- Artists:
- Gregory & The Hawk »
- Label:
- Fat Cat »
Meredith Godreau's voice is feathery, airy soft and saccharine sweet. Soothing on the ear and blissfully calming with an edge that denotes something deeper and more meaningful beneath the surface. From her opening breath there is potential here for something truly haunting and powerful and yet, much to its detriment, Moenie and Kitchi never pushes further than the realms of safety and expectation.
If I were to tell you that Gregory & The Hawk is another female vocal led acoustic folk/indie band, images would inevitably conjure in your mind, and disappointingly those images would most likely be spot on. Track after track, this is a selection of meandering guitars, touching melodies and instrumental niceties. It's pleasant enough, lovely in fact. Indeed, during songs such as 'Stone Wall, Stone Fence' it hints at something enchanting and intoxicating, but when it comes to displaying anything that sets this record apart from its myriad predecessors, it falls disappointingly flat.
Sadly, this is a record that skates over but never quite grips the dramatically beautiful and emotional, nor the edgy or inventive. In a generation where each and every one of us carries around hundreds of albums on a daily basis, that means it's also one that's destined to be forgotten.
i'm not going to forget this.
i think it deserves a better review (i say 8). but i like the nicer sounding tracks like oats we sow.
is that not tautology?
saccharine sweet
ahh
i just heard of this person so I'm hoping its better than DiS say!
thats
much better :]
5/10 is harsh for this...
I know how tempting it is to say - there's thousands of better albums than this out there - but records should be reviewed on their own terms as well. You say it's 'lovely', and you use 'touching melodies' as a negative(!). Her voice is stunning. Granted it's no earthshaker but there are some wonderful moments.
I find
the last minute of every song pretty incredible, the preceding bits pretty dull. 5/10 = harsh but fair
I disagree with the 5
some of the moments on this album stay with you. oats we sow is a track that is going to stay with me for a long time.
At least an 8!



Drowned in Manchester #15 – May 2013
armchair dancefloor 39: Mount Kimbie interview, Bobby Browser, Powell, Move D, Leon Vynehall...
DiS meets John Lydon - Part 1: The Man
DiS Does Singles 20.05.13: Paramore, Laura Marling, The Replacements
DiS joins the Music Alliance Pact + May 2013's global MAP compilation
Drowned in Bristol #12
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article