Logo
DiS Needs You: Save our site »
  • Yann Tiersen - ALL 3 days ago
  • DiScover: IYEARA 4 days ago
  • Two’s Company: Asta Bria & John Metcalfe @ The Playground Theatre 4 days ago
  • Methyl Ethel - Triage 4 days ago
  • “Music as a personal outlet really isn’t all that interesting”: DiS Meets Lewsberg 5 days ago
  • Panda Bear - Buoys 5 days ago
  • Mercury Rev - Bobbie Gentry's The Delta Sweete Revisited 6 days ago
  • TBC: Sign Of The (Stage) Times 6 days ago
  • Logo_home2
  • Records
  • In Depth
  • In Photos
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Search
  • Community
  • Records
  • In Depth
  • Blog
  • Community

Idlewild

Scottish Fiction (Best Of 1997-2007)

Label: Parlophone Release Date: 01/10/2007

28004
Mike_Diver by Mike Diver October 5th, 2007

Ten years in the business and still going strong – check out this year’s Make Another World album for the evidence of an all-firing group, still very much full of the fire that comprised their initial catalyst – Idlewild’s decade-up anniversary arrives at a time where retrospect is so very now: Control is doing the business, or about to, at the box office, and ATP’s Don’t Look Back series rolls onwards, with GZA the latest artist confirmed to tackle a highpoint of their back catalogue in its entirety in the live environment. Yet the Scottish rockers have gone about their business with a degree of stealth – while press has remained consistent since the heady days of the Maker once a week and Select a dozen times a year, they’re hardly as celebrated as Scottish Fiction suggests they should be.

This best-of offering collects 17 of the quintet’s tracks, although whose opinions have counted towards the compiling is a mystery: old-school sorts will bemoan the lack of anything from pre-Parlophone EP Captain, making this actually a run through of picks from the era 1998-2007, rather than the clean decade indicated in the title. The omission of a ‘Last Night I Missed All The Fireworks’ or ‘Satan Polaroid’ is slightly detrimental to the collection, and it’s a shame that pre-major label material isn’t represented in the same manner as tracks from the Sanctuary/Sequel-released Make Another World (both ‘No Emotion’ and ‘Make Another World’ feature).

But it’s not like Idlewild don’t have material of a quality high enough to warrant a best-of_ without_ their earliest flailings: their peak period, from debut album Hope Is Important through to 2002’s The Remote Part, produced a flurry of excellent singles, and they’re muddled here into an interestingly erratic coherency. ‘Roseability’ leads into ‘When I Argue I See Shapes’, the sublime ‘American English’ to ‘These Wooden Ideas’; put _Scottish Fiction _on random and it’s a truly different experience every time through. These are great pop-rock songs, simple as.

Some will question the need for an Idlewild best-of when one is already available in the form of their second album proper (should have been an ‘IMHO’ disclaimer there), but Scottish Fiction is a timely reminder in an age of must-succeed debuts that, given the space to breath and develop on their own terms, a group of troubled teens can transform into a truly classic act of our time, with singles that resonate with a timelessness that few bands bearing similar influences can claim as their own. Sure, the Warnings/Promises cuts aren’t so great, but we all know that anyway. Skip ‘em if you must, that’s the beauty of a compilation like this. But the winners… seriously, even so many years on, ‘Little Discourage’ still kicks like a particularly riled mule. Hard and fast, deservedly re-acclaimed.

Don’t Look Back: 100 Broken Windows? Please?

 

Also available this month: _A Distant History – Rarities 1997-2007, available to download on EMI/Parlophone from October 29. It features Captain tracks, oddly enough._

  • 8
    Mike Diver's Score
Log-in to rate this record out of 10
Share on
   
Love DiS? Become a Patron of the site here »


LATEST


  • Yann Tiersen

    ALL


  • DiScover: IYEARA


  • Two’s Company: Asta Bria & John Metcalfe @ The Playground Theatre


  • Methyl Ethel

    Triage


  • “Music as a personal outlet really isn’t all that interesting”: DiS Meets Lewsberg


  • Panda Bear

    Buoys



Left-arrow

Y Society

Travel At Your Own Pace

Mobback
28000
27957

Various

Control OST

Mobforward
Right-arrow


LATEST

    review


    Yann Tiersen - ALL

  • 106053
  • Interview


    DiScover: IYEARA

  • 106046

    Live Review


    Two’s Company: Asta Bria & John Metcalfe @ ...

  • 106052
  • review


    Methyl Ethel - Triage

  • 106051

    Interview


    “Music as a personal outlet really isn’t all th...

  • 106049
  • review


    Panda Bear - Buoys

  • 106048

    review


    Mercury Rev - Bobbie Gentry's The Delta Sweete ...

  • 106047
  • Column


    TBC: Sign Of The (Stage) Times

  • 106045
MORE


    Interview


    The ineffable joy of pop: DiS meets Carly Rae J...

  • 101425
  • review


    The Enemy - Music For The People

  • 93727

    DiSband


    DiSband #7: Viva Brother

  • 77972
  • feature


    Jimmy Eat World answer your questions

  • 93725

    In Depth


    One-Hit Wonders: Our 12 all-time favourites

  • 95806
  • Interview


    Life, Death and Broken Bells - DiS meets James ...

  • 82768

    feature


    This is Our Music: SXSW '06 With No Prospects

  • 94784
  • news


    Album Stream + Inventions' (Explosions in the S...

  • 95303
MORE

Drowned in Sound
  • DROWNED IN SOUND
  • HOME
  • SITE MAP
  • NEWS
  • IN DEPTH
  • IN PHOTOS
  • RECORDS
  • RECOMMENDED RECORDS
  • ALBUMS OF THE YEAR
  • FESTIVAL COVERAGE
  • COMMUNITY
  • MUSIC FORUM
  • SOCIAL BOARD
  • REPORT ERRORS
  • CONTACT US
  • JOIN OUR MAILING LIST
  • FOLLOW DiS
  • GOOGLE+
  • FACEBOOK
  • TWITTER
  • SHUFFLER
  • TUMBLR
  • YOUTUBE
  • RSS FEED
  • RSS EMAIL SUBSCRIBE
  • MISC
  • TERM OF USE
  • PRIVACY
  • ADVERTISING
  • OUR WIKIPEDIA
© 2000-2019 DROWNED IN SOUND