Sign In:
Login with Facebook
44334
Type: Album Release date: 19/01/2009
Your Rating:

The dawning of a New Year always brings with it the music industry's "hot tips" for the next twelve months, in many cases representing little more than a bunch of artists who've been snapped up by major labels before being unleashed (via mass advertising budgets and such like) on Joe Public. If last year's main contenders Adele and Duffy became success stories purely off the back of the absence of a certain drug-troubled beehived soul songstress, then it would be hard to see where White Lies are meant to fit into the obviously marketable demographic scheme of things, particularly as the current artists their sound most resembles, Editors and The Killers, have new albums and sell-out Arena tours already in progress for 2009.

While there's no doubt that a dose of familiarity will always keep the cash registers pinging, rather than something ostentatious and ambitiously original, maybe, just maybe, on this occasion the reason why the spotlight is shining so brightly on this West London trio is simply down to the quality of their songs, because make no mistake, if To Lose My Life is anything to go by, White Lies have an armoury of them in abundance.

Although this may only be their debut record, To Lose My Life could easily double up as a 'Singles' collection, an album that given time may very well end up castigated as a "Best Of" such is the potent radio potential of pretty much every one of the ten songs contained within. Much has been documented about White Lies sudden change behind the scenes from indie also-rans under previous moniker Fear Of Flying to their current status, and while there will always be an element of suspicious doubt as to whether such a drastic transformation both aesthetically and musically has an element of contrived guidance about it (they, after all, do share management with Franz, Kaisers, Crystal Castles, et al), it could also be said that not enough credit has been bestowed on the band themselves in terms of their obvious development as songwriters goes.

Yes, yes, it's really easy to be critical where a band like White Lies are concerned. This is polished and despite some clumsy lyrical couplets that punch holes in the near to perfection, which won't do them any favours in the eyes of their most cynical detractors. Take 'From The Stars' for example, a song which opens with the line "I saw a friend I once knew at a funeral...", hardly an inspiring opening, before diving headlong into the entire rhythm section - bassline, drumbeat and all - from Joy Division's 'Atmosphere'. If there's any time where White Lies' authenticity is brought into doubt it is here, at this uneasy midpoint of the record.

However, To Lose My Life is blessed with some of the most audacious bittersweet pop any British act has committed to tape over the past two decades. While the omnipresent theme of mortality threatens to turn this into a concept album, the likes of 'Death', 'Farewell To The Fairground' and the superlative strains of the title track stand head and shoulders above the most revered works of several of their contemporaries. While singer Harry McVeigh's vocal styling can be traced back to the equivocative musings favoured by the likes of Julian Cope, Ian McCulloch and Tom Bailey, he and his bandmates have an uncanny knack for penning unforgettable hooklines and insatiable choruses by the bucketload. 'Death' is an obvious example, "This fear's got a hold on me" punctuating the final line to every verse, almost rendering the rest of the song irrelevant such is its insatiable, serotonin-diluting purposefulness. Likewise, title-track 'To Lose My Life', with a refrain which insists "Let's grow old together/and die at the same time", like some earnest instruction to seal one's own fate, takes you to places the average British band fail to find, let alone reach.

'A Place To Hide' and 'Nothing To Give' both show a more introspective side to the band, again drenched in eighties-style synths like the ghosts of Tears For Fears and Fiction Factory past, yet undeniably relevant, almost modern even for the present time. Similarly 'Unfinished Business', the song that set pulses racing about White Lies in the first place, in one instance the sound of Duran Duran scripting a suicide note before adventurously coming to life in a way that unites all music factions irrespective of genre or era.

On the whole, To Lose My Life is a solid debut that will certainly divide opinion, but approach with an open mind and dividends will be reaped en masse. Of course the ultimate question regarding White Lies surrounds whether or not they have the staying power to match the longevity of their peers, but having already experienced failure in a previous life, one suspects the upper hand will be theirs for the forseeable future.

this is very, very generous

Difficult to say under the circumstances I admit...

but ignore the hype, and listen to this record with an open mind and I guarantee there won't be a better singles collection released this year.

Because of the hype they were always on a hiding to nothing from a lot of people regardless of their output which is a shame, because both with this record and live on stage they are actually a more than competent outfit.

nice

it's a good listen, very polished, but wears after three or four unlike editors

Oh Dom, you're such a legend

Even after the constant battering this band recieves on these boards you still don't give in to the mob. Having just read this and his review for Hush by Asobi Seksu, I think Dom is my favourite music critic after John Earls.

^

I appreciate what you're saying...it is important to see past the hype and jusdge it on its own merits. However, I think I've done this and it still leaves me feeling cold. 'Death' was an admittedly brilliant first single but there is nothing that comes close to touching it on the album. The rip-off of 'Atmosphere' is cringe-inducing.

I don't quite agree with a 7

but I will say that every other song on this seemed to have a moment or a hook that I enjoyed. Unfortunately that was surrounded by both unfocused ideas on the rest of the song or the other middling efforts on the record.

hmmm a little dubious

i think the score is a tad high, and is maybe a reaction to the bad press it's received elsewhere?

A good review.

The rating is about right -I'd say a 6 or 7, depending on how generous I were feeling.

"I guarantee there won't be a better singles collection released this year"

why on EARTH would you say something like that? why?

When

I read this review an hour ago the score was 8/10... what gives?

Don't rate this band in the least. It's plodding, affected 80s artifice and not a note of it fools me for a second.

Definitely not!

This review was written over the Xmas holiday period, and even then, most of the reviews I've read since (Clash, NME, Gigwise to name but 3) have been positive, so....?

oh god

*facepalm*

Because its a valid point

That's why.

Mike Diver said pretty much the same in his Quietus review...

and i completely agree, im usually cynical of bands that are thrust into our faces, killers, kaisers etc because they lack any dynamics and this lot have been marketed as a joy division/interpol clone which they simply are not, they are great pop music and its impressive that nearly everyone of their songs could be a single, this is true (besides nothing to give, which is a bit boring). if you want innovative music go listen to the animal collective cd, however approach this with an open mind and there is some really rewarding music, its not going to break any boundaries but so what. good review dom

maybe you were cynical towards the killers

because they weren't quite watered down enough for your tastes? ;)

i can't hear their music without imagining venn diagrams of demographics trying to find that sweet spot between sounding contemporary and getting that nice balance of an 'edgy' press angle but with the actual content surprisingly non-threatening.

can't dispute that Death is a strong song and the review was well-argued, but i don't really think it's an album of singles, it's an album of the formulaic single-template being repeated over and over, without any really enduring melodies to back it up. the hooks less burrow deep into your skull but instead cack-handedly bludgeon themselves against your forehead.

it's quite telling when every defence of this band is along the lines of "they're decent enough, not doing anything special but I had nothing to complain about when listening."

the reason they get so much stick is because people object to an awkward celebration of the mundane.

I was wondering when one of the social board's

dynamic trio would add their incisive viewpoints....

coolio

just wonderin like

it would *probably*

*make* him *very* angry

i like

the artwork, and i like 'Unfinished Business' so I'm going to investigate, ok?

Superb and fair review

The album definitely deserves the rating afforded to it by DiS. They're a good band with tight songs, and the fact that biggest criticism anyone can lay on them is that they sound derivative is a pretty good achievement for them. I'd rather these guys got sucessful than that Florence and the Machines or whatever the frig she's called (yet another "Look at me, I'm an indie popstar!" that crawled from the doldrums of despair).

Bravo Mr.Gourlay

When I saw DiS had posted a White Lies review, I was expecting something cynical, insulting and very narrow-minded. The opening two paragraphs left me wondering whether you were going to swing positive or negative and when you went for the positive, I smiled. Lots.
They're by no means the best new band around and yes, they are over-hyped a tad. But they're also been unfairly targeted as something dreadful, which they're quite clearly not.

great interview

7 is perfect for this record

errr

i mean review

This band....

...is just so middle of the road. And boring...

no it isn't

you don't know everything that will be released this year, and you never will. also white lies are shit

I'm curious to hear 'em, I'll say that

Glasvegas got a bashing and I quite liked that one; The Feeling got a bashing and they're dogshit and it was deserved. But I certainly don't care whether the NME hypes WL's or not...except that they've a piss poor track record.

I saw white lies back in June...

...before I even knew who they were. And I was blown away by how amazing Harry's voice is. On record he sounds good, live he knocks every band around out of the water. Add the nostalgic eerie sound of fear and death and I was mesmerized. White lies to me represent a hyped band which are actually good, unlike the rest of bands in their field. For anyone who hasn't seen them live and think they are shit, you haven't got a valid argument.

sterile

The whole point of joy division's sound was the tension in it. This album has none. It's dead music.

i just went to their myspace to see what all the fuss was about

and saw that film they've got on there..

So wanky. So so wanky.

7 is a fair score imo

the sneering attitude towards anything given even an ounce of hype on here (and on other websites) really grates, because theres no real 'need' for it

id like to see this place 'drop' the x/10 rating, and just have a review, cos i suspect theres a fair few who didnt even read the review before sinking their teeth....

must say the score doesn't bother me

the review was a positive slant on a pretty average band, so it fits.

though if the best singles compilation of the year only gets 7/10 then 2009 is not going to have the greatest pop harvest.

it was originally

8/10... seems quite a lot gets marked down on this site.

erm...

what evidence do you have of that? I wish former contributors would keep their conspiracy theories to themselves.

hahahaha, i'm so silly.....

I read the score for this as a 7/10!!!!

this is true

actual fact.

There are at least 3 songs on this album

That sound like Ultravox's 'Vienna'.

i was told by a

current contributor. i also know other albums that have been marked down, having seen it for myself, including the Popular Workshop review which was originally a 7/10 and then got marked down to 6... not a conspiracy but a fact. pretty sad that it's come to this.

as little

as I care for the music of the Workshop, that's really shitty. It shows the editor of a site has no respect in the individual judgement of reviewers. On God Is In The TV, noob reviewers are free to give laughable albums 5 stars, but that's fine because it generates discussion and keeps things lively. I know I'd feel undermined if points were being shaved off ratings I gave just because they didn't fit the editoral 'line' of a site.

Wow!

Great review. My faith is restored in DIS.

I only mentioned them because of the constant comparisons

especially from people who've been praising WL.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon