Sign In:
3361
Type: Single Release date: 24/03/2003
Your Rating:

(Midday, somewhere in Islington)

Roddy Woomble sits up in bed, dazed and disorientated. The mental fog from the all-night peppermint tea bender he was on last night has yet to lift.

Stumbling across the flat to make a rejuvenating cuppa, Woomble treads on a copy of REM's Green album, shattering it in the process. "Nay bother", he thinks to himself, _"There's plenty more of those hanging round the flat"_

Upon slumping back in his four-poster, Roddy eyes the message **'Rodee smels of poo'** which has been viciously gouged into the headboard. Ruminating on the still-fresh split with Bob, the be-crumpled one sighs wistfully.

With another furtive moan, the frontman slips on the CD player. Seconds later, Woomble sits up bolt right as a shuddering, angular stop-start rhythm pounds out, sounding like the greatest of angry college rock anthems; ferocious yet melodic; dervishly whirling like a focused maelstrom of noise. Its a hard-bastard rocking tune. Excitingly, the next track is even better.

_"Yes! This is it!, this is the sound! This is who we are and where we want to be!"_ Roddy cries.

Ejecting the CD, Roddy peers down at the disc to see a scrawled message saying 'Biffy Clyro: Better than what you could do'.

"So, what should be mine, can never be mine," murmurs Woomble. "Yet, all the sounds in my room make room for the sound in my head."

Only stopping briefly to jot this down in a little notebook, he slumps back into bed.

Listen to this track in Real Audio: HERE

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

errr...i dont like this review. biffy clyro and idlewild are two different bands who are good at what they do, the only thing is that theyre scottish. and as idlewild happen to be my favourite band i found this quite offending. thats all..

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

come again?

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Fantastic review Gareth...

That is how we like it.

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

i really dislike biffy clyro.

awesome review though.

o
o
o
<><...
Gen

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

I think that's this reviewer's intention. He wrote a similarly nasty review of Feeder's last single.

I like both Idlewild and Biffy Clyro. I'm just a little puzzled as to why BC's song isn't given a proper description or critique here. This review is just a totally amateur attack on what is perceived to be Idlewild 'selling out'.

Gareth, can I ask?...do you have any musical talent or ability yourself? Just interested. If so, I'd love to have a listen to some of your music.

Or are you just a 'fan'? Cos, a writer you are not; unless you consider your attention seeking sixth-form style to be worthy of this pretty decent site.

a.

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Idlewild roxx u r all gay.

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Yeah Gareth, goddd, are you just a 'fan'? Cos clearly bands aim their music solely at their musical peers, dontcha know.

alan. did you ever notice how musicians tend to generally be not-all-too-good at writing reviews?

love it gareth.

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

what does "sixth-form style" mean?
I've always been intrigued
lots of people use it as derogatory but what exactly *is* 6th form?
I never did A-level English you see
So technically everything I say is so goddamn 'GCSE' it's unbelievable

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

gcse. oldskool. i like it.

o
o
o
<><...
Gen

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Never mind the review, someone's just re-issued 'Smell the glove' with the original artwork!
Fantastic

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Does this make your opinion of it of more worth than mine (it was abysmal)? Don't DIS writers have an internal email list to pat each others' backs on?

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

yes but we like to do it here as well :D

it was a well written piece. why shouldn't i say so if i think so?

just fuck off with the attitude man.. no-one's suggesting my opinion is worth more than yours so enough of the aggro.

o
o
o
<><...
Gen

Re: Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Oooh my writing is, like, genuine 6th form stuff then.

Nightmare!
KPxx

Biffy Clyro - The Ideal Height

Surely the reviewer is making the point that, before they went pussy and dropped Bob, Idlewild were in fact more of an angsty rock band rather than duller than Coldplay mellow-rock?

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon