- Artists:
- Caribou »
- Label:
- City Slang Records »
Dan Snaith is an aesthete. A tireless one, by the sounds of his Andorra. Each track on the follow-up proper to 2005’s _The Milk of Human Kindness is layered into perfection; piece by piece, blip by blip. Some of its contingent parts sound organic, some electronic; some I couldn’t bet either way, not that it really matters here. The result is a record that drips with colour but remains light to the touch, compacting ten summers and then airily wiling each one away in hangovers that dissipate over a couple of dozy hours. What's interesting about this collection of songs, the tension in its placid breaks, is evident from the first minute, though the opening track - 'Melody Day' - plays it so cool it acts as something of a distraction.
The Eternal Crux, then - the t'ing and t'ang that keep a record frict and make it interesting. ‘Dozy’, ‘hungover’ - not words you would tend to associate with a "tireless aesthete". You get the feeling that Dan Snaith put a ton of work into making Andorra sound so natural and easy. Melody and noise; ease and toil; rhythm and blues - of which there are plenty here - are all dichotomies understood and put to work by Snaith as he endeavours to hold the unbridled attention of your ears.
Being endeavours, they don't always come off. Back to that first song. The album's lead single is an avatar in mood, (if not in form), for a long-player that would specialise in pop if only it didn't seem to find it so very easy. A breezy panacea for last night’s sweatbox comedown; 'Melody Day' is full of glacial, Jolly Rancher colour and flourishes of sound that blow fresh air in your ears. It's direct and it's rampant, but it's possession of these qualities that places the remainder of the album in stark contrast to itself.
So slick is the production and so smooth is the transition from one moment to the next that Andorra suffers from an apparent reluctance to take us by the scruff of the neck and rattle us out of our mental Laconia. Comparable bands - Autolux, Four Volts - know when to throw in a jarrer to burst your pop bubble. Snaith's mastery of his craft betrays the effort that goes into his work - you struggle to detect any joins and all the cracks have been completely sanded over. Soft and undefined, the record opens up and stretches away around you in all directions, creating a vast expanse of sound that will prove impossible to chart completely. So ears tend to give up, or at least give it half heart. Golden hooks and melodies are lost in the distance that builds between music and listener.
Still, give it the time of day and you'll plunder all sorts. 'Sandy' starts off sultry and seductive and carries on that way; Snaith is the explorer discovering all manner of things shivery and wide-browed. "Sometimes in her eyes I see forever, I can’t believe what we’ve found," he reckons, in front of swooing harps and back-arched psychedelica. 'After Hours'_ and 'She's the One' run along similar, if increasingly darker lines; the latter rescuing the former from its listless meandering with a down vocal cameo from Junior Boy Jeremy Greenspan. Caribou tries to anchor the album in the empathy and security of introspective, 'relationship' lyrics, which works for a while 'til the music gets the better of words and songs float off into the up, like dandelion parachutes untethered by puny wind.
It's that ease that proves to be Andorra's biggest failing. If the record's creator can be so easily distracted from the task at hand, what's to stop the listener from following in his footfall? When the music tries to come back to the path it was treading it finds nothing but covered prints. So, it finds nothing. Which is fine if you don't particularly care to be reminded of the last half an hour - on that sweatbox hangover, for example. But, if like me, you wouldn't mind carrying such well-built songs along the road with you, I fear you'll just find yourself disorientated by the sheer, intangible release of it all. I can't work out if Caribou is lost in self-importance or modesty - either way, Mr. Snaith, you've spoiled us here.
From the archive
-
If Santa strapped on a Flying V...
-
Real-Life Processes: ¡Forward, Russia! on the making of their new LP
-
T In The Park Diary Part 2: Sunday 13 July
i like big words too
..what state of mind were you in when you sat down to listen to this?
Andorra seems to literally radiate summer warmth, and you can't beat Snaith's soaring melodies..
even the more subtle songs like 'desiree' or 'irene' have these beautiful memorable hooks that you can get lost in all season..
Then there's the songs that we'll all be listening to for years like 'she's the one' 'melody day' 'niobe'
Basically what i am saying is, what's your freakin' problem?
interesting review
maybe a bit too much gravy and not enough meat, but interesting nonetheless.
As a fan of his last 2 albums (Up In Flames in particular) i still hold out hope that this one could be special, and despite the average score i find your description pretty enticing. But i may wait for some more reviews before i put any cash forward
sorry,
it just sounds like you've been cooped up in a government building or call center for weeks and you desperately need a vacation
could someone summarise this review?
I keep trying to read it but find myself thinking about something else. Kittens mostly.
Are you hearing the same album as me?
This is easily a 9/10.
I was soooo excited by this album
it left me feeling a bit dissapointed... dunno maybe needs a few more listens but nothing held me really...
from what i've heard
it sounds more like 'start breaking my heart'.
which is good.
I loved it from the first listen
Great album, only let down in places by some poor lyrics. One of my fav albums of the year so far though
I don't usually bother
getting embroiled in this, but hearing these songs shuffled in with the rest of my iTunes today, I can see why you'd disagree with this review.
Taken on their own, the songs are great - summery, breezy all of those Beach Boys adjectives.
But when you listen to it as a whole, the album's weaker - it's so placid in places, and it's top-heavy so after 'Melody Day' and 'She's the One' it seems to wither away like a decrepit Beadle-arm.
Also, the fact that it's so tirelessly constructed rankles - because the record is so smooth and ultimately a lot of that work seems pointless. I suppose there's a weight of introspective self-indulgence that I'm trying to dispel. Modern-flower-prog. It needs more bite.
i don't quite understand
this review either...is this a 6 because snaith knowingly suffered through the album process (or that is what his record label would like us to portray him as, a romantic, struggling artist) and the suffering isn't well apparent enough in the execution? i know snaith wanted to make a no-fuss retro-pop album, and it's lovely and all...but does this kev think this is all a superficial act...?
this album is fucking great
I cant turn it off
what?!
6!?!
I give this CD at least an 8, and thats just for the haunting 'Irene'. This CD is definatly worth another listen and then you'll want to tack on a few more points. Its fantastic.
10/10
my favourite album of the year. I hope he progresses with more of the Irene/Niobe route on the next record. I love the 60's pop, but those two tracks are nigh on perfect. just found out he's playing leeds on saturday so must make the trip up....


Search on Spotify
Caribou - She's The One
Caribou - Melody Day
Caribou - The Milk Of Human Kindness
DiS' Guide to Musicians on Twitter
St Vincent - Actor
Primavera 2009: DiS's highlights
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
In Photos: Glastonbury 2009 - Day 1
Artist 'n' Artist: Catherine AD meets Tori Amos
Glastonbury In Photos: Jarvis Cocker
Glastonbury In Photos: Neil Young
Glastonbury In Photos: Bloc Party
Glastonbury In Photos: Bat For Lashes
Comments (13)
- Post a new comment on this article