- Artists:
- The Fratellis »
- Label:
- Island »
The Fratellis are Supergrass doing Chaz & Dave – perky popsters swaggering their way into the hearts of idiots whose idea of a top night out is eight Stellas and a greasy kebab, swiftly followed by either a) a scrap or b) collapsing in a pool of their own making on a stranger’s driveway. Or both. Ideally both.
Actually, scratch that opening gambit. Neither Supergrass nor the Cockney sing-along souls have ever been responsible for singles as overwhelmingly inane as ‘Mistress Mabel’, this record’s lead off-cut. It is appalling, the worst kind of revivalist Britpop shite that no band should be allowed to unleash unto the masses. How it even climbed to number 23 – disappointing for a band who’ve previously graced the top five – is beyond me. Perhaps the drunkard dullards buying the fuck out of debut LP Costello Music have wised up. Or, not. As this album is presently sitting pretty in the top five of the albums chart.
So, the time comes to analyse the hows and whys. How: ‘Chelsea Dagger’, the Scottish trio’s most ubiquitous effort to date, infecting all and sundry with its “nah nah nah”ing… or its “doo doo doo”ing. Whatever the xxxing, it’s one of those staples of daytime radio, across the board as good as, that’ll perhaps never go out of rotation. Why: because people are stupid, really really really stupid. You know this; it’s why you’re here and not reading some trash about Lily Allen’s breasts or Guns N’ Roses’ latest fart of activity… oh… but you get my point, right? There is right, and there is wrong. And so very many people heading to HMV each weekend are wrong.
Here We Stand offends, such is its banality. Frontman Jon had told DiS that little on the band’s second would sound too like its lead single, but if he truly believed that then it’s clear the man’s depth of taste, his knowledge of music in its myriad forms, is shallow beyond belief. Formula is strictly adhered to, and while pace may differ from one jolly strum-about to the next, the void where there should be a worthwhile tune remains. ‘Jesus Stole My Baby’ plods with as much purpose as an environmentalist’s best efforts to halt the melting of our icecaps; I’m sure the band mean well when they’re laying down lines about the departure of their beloved (I’m sure it’s more to do with her no longer putting out than, y’know, properly finding God, but whatever – ambiguity is rife when meaninglessness abounds), but their execution is drearily tiresome. And so it continues…
‘My Friend John’ would have my _friend John pulling teeth – he’s a broad-minded man when it comes to music, but this deathly insipid opener would destroy his opinion that everything has a place, every song deserves an audience. “This is where I’d quote a lyric conveying the song’s hideousness, but to pick one from many is just too tough.” ‘Shameless’ contains a telling line, though: “I’m so sick of hearing how your love for this has died”. Best pick up some Rennies, lads, because hopefully nobody’s quite done telling The Fratellis that they’ve flogged this horse beyond the grave. The sole saving grace of _Here We Stand is ‘Stragglers Moon’, which twinkles and chimes in an oddly proggy fashion without going all-out Kula Shaker, quite. But one track does not an album make (and it’s not that good, anyway; everything’s relative).
Stupid people will, one day, inherit the Earth. It’s happening, all around us; every day we read stories about certain institutions being dumbed down. As music moves on its merry way through history, we see devolution in effect: from Chopin to The Ting Tings, this is not progression, friends. We are witnessing that which stokes the fires in our bellies gradually turning to shit. That’s why you’re here, though, because you recognise that there are still treasures to be found. Diamonds in the dirt. And if you’re of the opinion that Here We Stand is a glittering treat for the senses?
You’re stupid, you’re wrong, and you stink of shit from wading around in it for so long. Fuck off.
From the archive
-
DiScuss: Is this News? - Yours Truly, Indie Mob
-
In Photos special: DrownedinSound UK Tour
-
DiS meets Panda Bear
I despise the fratellis....
and I need not hear a note from this album to know that it will be utter shite!
The new single did not sell so well
because it did not have a saucy picture on the poster.
I was subjected to this in Fopp the other day
I found it pretty horrible- but I don't think it was ever designed to appeal to a 26 year old who enjoys playing 'chicken' with toppling speaker stacks.
On the plus side, I can't remember any of the songs on it..
Brilliant review.
One of the greatest reads here. No idea how much it represents the album but by golly, does it sound shit!
Good review
But given the vitriol displayed throughout, I'm rather surprised that it managed to get 3...a 1 or a 2, surely?
That one song mentioned as being okay...
...probably lifts this up to a three. It's a bit weird for the Fratellis... would be interesting to see how it did if released as a single.
Totally agree
Doubtless the backlash will come and someone will point out that we're all being indie snobs but I would rather be an indie snob than someone who accepted or celebrated mediocrity.
predictable review
i don't like the fratellis and mistress mabel is a pile of tosh as, i expect, is the rest of the album, but they have made some half decent pop songs and i can tolerate them far more than any guff produced by SFG and their ilk.
I guess it's the sort of review we have come to expect from DiS, but sometimes it's nice to see a level-headed approach being applied to reviews of bands with such universal unappeal to the sort of demographic DiS appeals to, rather than pandering to it.
actually, fuck it, fratellis can suck my pole.
I'm assuming mistress mabel
is the one with the dreadful lyrics?
I can't imagine anyone/thing called Mabel not being a cow for some reason..
I'm not even gonna read this
What's the point of reviewing it? What's the point in grading it? It's shit, why give them any attention?
Haha
tru dat
I am not keen on The Fratellis
but this sort of reveiw is rubbish. A destructive veiw is always the easy way. Sad.
I'm ashamed
that I was able to identify it for you fairly swiftly.
Shouldn't have even been mentioned.
I think we can blame Jo Whiley for all this...
bit predictable
this review that is.
People who write for DiS hate The Fratellis, allowing all indie types to get together and shout "yeah! i hate them to". shock horror. surprise.
Didn't we just give them a fairly flattering feature piece...?
Yeah, we did.
But nobody cared about that. People said: this band is rubbish, fuck off.
And then there's a review that says they're rubbish, and the table turns again.
What an odd business this is.
The reviewer can fuck off...
How can someone call themselves a music reviewer when they knock out pretentious crap like this.
I really don't mind his dim view of the album as that's his opinion. But as a reviewer, he's failed, no, massively failed, in his duty to back his opinions up with any information or mention relating to the music.
A third rate hack who can just fuck off.
"How can someone call themselves a music reviewer when they knock out pretentious crap like this."
NO MUSIC REVIEWER IN HISTORY HAS EVER BEEN PRETENTIOUS
I predicted the backlash
and lo it appears below.
Call me MrNostradamusSir...
what would be an example of
'backing up his opinons with any information or mention'?
He has to produce concrete objective evidence to back up a subjective point of view? WTF? How? Why?
He doesn't like it, he's explained why - some of us agree, some of us disagree: isn't that the very essence of music reviews and all that they can ever hope to achieve.
I have read A LOT more pretentious reviews of music than this incidentally.
I don't need to explain myself...
I know what I mean, I know you know I know what I mean, and you know you're just being flippant and pedantic for the sake of it. But I see you chose to ignore the bit where I say "I really don't mind his dim view of the album as that's his opinion". Anyways, I will explain myself a bit, so here goes...
My point is that by being dissmissive, vindictive and, frankly, immature, he's trying to appear witty and clued-up, though comes across as an indier-than-thou smart-arse.
All I'm saying is that I'd rather something a bit more authoratitive and a bit less churlish. There's no need, for instance, to go on about his friend John. It adds nothing.
I'm done.
it's refreshing to see something so subjective on here
DiS does have a nice range of writers.
anyone who said that this was a predictable piece is silly, because DiS are usually rather moderate to shite albums (see - foals and Bloc Party).
Do you want a series of graphs and charts?
Or a review?
^here here!
that was a really enjoyable, humerous and entertaining review to read.
..
i guessed a 4 before clicking on it,pretty good guess
And if you’re of the opinion that Here We Stand is a glittering treat for the senses?
You’re stupid, you’re wrong, and you stink of shit from wading around in it for so long. Fuck off.
Class.
How
they're above Biffy on the Friday at Reading is beyond me.
That would
be the terrace anthem. It'll keep them in chips and gravy for the rest of their days, I reckon.
Mistress Mabel
has to be one of the worst songs I've ever heard. Sounds like some sort-of Oasis Morning Glory era sub-B side
stupid review
shooting fish in a barrel
"I don't need to explain myself, I know what I mean"
is the most epic fail in the history of internet comments
i think you missed the point of music reviewing somewhere - it's not designed to vindicate you, it's designed to be a personal reaction to the music. sorry if you don't like that
fratellis
make me cry.
Haha
"We are witnessing that which stokes the fires in our bellies gradually turning to shit."
"You’re stupid, you’re wrong, and you stink of shit from wading around in it for so long. Fuck off."
Classic. Great review.
..
i probably agree that it will be 3/10 and a bit naff, but i think its a bit ahrsh to tell thousands of people they are 'wrong' just to go into hmv, you'r being a bit closed minded, as funny as it might be, the fratellis were ok on the first album, two catchy songs, theres one on there, i cant remember what its called but its a pretty good bouncy rock track.
"this is why you are reading this" come on, i read DiS for decent opinion, not to be given a pat on the back for being 'cultured'
Your hatred
sustains me.
Unreasonable
The reviewer obviously went to write this review with the intent of totally dismissing the Fratellis and their fans, I don't think it would have mattered how good or bad the album was. The Fratellis were never trying to be innovative or break new ground. They just want to make some good rock n roll tunes that people can sing and dance along to and I applaud them for that. How fucking dare this guy call anyone stupid and wrong for listening to this album. Disgusting way to finish a review.
This is a review? Seems more like a rant
This "review" is less of a review and more of a hate post. This isn't a review at all, reviews are supposed to be done from a neutral point of view, it's perfectly clear to me that you've just gone into this with a hugely dismissive attitude, your references to the "stupid people" who bought the first album make this obvious, if mentioning previous albums it should be to compare rather than to criticise it and those that bought it.
Now while I agree that album isn't the best album I've ever heard, I thought the first album was great to listen to when you need a bit of a pick up.
The last thing I wanted to mention was in reference to your apparent loathing of all Fratellis fans, now I won't lower myself to your level and resort to swearing or name calling because I, unlike you clearly have the vocabulary to put together a structured argument without the need to revert to this. You're seem one of these indie snobs who couldn't care less about anyone elses opinion and, were it up to you, the only music existant in this world would be the kind of music you like, bit fascist in my view and very small minded.
. . .
"reviews are supposed to be done from a neutral point of view"
You're new to music criticism, right?
Nope
Just an idealist, for my sins :(
fucking brilliant
that is all
"i don't need to explain myself"
oh, irony


Search on Spotify
Various - Radio 1's Live Lounge: 2
The Fratellis - Creeping Up The Backstairs
The Horrors, The Maccabees, The Fratellis, The Dykeenies at Trent University, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, Fri 20 Oct
DiS' Guide to Musicians on Twitter
St Vincent - Actor
Primavera 2009: DiS's highlights
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
In Photos: Glastonbury 2009 - Day 1
Artist 'n' Artist: Catherine AD meets Tori Amos
Glastonbury In Photos: Jarvis Cocker
Glastonbury In Photos: Neil Young
Glastonbury In Photos: Bloc Party
Glastonbury In Photos: Bat For Lashes
Comments (46)
- Post a new comment on this article