Sign In:
14399
Type: Single Release date: 20/02/2006
Your Rating:

The Knife refused to play live for a long time. They said it's a throwback to the old days of rock 'n' roll, and not something that belongs to the digital age in which they find themselves living. Maybe they felt that perfection is only attainable in the studio, and that live replication is a dilution of that. They are all about perfection, and purity. They don't even like doing band photographs, taking the opportunity instead to "dress up like the music"... dark, brooding, mysterious, serious and oddly comical.

The costumes for the Silent Shout shoot would be interesting. Swathes of underwater-blue velvet perhaps, hanging from their outstretched arms, eyes shining under a heavy hood... or maybe bright flashes of cityscape neon, motorway floodlights flashing by against the black midnight sky. Or even the dim glow of a lamp bulb at some Berlin house party, light falling onto the face of a lonely girl sinking into the sofa and wishing she could leave. The synth alternates between attention grabbing treble and sunken bass, the vocal cold and robotic, but intriguing and insistent. This sounds like late night, and very early morning - cold air and slow revelations.

It's not an obvious pop single like Heartbeats, their most well-known song to date (partly due to the success of Jose Gonzalez's far inferior acoustic cover version). But then, very little is obvious about The Knife. And that makes them all the more interesting.

new album

the single's great and the album is even better

I know it probably isn't anything of the sort

But I don't like this "far inferior" cover thing. Just sounds like (for want of better phrase) indie snobbery because it did well. Not that I'm saying it is.

I think the Jose Gonzalez cover is different enough that you should be able to take both versions as seperate things anyway and not have to say one is better than the other.

For some reason this song reminds me of When Doves Cry...

well said, jesus.

this song, like the album, is SO incredibly good.

as in the Prince song

But if you make a Dove cry for me then maybe it will also remind me of this song.

No snobbery.

It's just better. Jose's version is a lame dribble of a song. This one's a striking pop statue.

In fact, that criticism is retarded.

Since when is it snobbish for a critic to say one thing is better than something else?

Fuckers.

Get bent.

Loser

Wow, talk about not being able to take criticism.

Gonzalez's version isn't as good, granted, but it's still lovely, and different enough to actually warrant being made, unlike so many covers out there. The point made was a perfectly good one and didn't deserve abuse.

Give Gonzalez a break. And learn how to write an interesting review while you're at it. Insulting your readership will get you nowhere you tool

You weren't

really saying one thing is better than the other though, it seemed like you were just bringing up the Joze Gonzalez cover thing in order to slag it, which you're allowed to I guess, but it seems pretty pointless...

The Knife must already be annoyed at that cover being mentioned every time they are, so you've added to that too.

I'm just being annoying now.

I'll take criticism

I'll take it
And then
I'll make you eat it
Yeah

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon