Following on from Friday’s news story about Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Efrim Manuck who was said interviewee, has asked us to post these comments / clarifications on the subject:
"the internet remains a refuge for lazy writing and diminishing conclusions-
the statements attributed to me in this 'news piece'
have been pulled out of their original context,
and pasted benath a misleading headline,
in the name of scoring some sort of bullshit 'news exclusive'.
godspeed's interminable silence will continue into the foreseeable future,
but it wasn't the iraq war that made it impossible for us to continue functioning as an active band-
a whole host of internal disagreements and external pressures contributed to us ending our long march together.
there were 9 of us in the band,
and i expect that if you asked each member to summarize the factors that led to our current hiatus,
you would get 9 different answers.
the truth is almost always both complicated and boring,
and can't be articulated via bullet points and pull-quotes,
especially in the hands of charlatans only interested in increasing their banner-ad rates by juicing their page-hit totals..."
efrim
While we are happy to offer Efrim a platform to air his views and thoughts on the subject, Drowned in Sound equally stands by the quotes and comments within the news story and does not feel they’ve been taken out of context and were a relevant matter to report. Not least given our admiration and interest in Godspeed… something that seems to be replicated by DiS users.
Hopefully, when the full interview is published later this month, all will become clear in a conversation held with Efrim on matters of A Silver Mount Zion and beyond… it was a fascinating, intelligent and engrossing chat, which hopefully you’ll enjoy too.
God, that's a bit full on
All you said was "The strongest hint yet the hiatus is permanent", which from my reading was a pretty accurate statement
Not really
The e-mail was worded in a much stronger and definite way. Besides, I imagine the problem is more that other websites (notably the NME) picked up on the story and published in very definite terms
Oooh, he's called you out.
He's seen DiS for the vile Murdoch spewing machine that it is.
Corporate fucks.
pwned.
what
an uptight a-hole. I'd expect no less from someone in a band that are so fucking boring that changing the placement of an exclamation mark in their name is the most exciting thing they've ever done.
ill bet this nme one
really pissed him off then http://www.nme.com/news/godspeed-you-black-emperor/34219 haha
thats not only bad journalism
its hideous as well.
haha
DiS jumping the gun!
he has a point really
that news article was a bit stupid. why did you feel the need to make an OMG headline out of part of the interview? why not just wait until the full interview is up and let people draw their own conclusions?
call his bluff
and put up the audio version of the interview.
lolz.
he said something similar when i interviewed him
the day previously. at no point did i take it to imply they'd split. i'd say the reaction is fairly expected, and basically justified.
i reckon
he made the statement due to nmes headline of:
Godspeed You! Black Emperor quit over Iraq
why would they reform Godspeed
when Silver Mt. Zion are continually making music far more innovative and astounding than they did at the end of GYBE incarnation?
Go Efrim!
.
I'd cry if efrim said something like that to me.
holy po-facedness!
he really needs to lighten up
ha ha
he is funny
bless
Ha
anyone reminded of:
"So, we did an interview with a liar"
anyone?
awesome
DiS get told
This.
But did he read the comments on the article? Cause we mentioned that it might have been a bit "Story out of nothing".
The NME shit was amazing though.
True, if this proves nothing else
It proves he reads DiS. Efrim, when I come to canada next year i WILL track you down and hug you.
Dis Dissed
lazy writing and diminishing conclusions
bullshit 'news exclusive'
charlatans only interested in increasing their banner-ad rates
Perhaps this website can learn from some of these (true) comments.
Pitchfork have jumped on it
http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/news/48600-godspeed-still-on-hiatus-not-completely-broken-up
seems abit over the top
the only thing I think dis did wrong was the headline,
Let me get this straight...
Pulling a shocking, out of place couple of quotes from the middle of an interview and then presenting them without context in order to make a statement that, even if there's no truth behind it, will grab readers attention isn't misquoting or an attempt to make something out of nothing now? Huh.