Sign In:
Login with Facebook
51806

First Listen: Arctic Monkeys Humbug



Ahead of its release, DiS got a first listen to the forthcoming Arctic Monkeys' album Humbug, co-produced by Queens of the Stone Age's Josh Homme and James Ford.

'My Propeller'

A sparse calm before the drums. A half-whispered "If you can summon the strength..." and we're off into the shadowland of Desert Sessions and the soaring bruised-rock of PJ Harvey's Rid of Me. It sounds a tiny bit like Rated R without the bombast of 'Crying Lightning', speaking of which...

'Crying Lightning'

Having listened to this via their MySpace a few times, I still can't decide whether Alex has become a lazy parody of himself (with lyrics about pick'n'mix and doodled imagery) or whether he makes his northern-mannered pub-poetry seem so effortless and so natural that it comes across a bit fake. Still, whilst some may say it sounds like a departure, these people should probably go back and listen to 'If You Were There, Beware' as it's pretty much the same track just with bigger bollocks and a better melody.

'Dangerous Animals'

This one has the same groove as 'Old Yellow Bricks' and isn't unlike that sloppy/choppy/jagged-sea feeling of much of Songs for the Deaf, with odd little drum breaks that click-clack just when you don't expect it. The bass-line which drives the track sounds thickened like double cream and has a Muse-ish pixelated quality to it that they nicked off of Millionaire/dEUS. Some great tumbling parts can be found dangling beneath this one and cranking it up only makes it seem better. Builds and builds into giant storm trooper riffs. 'Dangerous Animals' also features some of the best lyrics on the album like "I'm pinned down by the dark..." and "D.A.N.G.ER.OUS! ...so let's make a mess, lionness!"

'Secret Door'

And then the earth (the rock) falls out from beneath you and Alex is all megaphone-compressed and whispery for 20 seconds before the skittering drums 'n' bass tumble in on a breezy Beatlesy guitar line. Twiddly guitars, the word "indignant" and that ghost house feel of Favourite Worst Nightmare descends. It builds and builds 'til that clown-faced fairground feeling pinches the cheeks of the mardy "fools on parade" refrain.

'Potion Approaching'

Juddering sums up this one. There are some semi-biographical lyrics about the malnourished and then, halfway through, in comes that ominous Josh Homme trademark of Thor-like backing vocals racing across the track like thunderclouds. The song then breaks down into some kind of bashed-up 70s glam groove, complete with kettle-steam ooh-woo-ooh's.

'Fire and the Thud'

Pace drops, the tambourine shakes, the ghosts keep hovering (feels a touch more like the ghosts of cowboys on this one, than the ghosts of indie-pop past) and Alex does his sweet wide-eyed kitten-y cute vocal part. It gradually builds and builds until a telecaster bursts in. And it ends with things slo-moing to a vinyl-being-stopped whirr.

'Cornerstone'

This sounds really out of place, like some kind of acoustic jangle-pop. Not quite 'Be Here Now' wrongness but certainly has a whiff of will-skip-this-one-forever-more to it. Has none of the album's lingering guitars but will probably be the big radio hit around Christmas.

'Dance Little Liar'

The skeletal slightness is back. This, like a lot of the album before it, sounds like a swamp-side sing-song (picture that scene where Nick Cave is cradling Kylie on 'Where the Wild Roses Grow' then imagine a band crashing in as the song ends). The whole record has either blustery bullets of hail or, like this one, an early morning mist to it, which is odd when you think how dry the Death Valley desert is where they recorded it - I guess you can't take the dank British weather out of a band so steeped in it and they'd be nothing without their geographic anchor. Again, this one gradually builds with quivering guitars and then ends with a drum solo fade out.

'Pretty Visitors'

A church organ... then BOOM! A riff high on meth, drums rolling like a runaway train: this is exactly what I expected Homme to do with them. Huge moments make way for quiet organ moments so they can slap you around the head with a gigantic riff and lyrics like "what came first the chicken or the dickhead?" Speeds up at times like Descendants or Pennywise and slows to a Kyuss-like groove.

'The Jewellers' Hand'

Did they head to Vegas? "At the foot of a house of cards, you thought you'd never get obsessed," maybe. Yet more Doors-like sinister balladry, darkened slight grooves, ricocheting drums... This one's like a giant fade out, it's less of a whimper and more of an inky full stop running in the rain. And then, no sooner has it started, it's all over?!

 

Conclusion: Probably not the album your average Oasis fan would want them to make (they won't find it unlistenable, it's no Liars-like ear-fuck). Possibly not the classic rock album that will assure them an Iron Maiden like future. Definitely an interesting clusterfuck of textures, ideas, time changes and production suss, topped off with Mr. Turner's lyrical dexterity. The whole record ('cept 'Cornerstone') inhabits a haunting, misty, murky swamp land but it's hardly some brash metal record that the Black Sabbath mentions in interviews hinted at or a meddling Josh Homme could easily have attempted to turn it into.

Humbug sounds resolutely head and shoulders above most indie-rock records released this year and is certainly the sound of a band doing as they please, to please themselves and if the fans like it too, that's a bonus. There's no track that instantly stands out like '505' (easily one of the best songs written this decade!) but it's certainly a brave step forwards from a genuinely special band. 9/10.

Humbug is released on August 24th 2009 via Domino Records.

...and James Ford.

innit.

I'm excited

I'm really looking forward to this

Sounds special

Pretty Visitors

is immense. Up there with their finest works to date, for sure.

Potion Approaching and Pretty Visitors are the best tracks on the album

But I'm sad that there's no incredible stand out tracks like 'Do Me A Favour' and '505'.

Still, pretty happy with it on the whole. Just don't expect it to blow your mind.

cornerstone

is great. You've got that all wrong there sir.

There are some great moments, and it is nice to watch this band get darker and weirder with each album, but it all feels a bit samey. That said, Secret Door is one of the best things they've done.

scored waaayyyy too high

you've got the cornerstone part wrong. It was the first song on the album to stand out to me. It really made me pay attention to the music unlike the rest of the album which had me fading in and out with my interest.

My Propeller seems to be the radio hit in my eyes because of the sing along style chorus. Secret Doors seemed to remind me of an attempt to write a song in their old style with a speedy verse and and a slowdown entering the chorus.

i agree

cornerstone is a sweet, sweet song, and the album does so often just fade in and out of my attention, thus rated a little too high. i do find myself taking a little longer to 'get into' the monkeys newer stuff (Favourite Worst Nightmare included) rather than the instant body rockability that there first album presented.

this song is better than the whole last album

i didn't get all the buzz from the last album. but this song is pretty solid.

better than the first two

but still his vocals are too high in the mix (lyrics aren't as clever as he and other seem to think they are and his voice isnt particularly interesting or strong) and the music's still a bit too pedestrian. this is my opinion.

i was literally doing on this on first listen

sounds like it might grow on me.

I know it'll be a grower, but its no FWN

I do like the album, but for me it doesn't really have any stand-out tracks, its kind of best played as a 'whole'.

And I'm not a big fan of 'Cornerstone' (though I have a feeling it will be a hit if they release it as a single)

As for Turner's lyrics, he does have some good ones in there, but also a good few that I'm not so sure about...yes I understand the metaphorical meanings of his his sweet-shop imagery and such, I just don't think it really works. I think perhaps all the acclaim he has previously received has made him write lyrics more self-consciously than he would have done before. They sometimes sound a little artificial and forced, as if he's desperately trying to live up to the 'poet' label placed on him by the media?

Drowned in Sound Reviews

If "Humbug sounds resolutely head and shoulders above most indie-rock records released this year", then why does it only manage a paltry 9/10 when many of the other recent reviews here have managed 8/10 (The Longcut, Manhattan Love Suicides, Patrick Kelleher etc etc).

In fact, I reckon I could fart on CD and DIS would give it an 8/10 review (as long as I don't release it under the name Frankmusik).

two reasons

1) our reviews are the opinions of individual writers (not some drownedinsound consensus opinion)

2) I refuse to give anything a 10, apart from maybe The National 'The Boxer', The Shins or anything that I know I'll still be listening to in 20 years time that is utterly era-defining. Least of all gonna say something is a 10 based on 1 listen.

This is the only positive thing I have read about this...

From the first playback stream on the website. The single is pretty bad and I didn't mindtheir last two.

agreed that it's no FWN

which is a shame. still, tracks like secret door, my propeller, cornerstone, the jeweller's hands etc are instant keepers. secret door especially.

also, you have to think, turner has produced and promoted one album per year for the last 4. that's a pretty high level of quality output which, despite the 'hype', people don't give him enough credit for.

!!!

Different writers who review for the same publication MAY HAVE VARYING OPINIONS ON MUSIC!!!!!!

This is a corker...

I never got into the last release but this has had me hooked from the start.

The chicken/dickehad line always raises a smirk.

Agree with AlwaystheSea about Cornerstone

Although I agree it doesn't really fit I think it stands head and shoulders above every other song. It's certainly the best and most interesting lyrically.
I still can't decide on much of the rest of the album. It sounds like distant thunder and building clouds for a storm that never actually hits. The lyrics are much more abstract and I always felt Turners lyrical strength was the realism of them.
That said it's a brilliant album compared to those from the other 'bands' that make the on radio 1 playlist. I've only had about 5 listens, maybe it a grower....

with long hair..

The non singing guitarist has turned into samwise gamgee. Really.

Oh...

That's clearly where I've been going wrong all these years :-( I thought we were all supposed to get along and like the same stuff.

9 is a very high score on first listen...

...I was pretty underwhelmed on first listen TBH, perhaps a rush of blood to the head Sean?

It is definitely a record that improves on subsequent listens, but its not the classic it looked like being on paper.

On first listen the complete change of pace caught me out, they sound much more, well, sedate- gone is youthful excuberance, kinetic energy, this has been replaced with a kind of don't give a fuck steady plod. I guess Rolling Stone would describe this as a mature rock record...

The QOTSA influences really are as obvious and numerous as promised. This is both a blessing and a curse- the mix is bass heavy, driving bass lines and thudding drums with eerie guitar sounds and licks, which sounds great. However, for all the cool moments on the album they have inherited one of QOTSAs frequent shortcomings, they forget to bring the tunes, which makes the listening unmemorable.

Of course the test of time will tell whether I'll be eating my words. After 3 full listens I'm saying "that difficult 3rd album"- 50% of the album is pretty good, 50% of the album is dull - albeit even a dull Monkeys is better than most.

The best british rock record released this year is Future of the Left by a shitting mile, this I'm afraid doesn't even come close - 6/10

This cubed

Especially the bit about FOTL. You can do all my talking for me from now onwards if you want Alistair.

Thanks

..I did that once for a guy called Tony...it didn't end so well. For your own sake, I'll have to pass :-)

And FOTL didn't even need the help of a superstar producer...legends

This gets plus points for attempting something different.

But minus points for being dull and muso. They sound like they've had all the fun sucked out of them and they've been reduced to a one-paced plod. Shame. God save us from 'serious' musicians.

I really thought this album was

..one the most boring albums I've ever heard.

Every song snoozes along at the same pace. Potion Approaching and Fire and the Thud are deathly dull. I think I'm supposed to be enamoured with Cornerstone but I couldn't care less because I find Alex's voice kind of irritating. Pretty Visitors is finally upbeat, 8 songs too late, but Arctic Monkeys do a lot of good b sides and this sounds like one, in a way. That was my first thought when I heard it. The last track...I can't remember it. I've listened to the album in earphones about 3 times, and lying in bed in darkness, so..no distractions. I ended up falling asleep, which is a miracle. And twice out loud. Potion Approaching has this guitar twang sound that sounds very Queens of the Stone Age but I thought what their songs have is intensity and power. This has..neither. Every song just ambles along.

The law of diminishing returns really does apply to these guys

One listen of this album - I never want to hear it again. Every song is slow, plodding and totally lifeless. Where is the spark/excitement from those demos?

a fair summation

and totally agree its a change of direction they needed. I hope to continue to plough this furrow, I think it can bear richer fruit for them down the line. They've certainly not held back in committing to the new direction, and as this post is already showing opinion is very divided!

BTW Mike- how many listens did it take you to come up with that? Definitely a grower, took at least 5 listens before the album sat properly for me......still stand by my FOTL comment though :-)

QOTSA is obvious, i agree, but it's not a rip off, the songs and lyrics are still original. Good album 8-9 easily.

turner's vocal delivery on pretty visitors is incredible

he hits every note and at such a blistering pace akin to a very accomplished rapper.

i love that lyric about how they "came and waved their arms and cast the shadow of a snake pit". really quite brilliant.

they should stop writing tracks with "dangerous" in the title as they are usually the weak link.

i wasn't keen

on crying lightening to begin with, but after about 5 listens it grew on me. to be fair though, for one of the 'greatest bands of the noughties', it shouldn't take 5 listens to get into their first single off a new album. plus alex, and the lead guitarist look like the long lost brothers from the kings of leon.

SHIIIIIIIIIITTE

Drowned in Sound are the biggest squares in the industry. Enough Said. Be Here Now was the same, the reviews were all licking out of their arse for ages, when they actually listened to it they all realised it wasn't as great as they made out( could of been great if done properly). this albums shocking. i got all hot and bothered when they said they took influence from cream n hendrix. sounds like they took influence from something in the toilet and tried to recreate shit in music form. boring, twat haircuts playing twat music. its like a castrated kasabian trying to be cream. just signed up to say that, now, how do I cancel my membership.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon