- Artists:
- PJ Harvey & John Parish »
- Manic Street Preachers »
- Grammatics »
- The Week That Was »
- Micachu »
- Patrick Wolf »
- Super Furry Animals »
- The Maccabees »
- The Phantom Band »
- Late Of The Pier »
- Emmy the Great »
- Rolo Tomassi »
As you may be aware, DiS is throwing our second alternative Mercury Music Prize.
Yesterday, the nominees were announced on DiS but before you rate the albums, we thought you might like to listen to all of them or at the very least give the ones you've not heard a cursory listen. You've got until 8th of September to vote so take your time, form your opinion and then score them out of 10. You can change your vote at any time.
Oh and remember that 0 is unlistenable, 1 is rubbish, 2 is horrible, 3 is pretty terrible, 4 is bad but not without merit, 5 is average, 6 is vaguely liked it, 7 is ok, 8 is really liked it, 9 is brilliant and 10 is perfect. I like to think of 10 as unattainable, apart from works of universally connecting, era-defining, utter genius and 9 is usually what I award my album of the year. Basically, this award isn't about comparing the records to each other, it's about rating each on it own merit. We'll soon be introducing the ability to rate all albums on the site (building charts of the best & most rated albums of the Noughties, Emo/Punk/Dubstep records and/or albums by individual artists) and we thought these 12 would be a good place to start.
The Twelve Nominated Albums (in no particular order) are as follows:
- Manic Street Preachers Journal For Plague Lovers
- Emmy the Great First Love
- Late Of The Pier Fantasy Black Channel
- The Phantom Band Checkmate Savage
- The Maccabees Wall of Arms
- Super Furry Animals Dark Days/Light Years
- Patrick Wolf The Bachelor
- PJ Harvey & John Parish A Woman A Man Walked By
- Micachu Jewellery
- The Week That Was The Week That Was
- Grammatics Grammatics
- Rolo Tomassi Hysterics
Listen: Neptune Music Prize albums
Vote Now! drownedinsound.com/neptune
- Watch the new film for Manic Street Preachers 'Nat West-Barclays-Midlands-Lloyds'
- Manics Monday: WIN! Generation Terrorists - The Legacy Edition
- Manics Monday: Why Generation Terrorists was the most important debut of the 1990s
- Manics Monday: Rain Down Alienation - Generation Terrorists’ key tracks.
- Manic Street Preachers - Generation Terrorists (20th anniversary legacy edition)
- In Photos: Manic Street Preachers @ O2 Arena, London
- In Photos: XFM Winter Wonderland @ Brixton Academy
- Manic Street Preachers at The O2 Arena, London, Sat 17 Dec
how do you rate yours?
is average the same as "ok"? i might refine the above.
i think 'impressive' is a better one for 7
8 excellent, 9 outstanding.
no you moron
outstanding is the same thing as excellent
ye see...
I want rolo to win out of this lot but in my heart of hearts after living with the album for ages I know its only a 7 really and the album just bellow that Late of the pier is only really a 5 at the most probibly more of a 4. I don't know wether to bump up my scores to hype the ones I like or do it honestly, which probibly wont help the nomanees very much at all.
My honest manuva will no doubt mean emmy, maccabees and wolf get 0 tho so it might ballance out with manics bringin up the rear with 1 or 2. Micachu deserves a good 3 just for mentioning grime sometimes and having a go at mixtapes as does PJ just for respect value for being around so long and doing good things in the past. SFA get props for inventive prolonged activity even tho I'm not fussed at all about them so they can have 4. Phantom, Gram and week might get a listen but I doubt it I sware I've heard Gramatics years ago on DTTR CD's and not been arsed about them, the rest are probibly generic indie that I've not seen mentioned or recomended by anyone ever. To be honest I might just abstain I dont like rating stuff by number anyway...

Green Man 2009 - The DiS Review
"Less of my dirty laundry & more of the things I find inspirational": Patrick Wolf on Lupercalia
The Weekly DiScussion: the best festivals EVER
Manic Street Preachers
Grammatics
armchair dancefloor 39: Mount Kimbie interview, Bobby Browser, Powell, Move D, Leon Vynehall...
DiS meets John Lydon - Part 1: The Man
DiS Does Singles 20.05.13: Paramore, Laura Marling, The Replacements
DiS joins the Music Alliance Pact + May 2013's global MAP compilation
Drowned in Bristol #12
DiS Does Singles 13.05.13: Swim Deep, These New Puritans, The National
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article