Sign In:
50173
Type: Single Release date: 24/09/2001
Your Rating:

As far as Kelly Jones is concerned, it's all about the song writing. I read this interview he did in the NME a few months ago where he bemoaned the state of British song writing, and demanded that people got back to "proper" song writing and forgot about this stupid Dance music. "Proper" song writing Kelly? What, like this?

For a man who constantly swipes at manufactured bands, this is a pretty manufactured song. So predictable, so formulaic, so dull. It just frustrates me that Jones seems to think that "proper" song writing constitutes boring acoustic strumming, cod-philosophical lyrics, and a nice bit of harmonica at the end.

I'd like to know what we're all about"?? Wow, Kell!! Questioning our existence!! What a good, original idea!! "Will I get old and die, with someone"?? Yeah, cos you're an unattractive, poor bastard aren't you Kelly!! You're certain to die alone!! In your mansion.

This is first and foremost a tired record. Kelly Jones currently seems to be going through the motions, and trying to pass it off with some kind of 'authenticity' tag to it.

Why don't you tell it like it really is?? you ask, Kelly. What, that you're a horrible, backward-looking, no ideas band who think that all music made after 1974 is poo?? Right.

Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Hey Joe.. where you going with that gun in your hand? Off to shoot Mr. Jones obviously....

Sorry, it had to be said.. I'm feeling silly (for a change).

Coming froma Starsailor fan I could balk at that review but for some reason I found it rather amusing.. Joe 'straight shooter' Wisbey... nice one matey!

Al

Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

ohhhhh please stop it. you review almost exactly the same stuff all the time. middle of the road guitar songs. manics, starsailor, embrace, stereophonics, goldrush. please, please review something different, you getting too predictable that you can tell its your review before you've seen your name at the bottom.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Um... but he slagged them off?

Slagging off middle of the road guitar bands if fine by me... hehe

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

if he likes that music and it's what he listens to why not??

Can't review the latest thrash metal 3 piece from detroit if that genre doesn't interest him cos it wouldn't be a far review.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

But reviewing the same genre over and over must get boring for yourself... branch out a little, let the next 'Indie' release go to someone else and show a differing view on a specific genre.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

i don't see any harm in reviewing similar sorts of stuff and sticking to it. i'd disagree if the reviews the guy is doing were shit but they're actually a good read and very well written so i don't have much of a problem. its a bit pointless an out-an-out indie kid reviewing the latest underground d'n'b record is it?

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

but if you review a metal band that's not a fair review cos you're clearly biased in favour. where did this idea that you're only capable of writing about stuff you like come from ? nothing would make the site as boring ..... the people who are genre-specific should claim a few unknown freebies from Sean ....

Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Oh, Joe Wisbey,
Who forgot his chill pill this morning?. If you dislike Kelly Jones that much why did you lower yourself to write about him?
I'd be the first to agree that this may not be their best album, but you cannot call it unoriginal. You also can't say that every song sounded the same (as you find with many "modern" bands)
Would you be able to sit down and pen an intro riff like that? If you could maybe you'd be on stage somewhere rather than slagging off bands that have touched peoples lives by being different. Hey! If you don't like, Don't listen to it. Hope that you calm down soon and find a less pesamistic attitude.
Best regards Paul.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Paul could not be more correct!
Calm the hell down reviewer-the album can be a bit poor in some places but at least its diverse and different. Maybe you should be thankful that at least you live somewhere where there is music such as this and more than a handful of people have heard of the band and have seen them play live. You'd be moaning you're arse off if you had to review most NZ music.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Are you people fucking insane. "Original", "different"???! Pwahahahahahahahahahahaha.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Is that the best response you can offer?
What are your thoughts on originality and being different then?

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Even the mightily dull, insipid, ripoff merchants Radiohead are more original and different than the Stereophonics.

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Who do Radiohead sound like? Others may try and reproduce their sound but as a band they've been doing their own thing for quite some time now.
What is 'original' now anyway? Of course you can say that the Sterophoncis can be lumped into a music type but don't the lyrics matter as well?
Have a listen to Mr Writer and ponder the meaning...

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

meh, stereophonics have had there day.they may be at their money making peak now (for what reason i don't know) but they were at there musical peak during 'word gets around.'
and radiohead are still going strong! i don't know how anyone could call them rip off merchants as with every album they have changed. not only have they changed but they've also bought out stuff thats completely different to what everyone else is doing.at least theyre not so obviously in it for the money, unlike the phonics who have realised what their fans want, so will sell out to give it to them. this will get rid of the phonics quicker than anything else 'cus soon the masses opinion will change and they wud have lost all there original fans. oh well. anyway im bored of this now, lets start a new argument. who has the most sex appeal in the phonics? kelly jones or stuart cable?
stuart cable wins my vote!

Re: Stereophonics - Step On My Old Size Nines

Most people hate Stereophonics BECAUSE of Stuart Cable.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon