Sign In:
Login with Facebook
26554
Type: Single Release date: 13/08/2007
Your Rating:

A recognised metal-head friend of mine – who shall remain nameless to preserve his reputation – recently asked me for contact details for The Pigeon Detectives’ PR company. He’d suddenly been taken by their debut album, Wait For Me, unexpectedly; defences weakened by daytime exposure to mainstream radio, the Yorkshire quartet’s jaunty melodies overran him. I felt sympathy, initially; but, after a few cursory listens to ‘Take Her Back’, I understand my friend’s condition. There is something mercilessly devastating about this band’s assault on your twitchy toes.

Yeah, it sounds like it fell off an itchy-indie-pop production line; yeah, the accents are as broad as the appeal of the peers The Pigeon Detectives hope to emulate commercially; and yeah, the lyrics are matter-of-fact nonsense, designed with the sole intention of having them absolutely hollered back at the band at bigger and bigger venues around the country and beyond. But despite all its clichés there’s no doubting the quality of ‘Take Her Back’’s assembly – it’s destined to fulfil its mission, to infect the easily pleased like Spanish flu and take a few more discerning souls with it for ballast, just for the fun of it.

Conclusion: it’s shit, really, but in a good way; a way that can be respected and appreciated on a level beneath personal tastes. Me, I’ll be tossing this disc as far away from me as possible once the next full stop’s tapped into place, but my mate? Well, he’s in for the long-term I fear, and I’m going to try my very best to avoid being dragged down with him.

What a wonderful review

and very honest also.

It is nice to see something that is not like, yep, NME like, therefore it is shit.

It is bad, but, yes, in a sort of, half-good way.

j'agree

The Statik remix

is Ace.

Poor Raz.

poor, poor Raz.

Ahem, the contact details?

The PR company your metalish friend was inquiring about, I mean.

I wonder how shit like this,

The View, etc. ever get signed.

You have a fair point that this is at least shit in a good way.
It's not offensively shit. Just tedious.

wrong

this band are just shit.

Their faces alone irritate me. Less said about the music the better.

This review

basically sums up The Pigeon Detectives for me..

Lowest common denomentor, NME identikit indie, bereft of any originality, yet theyve honed their schtick to such an extent you wonder if they've been cynically put together by a record company, or even the KLF..

I cant say I hate this band ever

they were really fun live & they do have a couple okay songs. Sure they lack originality but they are heads and shoulders above 'The Enemy' or 'The Twang' this review is pretty much spot on.

Cos

Bands like these and The View have tallied the attributes of successful mainstream indie bands of the last 5 years, found the average and ran with it, the appeal (for now atleast), unlike the music itself, is unquestionable. Mercifully Id happily bet that these bands never get past a second album..

I really hope this is the last in the line of bands of this ilk, the lineage of Strokes/ Libertines bands is now so watered and the reference points now so narrow it sounds like bands are looking no further than last years soundalikes for inspiration.

Please let this be the end.

J'agree also

Shame that pretty much all of the people on here agree with the aforementioned philosohpy and so won't

i do love hor DiS tell it like it is

NME?
heck they probably shoved them on the front cover of their magazine in light of this single.
but i have to say.

they are top blokes, when they played the drum and monkey in ipswich everyone had a raucous time and they sat down and got pissed with the regulars.

and they played with vigour and delighful energy but now they are everyones favourite band and they aren't playing to music loving cynics who heckle at any band they dislike in dingy pubs they don't have to fucking make an effort. shame.

The problem with their tunes

is that they really are mercyless-they stick to your neurons.
"I'm not sorry"-I keep waking up with that tune in my head, and god bless I must have listened to it about 3 times.
Bah.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon