Sign In:
Login with Facebook
58922
Type: Album Release date: 03/05/2010
Your Rating:

Legacy isn’t something that comes overnight. For all Iggy Pop’s rhetoric surrounding his latest reunion with The Stooges, the fact remains that whatever he might have thought of Raw Power when it finally emerged, spitting blood and teeth, in 1973, he could have had no idea exactly how long the legacy of what has become known as one of the finest rock records ever released would last.

And in that sense, I’m done reviewing the ‘legacy edition’ of Raw Power already. The record speaks, or rather howls, for itself, and the addition of a thousand words to the reams of prose dissecting, fawning and investigating this most feral of albums seems almost pointless. Bluntly, if you consider yourself in any way interested in rock music and don’t already own this album, you’re doing yourself a rather large disservice.

Because if you don’t already own this album, you haven’t heard the way James Williamson’s guitar lurches out of the original mix of ‘Search and Destroy’, clawing at your ankles, exactly in tune with Iggy’s threatening catcalls. “I’m a street walkin’ cheetah with a heart full of napalm” would sound borderline ridiculous if it didn’t feel like it was being cooed by a man who genuinely believes it. And you probably haven’t experienced the paranoia seeping out of ‘Gimme Danger’, a psychotic trip into psychedelia if there ever was one, Iggy’s terrifyingly unhinged personality never sounding more seductive. “There’s nothing left alive, just a pair of glassy eyes” he cooes over one of the greatest hooks ever written, concealed beneath a veil of guitar squall and that shaking, sweating beat. And you definitely haven’t felt the voltage on your stereo surge as the title track kicks into gear following an intro that appears to be composed of a man throwing up. You haven’t felt the entire album catch fire as Williamson hijacks ‘Death Trip’ and takes it careering down an unmarked dirt track, before the whole station wagon flips over in a burst of flame, scree, shredded feedback and howling.

All that remains, remastered, but essentially unchanged, as this Legacy Edition is a faithful one: the original, much bemoaned, but undoubtedly superior Bowie version is retained over Iggy’s 1996 reworking. And that’s important: Raw Power was ugly, still is ugly and shall remain ugly for years to come. It wears its flaws and scars like a badge of honour, which is why it’s not only better than Fun House, but also why it’s better than Kick Out The Jams, and even why it’s still better than almost every ‘rock’ record released year on year. Concisely, it’s a perfect record.

And as much as it’s always a pleasure to listen to Raw Power a few times through, for those shelling out for this Legacy Edition, or indeed the three disc Deluxe package, it’s worth asking how much extra bang’s been added in return for those extra bucks. Whilst the disc of rarities adds little that serious fans won’t have already heard, it’s worth noting for a strange prototype version of 'Penetration' which sees Iggy howling “I’m hungryyyyy” instead of “penee-traaaaaa-shun”, although the rest of lyrics seem farcical enough to confirm that the released version captured the suggestive swagger far better than food metaphors ever could. Most fans will already have been exposed to the jarring 1-2 sucker punch of ‘I Got A Right’ and 'Gimme Danger’s nauseatingly twisted cousin ‘I’m Sick Of You’ anyway, but it’s good to see them included, even if it’s alongside some rather pointless single edits and a few of Iggy’s reproduced 1996 tracks.

Yet the second disc is an entirely different beast: Georgia Peaches is an intriguing live recording of the Raw Power era lineup live in concert, including Williamson. Every bit as raw and rough and ready as its studio companion, it’s been re-assembled from segments of recordings held by a variety of fans and archivists. As such it’s disappointing, but not surprising, that Williamson’s guitar part seems bizarrely shorted out of the opening few tracks, drowned out by Ron Asheton’s crypt-walking bass and frenetic honky-tonk piano. Even without a recording that does it full justice, the band sound as lean and limber as their frontman, tearing through nine songs with the kind of filthy swagger that might be expected, Iggy howling and adlibbing his vocals in between taunting and baiting the audience (the speech from which the bootleg takes it’s name is an exercise in suggestive filth – take note, Lady GaGa). The set is dotted with tracks that never made it to the studio: the extended jam of ‘Head On’, the motorcity rock n soul of ‘Heavy Liquid’ and the Little Richard reductionism of the crudely titled and even more crudely executed ‘Cock In My Pocket’. But it’s left to the very best cut from Raw Power to really make this set shine. Granted, the overextended melancholy of ‘Open Up And Bleed’ has its moments, but who are we kidding: it’s no ‘Gimme Danger’.

Because the live version of ‘Gimme Danger’ on Georgia Peaches captures everything that makes Iggy & the Stooges, and Raw Power, so dangerously addictive. It treads the knife edge between fragility and swaggering machismo in a way that Iggy couldn’t have expected when the record company asked him to write a ballad and he poison penned a twisted love song in response: Asheton’s slumbering bassline, that down tempo percussion and Williamson’s pained guitar mere background for a vocal performance that explains quite why the band suddenly felt the urge to add Iggy’s name to their album covers. Live, it’s reproduced with clear passion; if on Metallic KO you could hear the beer bottles shatter against guitar strings, on Georgia Peaches you can hear Iggy stalk the stage like a hyena and paw at the ground like a dog as he howls about a “girl with the death in her eyes”. And that’s what makes Raw Power and by extension, Iggy & The Stooges, so special. Raw Power is a timeless piece of work not because of it’s beautiful qualities, not because of it’s technical prowess, but because of the passion and emotion that sweats out of every filthy pore of the record. And if that hasn’t come across, I’ve just wasted another thousand words.

nice review...

...though, if it's a 'perfect record', why not give it a perfect score?

Nice review of an incredible record

I was utterly blown away by their sheer energy, even years down the line, when they played at Thurston Moore's ATP in 2006. Still one of the best full-on rock gigs I've ever experienced.

If it's the 3 disc deluxe set that's been reviewed then it's likely that

a point has been deducted due to the inclusion of the less worthwhile single edits and '96 remastered tracks as noted in the review itself. Maybe.

exactly this

I mean, consensus on Raw Power as an original recording is that it's up there with the very best.

What I was reviewing wasn't the original recording, but the original recording plus a fairly hit and miss bonus disc and a pretty enthralling live recording.

I'm gonna have to come out and say it

I prefer Iggy's mix. Bowie's mix is clean and sounds restrained. You can clearly hear where the guitars cut in and out in the mix in 'Search and Destroy'. Iggy's mix, by comparison, sounds like a live mix...like a band who can barely be comtained by the walls of a concert hall, let alone the studio and I like the fact it sounds like my speakers are about to blow. Bowie's may be a more accomplished mix but Iggy's is truer to the nature of the music.

You think?

I reckon Bowie's mix is much more abrupt and unhinged sounding which I prefer vastly to Iggy's more wall of sound approach - I love the way guitar cuts in and out, it gives the album this amazingly crazed quality.

Nice words

It's not better than Fun House though (ooh!)

Yeah, I have to agree with Philip

there is something completely barking about the way the guitars fade in and out that I just love. I seem to remember Iggy being interviewed by somebody like P4K commenting that the remix of Raw Power was kind of a ploy to flog it to grunge kids - I seem to remember him not exactly selling it!

I think I agree with you

It sounds a bit flat compared to the Iggy version somehow. That live bit sounds like enough reason to buy it again though anyway.

I wouldn't really compare it with Fun House, it sounds like a totally different band to me. Even though it isn't obvs! They are both best.

I'm so excited about Iggy at ATP

that I can barely sleep and will undoubtly listen to this for hours on end before the day :D

In reality, it's Iggy's remaster that's more restrained.

It's compressed to shit like Metallica's Death Magnetic or a fuckin' Britney Spears record. Bowie's mix is much wilder, allowing all the instruments to run free.

Then why doesn't it sound as exciting?

:(

Seriously though why haven't they turned up Ron's bass and given it the position in the mix it deserves?? The basslines are awesome but you can barely hear them.

I don't think Iggy's version sounds even remotely exciting, it's bland and boring and devoid of dynamics.

Penetration and I Need Somebody are completely ruined and all the tracks are at least severely compromised. With Iggy's version I feel like I'm listening to a greyish mush, with the Bowie mix you have to turn it up to the point where it's almost like you're being sexually assaulted by the guitar to even hear the bass and drums, which leads to a much rawer and more powerful experience for me. Sure, the mix could be better, but I feel like something is lost by forcing all the tracks into a narrow range and jacking the volume up. A sort of fake polish that often passes for real "excitement" in an age where real dynamics are forsaken, but I'm kind of seeing right through that.

well calling it 'not even remotely exciting' is just mental!

The songs and the way they are played/sung rise above whatever mix you're listening to, crappy or otherwise. I think my main problem with the Bowie mix is how it sounds like a load of instruments that are recorded at different times in a studio, whereas the other one actually sounds more like a band. I guess it's just the way I like this particular record. I mean 'Accelerator' by Royal Trux barely sounds like a band a lot of the time but I love that one. Who knows.

wrt dynamics i'm not going to be sitting at home listening to this on headphones, it's ok everything is stupidly loud. It's a rock record!

I need to find the 'Rough Power' mix and listen to that again now. Bah!

Great review.

The amazing thing about the Stooges is that all 3 of those records are different enough to be absolutely essential. Fun House is easily the best of the 3 for me though. Raw Power has the best tunes but, let's face it, the tunes are far from the best thing about The Stooges. The real raw power is on Fun House, particularly Iggy's screaming. That's mostly missing for me on Raw Power regardless of the debates over the different productions.

I don't feel like the Iggy version sounds any more like a band playing all at once than Bowie's does.

It's just one is poorly mixed and one is mastered like a Britney Spears record. It's clear that we're not going to agree on a single detail regarding the relative merits of the different versions of this record, which is rather insubstantial. The heart of the matter: That the Stooges are superior to just about anything.

I agree

let us be friends

funhouse

there's nothing better than Funhouse, in what we call "rock". It's the end and the beginning of everything.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon