- Artists:
- TV On The Radio »
- Label:
- 4AD »
A bombshell: as good as it undoubtedly is, this record isn't going to change your life. Nor will it be considered an OK Computer or a Velvet Underground & Nico in ten years' time. Did it ever promise to be? Some people seemed to think so, and many still might.
TV On The Radio's rapid ascent to somewhere very near mass popularity - a surprise given the often oblique nature of their cultured, soulful art-rock - means that Dear Science has become probably the most hotly anticipated LP of the year. That's all the more troublesome considering the slow-burning nature of what TV On The Radio do (or did). In mainstream terms, it isn't immediately catchy, or particularly anthemic. And 'obvious' is the last thing it is. To evaluate this release on a cursory few listens would be pure folly; even after twenty to thirty, it's tricky. But one thing appears certain: this is the album that will takes its makers to the masses, if only because everybody seems to want to have an opinion on it.
They're definitely getting easier on the ear with every release, and by TVOTR standards, Dear Science - with its frequent forays into pop, funk and soul - is almost brazenly commercial. Compare it side-by-side with their first couple of EPs, for instance. They still had those influences, no doubt, but didn't let them bleed through to the forefront quite as gloriously as this; it's undeniably pop, but pop at its most complex and technically accomplished.
It's also as brilliantly sounding a record as you'd expect from a Sitek production: crisp, almost brittle in places, but with a surprising amount of overall warmth and clarity considering the array of different instruments employed. Antibalas' horns reprise their Antidotes role; that of welcome, sparing accompaniment. It's all cunningly layered, nicely textured, ever so subtle. The sonic maelstrom you can take home to meet the parents, if you will.
Stylistically, it's also one of the most varied records you'll hear all year. Few bands break this many boundaries in a whole career, let alone a single album. One song here, 'Family Tree', could be described as a ballad. Others might belong to a new Prince record, should he continue his pursuit of a futuristic-pop direction ('Golden Age'). And with their varied means of treating and disguising the guitars, Talking Heads also provide a clear reference point. Similarly, at its most frantic, Tunde Adipimbe's rapped delivery ('DLZ', 'Dancing Choose') echoes the likes of Saul Williams.
Indeed, lyrically speaking TV On The Radio are certainly more daring than the majority of their peers. Guitarist Kyp Malone takes an increasingly prominent role in both the writing and delivery on Dear Science, and his vocal partnership with Adipimbe proves itself to be a rich and potent combination, one capable of successfully exploring a number of themes.
'Family Tree', for instance, oozes poignant heartbreak (the chorus, "In the shadow of the gallows of your family tree", proves particularly affecting); 'DLZ' is a three-minute outburst of sceptical anger ("Who's sick?/Who's next?/Never you mind/Death Professor") while closer 'Lover's Day', unsurprisingly, discusses carnal relations ("I'm gonna take you/I'm gonna shake you/I'm gonna make you cum").
The shear breadth of styles, emotions and moods here makes for a sometimes bewildering listen - from anger, passion and lust at one end to loss, regret and depression at the other, Dear Science covers an awful lot of thematic bases over the course of its eleven songs. As a result, on casual listens it can feel more like a disparate, disjointed collection of tracks than a coherent body of work. That's a tiny beef, though, when there's nary a weak track here. Overall, it's an unqualified success.
Back to that opening assertion, then, which of course rings true for 99% of albums released on the back of such an enormous wave of hype: whether Dear Science stands the test of time like classic records must is impossible to predict right now, but, at this moment in time, it's sounding like one of the albums of the year, and its makers' latest, greatest masterpiece.
- Rain Machine - Rain Machine
- Steven Wilson remix album to include work by Sitek, Dälek and Engineers
- Massive Attack reveal EP details, guest stars a-plenty
- T In The Park: The (slightly delayed) DiS review
- TV On The Radio at Central Park SummerStage, New York City, Fri 05 Jun
- TV On The Radio at Manchester Academy 2 (formerly MDH), Mon 17 Nov
- Concrete & Glass 2008: The DiS Review
- In Photos: Concrete and Glass (Friday)
More TV On The Radio
-
Concrete and Glass: the DiS preview
-
David Shrigley Gets Worried about Liars, TV On The Radio...
-
More TV On The Radio details leak
all the 9s
I've seen a few 9/10 reviews recently of albums I haven't been overwhelmed by, so I'll try not to get carried away until I've actually HEARD this...! But I do look forward to hearing it, for sure.
good one
cant really argue with that.. the second half of DLZ my favourite bit at the mo.. but like a brilliant record should - my favourite bit changes a lot!
Really
great review, well done :) I agree with 9, beautiful album.
Gave it a first spin this morning...
...and liked what I heard. Much easier to embrace than previous TVOTR records. the test of time will tell, but am looking forward to diving deeper with this one
wacko
Golden Age = Wanna Be Startin Something
which is odd
Yes.
Pure love <3
a worthy review
i'm loving this album.
For the opening track alone
it is a nine.
Nice review
I would use the same adjectives in a critique and yet I've only spun it once or twice (which include factors beyond Dear Sciene's control) so methinks it falls short of classic. It will certainly be in everybody's year-end Top 10.
Haven't
gotten or heard it yet, but I love TVOTR, and I'm hoping this album delivers. I'm sure that they bring something powerful to this release.
cracking review
this isnt as good as Return To Cookie Mountain imho. still good though.
Absolutely brilliant
Best album i've heard in a good while, totally agree with your review too, great stuff.
I hope this grows on me a bit
because on first impression it's good, but nothing in comparison with 'Return To Cookie Mountain' (although that album took 9 or 10 listens, hopefully this album is the same)
I'd heard that this album was immediate but I seems as though it might be missing a couple of catchy, upbeat tracks like 'Wolf Like Me' or 'Dirty Whirl', it's not as engaging so far.
I'm really hoping this album takes time to appreciate, the signs are encouraging but I must admit that I was expecting more from these guys.
Probably a 7/10 album at the moment, I'll give the time it deserves before reserving full judgement though.
...
That's exactly what I thought initially. For ages, this was going to be a 7. But once it clicks, boy does it click. Stick with it.
That's made me more hopeful
RTCM was a slow 'clicker' but I'd heard that this album was supossed to be more immediate, which was worrying me that I didn't think it was awesome straight away.
Yeah
I feel like the tracks themselves are quite immediate, but as a whole listening experience it took me ages to appreciate it as a record. The lyrics booklet's worth a look too.
Family Tree
If this doesnt give you goose-bumps, please consult a physician. This is the ballad bands like Coldplay aspire to create but will never come close.
family tree
sounds like stay by east 17.. truedat
Agreed with review
Definitely a 9/10 or 10/10.
8/10
not as good as 'Return To Cookie Mountain'
They've lost it!
The most disappointing album I have ever heard. They've lost their edge and opted for middle of the road tripe. Such a waste.
Two words in reply to the above poster:
Utter shite.
I like it
I didn't like return to cookie mountain much, but this one i shall listen to again :)
excellent review
Rob. I give the review a 9. Not gonna be a classic, but definitley one of the best of the year.
oh christ!
somebody had the nerve to criticize the sacred cows of the indie-scmindie brigade. what is to be done?
Its too 'safe'
I've listened to it about 15 times now. All the best albums (including Cookie Mountain) take time to reveal their hidden depths. This one is accessible straight out of the box. If it doesn't do what Neon Bible did for Arcade Fire then there is something wrong with the world. They deserve any success they get from this but, really, Dear Science isn't that good.
Sounds great in the car though and I'm sure it'll be excellent live.
7.5/10.
i haven't heard
the record yet, but the first sentence of this review says a lot to me : 'this record won't change your life'. you just don't say things like that about an album as highly anticipated as this without conveying the message that it's a disappointment, regardless of the score at the end of the review.
How good is Halfway Home?
What a great way to open the album!
Very good record
the hype was right for once!
Just picked this up
Tis good indeed.
you get used to DiS's ubiquiry of 9/10 reviews
and eventually learn to pull alot of them down a notch or two.
yep
wolf like me and dry drunk emperor absolutely clinch it. but, i'm still eager to hear this one.
Dear Science
This is the best album of the year so far. Good chance it will stay that way for the rest of 08.
is it really that amazing?
good album but their most commercial. production is almost slick here. not expecting that from this lot. its amazingly crafted though, you can tell theyve put a lot into it, and its prob their best overall 'album' in terms of covering so many moods, sounds, and in being so consistent - their past 2 albums have been a bit patchy at times -but it doesnt really keep them at the vanguard of indie rock anymore. its too obviously poppy for that. yeah it still has weird shit going on, but its much more conventional in many ways than anything else theyve done before. good songwriting, some lovely melodies, but its still not got that pop immediacy thing going on. maybe thats a good thing, but it kinda feels like theyre still not *really* a pop band, despite trying to be much more of one. i still like them but its a bit dissapointing to hear them going this route after starting off so groundbreaking with the first ep/album.
It's not a 9.
But it's a fucking good album.
I agree with Scottiek
Its really banal and uninteresting.
It sounds like the produced the tracks thinking oh this one will work in a mobile phone advert.
One track even sounds like Coldplay!
...???
Diversity is not an old wooden ship yoof.
^ it really does sound like Coldplay
even the vocals. Shocking.
Update:
It's worthy of the 9/10 it was given, more commercial yes, but when the songs are this good, it doesn't matter.
Dancing Choose, Family Tree and DLZ are my favourites at the moment.
WTF?
How can you start a review with 'This record isn't going to change your life...'? Thanks for that, I didn't expect it to, who the hell did?
It's brought a little cheer on repeated listens and brightened the corners of my recent days.
And what the hell is the talk of 'mass popularity', 'taking it's makers to the masses' and 'mainstream terms'? If one of their singles gets into the top 5, played on Radio 1 daytime or soundtracks Come Dancing then your guide-stick is strictly on fire. (Staring at the Sun was radio 1 playlist back in the day btw)
Sod trying to predict 'classics' and talk about the record. Which is ace. It ain't about their positioning in some daft canon. Maybe reviews can relate it more to their previous work a bit more and their artistic or thematic progression. Or the funny lyrics.
This is addressed to the reviewer below...
"December!? There's no such track on Young Liars, I think you may be referring to 'Blind' perhaps? Call Stephen Malkmus because I think you need a fact checkin' cuz!!!!
disappointing
not spine tingling like cookie mountain. i was hyped by this review but after repeated listenings i had to come to the realization that they failed. love this band, seen them live and they were awesome but unfortunately dear science is a let down.


TV On The Radio
In Photos: Arctic Monkeys @ Wembley Arena, London
In Photos: The Flaming Lips @ The Academy, Manchester
In Photos: Moby @ The Palace Theatre, London
In Photos: Tegan & Sara @ Shepherds Bush Empire, London
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article