the Eighteenth Century to ensure that inmates’ activities were monitored around the clock; a forerunner to modern-day CCTV-riddled gaols. It's too complicated for a simpleton like me to explain in depth, but you can read up on the basics here, and explore from there should the mood take you. ‘Panapticon’ can also be used describe a society that is all-seeing, all-hearing and all-knowing; Big Brother, if you will. Thus, you'd reckon 'Panapticon' would be an oppressive record, one that suffocates the listener like a fat warden doing his utmost to stuff a pillow down your throat. You’d go into the experience expecting darkness and terror. Yet it’s a misleading title; nothing terrifying emerges from the multiple layers of sound. Indeed, as far as Isis records go, this is positively joyous – even Aaron Turner sings as if he’s shot-through with that Friday feeling.

Introductions over, let’s cut to the chase: I can’t tell you if you’re going to like this. Isis records don’t work that way, and if you’re one of the handful of people reading this that own previous material, particularly ‘Oceanic’, you’ll be well aware of why I can’t break this down into easily analysed pieces. ‘Panapticon’ must be absorbed wholly. Last night I sat with it and let it have me. It filled the room, and then the next, and then next door, and then the street. My walls aren’t porous, but ‘Panapticon’ breached them as if they were made of rice paper. That ‘Backlit’ and ‘Altered Course’ are two of the most emotionally engaging rock songs of a decade, or more, matters little: they are but part of a much bigger picture, a picture that can neither be seen nor held but must be felt.

Isis have never sounded so organic; this truly is music that lives and breathes like the Earth itself, all limp tie-ins with that first paragraph aside. People speak of the ebb of tides; this has an ebb all of its own. It laps at your ears like the sea does at your feet. It caresses them, before brutally laying them to waste.

Be fair, no Isis review is going to skirt around the fact that THEY ROCK SO HARD. Fact. That this is the metal record of the year is indisputable, to these ears at least. Don’t let that – ‘metal’ – put you off though. Isis aren’t Mastodon or Neurosis or Converge; whereas 2004 records from those bands have balanced a degree of subtlety with all-out war riffage, ‘Panapticon’ is an altogether more ethereal beast. I want to listen to it every hour. I want to be listening to it right now. As soon as I finish this, I will. It’s the only record that’s speaking to me right now; the only one that’s making me excited about music, this thing that we take for granted, such is its omnipresence in our lives. I never want this feeling to end.

Somehow Isis are in tune with the Earth. Don’t question it, just accept it and enjoy the ride. Same time, same place, 24 hours from now? See you there.

Isis - Panopticon

Good golly gosh Diver! Talk about hitting the nail on the head!

Re: Isis - Panopticon

Where's my BoP record, slag?
Billy said he'd send me one if you didn't.
65dos and The Mass tonight? Gonna be hectic.

Isis - Panopticon

Great to see a metal review featured in DiS. It's becoming clear that the mainstream/industry is moving away from metal/nu-metal/blah (though the emo/screamo bands were still easily the most popular genre with the 'kids' at Reading/Leeds this year), and this would mean that it will all go underground again. Very cool to see Isis featured. Open minded music fans need to be aware of this kind of thing.

Isis - Panopticon

Oi warrrntz it! Ooooh.

Re: Isis - Panopticon

yo bitch - i've run out! We got royally rogered by the label so the whole package looks horrible, but I'm back in the hood next week, otherwise mail me your address again!

Isis - Panopticon

Oceanic was great - but I'm not sure about Aaron Turner's screaming. Some of the songs would work as well without vocals I reckon. Is there as much screaming on this album?

Re: Isis - Panopticon

I don't understand your street jibe homey, but I'll email you my address.
Yo.
etc

Re: Isis - Panopticon

No.

Re: Isis - Panopticon

Urgh, dirty.

Yet another Diver review that made me want to hear the record badly. I'm not really a metalhead, but it looks like this is a little more progressive..

Isis - Panopticon

This could be another one of Diver's reviews that makes me think "Oh, alright, I'll buy it and give it a shot".

As long as Aaron Turner can actually sing. I'm wary about this kind of band ever since I laughed my arse off at how bad Neurosis' vocals are.

Isis - Panopticon

i fucking love isis.

i'm not sure about this record though. there are moments which are absolutely beyond compare - e.g. 'backlit' is just astonishing. but there are too many other bits that don't fit... feels like with the other two records they had a definite concept that they wanted to pursue, whereas with this one they couldn't decide between several ideas. there're no bad tracks on the album, i just don't think it flows well at all. still, gonna get to know it a bit better and see if i get to like it more...

x
gen

Isis - Panopticon

Oh, goody. I liked Oceanic but the vocals got annoying after a while.

Isis - Panopticon

i like this a lot, probably more than oceanic. the reduced scream quota helps methinks

Isis - Panopticon

whats wrong with screaming? and what the hell is wrong with neurosis' vocals? just because they dont sing in a conventional way doesnt make it bad. its just different than youre maybe used to. open your mind. it reminds me of people who refuse to listen to anything with cookie monster vocals on.
and surely aaron turner is some kind of genius. his artwork, all his bands. the last house of low culture thing was great. isis are amazing live as well. best thing at atp despite the sound problems.

Re: Isis - Panopticon

Singing > screaming because there's more variety to it and it actually contributes to the music. Screaming is fine in moderation... in places it seemed to fit Oceanic well but I felt the lack of variation detracted from the music.

Re: Isis - Panopticon

If only that equation was true of idlewild.

I hate it when roddy tries to sing properly :(

Isis - Panopticon

I like it a lot but one thing does knock a point off it for me, the drums are a tad dull.

Some more variety would have been nice.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon