- Artists:
- Franz Ferdinand »
- Label:
- Domino Records »
Dear Franz Ferdinand,
I recently came by your latest single, 'Do You Want To', in my mail. Initially I was shocked - who would have thought you'd want _me_ to have a sneak preview of your forthcoming second album to call my own? - but after a clutch of listens my mood has shifted from one of optimism to something rather less savoury.
Please, give me back the three minutes and thirty-eight seconds I spent listening to the aforementioned. I'll forego the repeat encounters.
I understand you have an audience to placate, really I do - throughout school I would always stick to the straight and narrow path of behavioural mediocrity to satisfy my parents' desire for me to at least achieve something - but this is nonsense, isn't it? Really, Franz Ferdinand, all you've done is taken half an idea and flogged it out 'til you reached a radio-friendly length. Said idea isn't even that great - 'Take Me Out' this most certainly isn't - and the least you could do is pronounce "want to" properly. It comprises fifty per cent of your song's title, you know.
Again, I do understand your need to have someone love you - indeed, you stress it with your very first line - but this isn't the right way to go about things. It's beyond simple laziness: this is hackneyed to the point where people will actively stop wanting to love you. No longer will they come and dance with you, Michael.
I know I have fallen out of love, and I am sure I am not alone. I would return this abomination to the point of purchase if I had attained it through such channels; as I have not, I will consign it to the top shelf alongside other, now dusty, disappointments. See: most of the bands you were meant to be a superior take on.
Yours with an unsettling queasiness,
MD
- T In The Park: The (slightly delayed) DiS review
- Hove Festival 2009: DiS' highlights
- This Week's Singles: 06/07/2009
- This Week's Singles: 06/04/09
- In Photos: Franz Ferdinand @ Manchester Academy
- Franz Ferdinand - Tonight
- This Week's Singles by The Lipster: 19/01/09
- "It's not a concept record, don't worry" - Franz Ferdinand talk Tonight:
More Franz Ferdinand
-
The Weekly DiScussion: the movie soundtracks that matter
-
"It's not a concept record, don't worry" - Franz Ferdinand talk Tonight:
-
The Royal We: album, shows, futures
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
I think this is pretty piss poor. It sounds strangely wierd, as if its off some kids TV show for the under tens. They have become something of a pastiche of themselves.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
It seems we put these people on pedestals, only to knock them off!
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
To put in context, I'm somebody who likes the first album but didn't expect the follow-up to be any more than a poorer rehash of the debut.
I've not heard the album but I am actually enthused by the quality of "Do You Want To?"
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
never really liked them much anyway, but I did like one song on the album - This Boy.
Uhm.. that was it really.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Yup, a dirty stinkin' one, too.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
We don't do backlash, they don't work so well with our back slashes.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Can't wait for the album now!
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
surely only mock surprise can be seen now?
nobody's dumb enough to actually be surprised by anything any more
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
And I like the song...a bit.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
But it does not.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
You talk about them taking a different 'radio friendly' path of writing songs... but all the tracks on the debut were possible singles (except 40').
Plus, do you not thing a fan of the band maybe should have reviewed it? You obviously dislike Franz, so people who want to know what other people think about it are just gonna find someone who dislikes the band, slagging the song off.
'No longer will they come and dance with you Michael.'
Come on! That's NME ammo.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
"You talk about them taking a different 'radio friendly' path of writing songs"
No I didn't. I just said that they've stretched a single idea over three-and-something minutes, thus making it radio friendly. No comment was passed on previous potential radio smashes. (As I agree: much of the first record was suitably FM friendly.)
"do you not thing a fan of the band maybe should have reviewed it?"
I like the first record, and the singles from it (okay, 'Darts Of Pleasure' is a bit shit). This, though, is just poor. Really.
"Come on! That's NME ammo."
This I don't get - are we shooting at a magazine?
Yours,
MD
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Whether or not this is a good thing given the context, I'm not sure
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
But seriously, the Franz backlash has kicked in all over the place in earnest hasn't it? I'm not referring to this review - he didn't like it, fair enough - but suddenly I keep reading that they're too cynical... calculated... 'planned'... mechanic.
What? It's pop music. Get over it.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
BUT
i reeeeally like this single. it's dumb and ridiculous, but great fun.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
I really don't think it's a case of 'Franz backlash time', I just think they've released a geniunely terrible record...They've taken their ''Pop'' infatuation/experiment a step too far and have made cheesy slab of indie-agadoo.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
i bet they've read 'the manual'.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
anyway moving swiftly on the single is pretty rubbish but the video is rather mega if a little unnerving x
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Also they have been dreadfull on all thier 'live' tv appearences - esp jonathan ross.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Maria x
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
The Rasmus' awful 'In The Shadows' gets stuck in my head, but as a piece of music it's shit.
Girls Aloud's take on 'Jump' got caught up in my head a while back, but that, too, is far from worthy of critical praise.
'Toxic' is something of an anomoly.
This is catchy, sure, but so's flu. It may stick in the head, granted, but so do kitchen knives if you stab them into your temple enough times.
Repetition breeds this addiction; if you heard it only two or three times you'd say it was shite.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
However, for me, this song is quite simply good 'pop' music, no more, no less. Chances are I'll get sick of it before too long, like with the Kaiser Chiefs, but at the moment, I love it. Like I said, it makes me smile and feel like dancing, which is more than likely the effect Franz Ferdinand were hoping to have on people.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
pretty standard but by no means awful Franny Pudding.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Jesus: "Don't ask me, man, I'm dead."
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz fans are idiots. It's official.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
This is okay. It's not great. Student dacefloor filler. Which is fine by me, because I'll only be hearing it when I've had FAR too many voddy red bulls.
Just a crosshair :(
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
You're right!
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz fans are idiots. It's official."
So what the fuck shall we all listen to, O fantastic one???
Mxx
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
But i like this song : dumb and fun.
It sure ain't no art, but it makes me smile. Which is what FF usually do to me.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
This is a great pop song which won't change your life, stop being an indy snob and slagging them off just because they've been embraced by the mainstream.
That said; you do have a point by saying that it's just one killer hook repeated, with some other less-good bits to make it a song. But it's a killer hook, and this is a dance-pop record, so get used to it. It's not my bag either, really, but I can admire it for what it is and it's bloody catchy. Remember "Take Me Out" was really just "der der da-der der derr" so it doesn't make any difference if this is just "doo doo doooo do do do doo-doo".
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
I was so looking forward to the new album but after hearing this, I'm not sure I am any more
Very disappointing
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
However, this single is utter, utter shite. It doesn't really have anything to GRAB me, it's just...well, not as good as previous things they've done. It's a shame.
Oh, and people: keep using the word 'cunt' please. It's a brilliant word and doesn't get used enough. You cunts.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
wrong.
i don't like it because it sounds like a lazy band taking the piss. let's face it, they've been pretty popular for quite a while, it didn't stop me thinking Matinee and Michael were 'okay'.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Yup.
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Sounds like a strange animal...
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
'Walk Away' is the plushest thing ever though. Ever.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
maybe mike diver wasnt the right person to review it. he quite clearly dislikes anything that sells more then a few hundred copies. he probably thinks he's being original by slaughtering this song
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Don't be stupid.
I love music that's made with love, with care and passion.
I loathe the lazy and dull, the uninspired and the bland.
This = lazy and dull, uninspired and bland.
Most of the albums I own have sold more than a few hundred copies.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
As for the single..it's OK, preferred the first stuff but was never mad keen. meh, as they say on t'internet
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Also had a naughty listen of the new album and personally I reckon it's better than the first album - The Fallen is quite possibly the greatest thing they've put their name to thus far...
That is all
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Outside Million Dead on Thursday I got given a condom in a card "DO YOU WANT TO" cover. Props to the Franz for the safe sex.
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
the album itself is also interesting (again not entirely sure if i like it or not yet) and i think it might not be as easily accessible for the swathes of fans that tuned into the first album... i dunno. time will tell.
i do really agree with Parsefone - i have issues with some music fans - goths and barries are stereotypes i generally dislike. However i am quite a big indie fan and the people that piss me off the most tend to be the stereotypical 'indie kids' because as Parsefone says, there seems to be some kind of musical fascism bred into them. I despise that.
and also, Relaxer, dont be such a tit. If you want to know why people have such a generally bad view of america (which it doesnt deserve) its because of people like yourself. It may not have occured to you, but Franz Ferdinand do have a British fanbase who have posted here that they like the song. and if we were all american, then Franz wouldnt have had a country to break the big time in would they.
when did it stop being about the music man?!
Re: Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
Franz Ferdinand - Do You Want To
I liked the first album. I'll probably buy this album but I hope the other songs steer clear of this abomination.


Franz Ferdinand
In Photos: Arctic Monkeys @ Wembley Arena, London
In Photos: The Flaming Lips @ The Academy, Manchester
In Photos: Moby @ The Palace Theatre, London
In Photos: Tegan & Sara @ Shepherds Bush Empire, London
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article