No Hope for the united States? Band to split... probably
- Artists:
- Hope of the States »
Is it because we gave their last single only three outta ten? Is it? No, of course not. But still...
Hope Of The States, it would seem, are all but over. The West Sussex sextet played the Reading and Leeds festivals over the weekend, but went on record as saying that said shows would be their last.
The news was announced on BBC3's coverage of the festivals via the band's management. Although an official announcement as to the exact situation is yet to be made, it seems the future's a Hope Of The States-less place.
The band's Left long-player is out now. The single of the same name is a bit pants, mind.
Hmmm...not sure what to think, really
Probably not an interesting story, but I went to see Metric, Tapes 'n' Tapes, Forward Russia and Dresden Dolls in a row at Reading, and left before HOTS came on because I needed a lie-down before SLAAAAAYERRRR were on. Makes me think I maybe should've stayed to watch HOTS.
...or maybe not. I dunno. The new record ain't good at all.
at the risk of sounding smug...
i DID suggest last week, in response to the 'Left' review, that a third album was by no means inevitable.
be nice to me - this does not happen often.
Left is great
well, I think so anyway...
Hope Of The States were tremendous I thought. Lovely version of Black Dollar Bills.
If they are lost - I will be soooooo upset.
They are one of the least influenced or scene bands around, it will be a crying shame if they are lost.
Metric? They badly need to lose their "rawk" influence I reckon.
Tapes N Tapes took a little while to get intio their strde which was a shame cos they ended really well.
Maccabees were brilliant and Sareena Maneesh devastating. TV on the Radio were sublime - not as good as ATP though I thought....The guitars there moved mountains, only medium sized peaks at Reading!!!
Well...
I love them. But I'm not too gutted. The new album was pretty bad, not a patch on the Lost Riots.
I've seen them three times, Brum Academy in 04, which was good, Northampton Soundhaus in 05 which was simply stunning, then the other day at Reading. I left the set early because I thought it was fucking awful, which is a massive shame... the sound was terrible, they were disjointed and none of them looked as though they cared.
It's a sad loss but getting over DFA1979 and Million Dead in the past 12 months has been tougher for me, despite me liking The Lost Riots more than the other two bands.
They were really great at Reading
I had heard the rumours - because I was poshing it at Reading, I could look at Teletext every morning and I saw it there, so I made doubly sure I caught their set - which was very heavy on the first record and didn't feature Sing It Out or Left (the single) at all.
It was a brilliant show. I hope they don't give up.
doh!
i couldnt be bothered to move from the comedy tent, so i didnt go and see them at leeds. damn.
they were brill at reading
and at the last 3 shows i saw them at (Astoria, kings college, Koko.).
A damn shame.
They were so good at Reading...
really beautiful especially the stuff off The Lost Riots, if it is the case that they've split up, I'm really upset by it, but at the same time really glad I got to see them at last...
I can't express myself properly after the weekend:(
Interesting
The Reading show seems to have polarised opinion.
Can't see how anyone could possibly have thought it was rubbish though...
I've seen them on about six or seven occasions I think a Barfly gig was the most awesome event. They were also handy the first time I saw them with Youth Movie SS in support (ICA)(what a show that was...)
.
i saw a few songs of their set, never really a huge fan of them so not to bummed out! Their new stuff has been sounding pretty pants though
They were
good at Reading. Maybe even very good.
But the set they played was more or less crammed with the same material they played when I saw them at Glasto '04.
2 years older with only 1 more record to their name (which they are clearly embarassed about).
I think they should call it time myself. The memories wont be all bad in thta case.
The Set....
I wasn't really taking notes but I do remember they played Blood Meridian and Bonfires (off Left) at the very least in what wasn't a very long set.
I have to say that these two in particular I remembered because they were so good, Blood Meridian in particular being much better than the recorded version.
To think I strolled through thier set
not knowing it was thier last (at Leeds).
I loved 'The Lost Riots', mind.
!
I was told a number of times by cool people Intheknow that Anthony wasn't happy with the new album at all. So this is no suprise really.
Like some, I'm not too fussed, last time I saw them, even the old stuff didn't sound as great...
I've never liked what i've heard
of them on the radio or record.
But live they were absolutely amazing!!! really fantastic and they were an essential part to break up the day.
Pity more people watched the Ravingly shite klaxons because it was cool to.
Metric were excellent too, some of the strongest songs of the festival.
On a side note...
Broken Social Scene said a couple of times during their set that it had been Hope Of The States last gig and dedicated a song to them. I've also got to admit that I wasn't overly impressed with HOTS set myself. I'm a big fan but it left me feeling underwhelmed when compared with their recordings.
The highlight of HoS perfomance at leeds
was The awesome Black amnesias, unfortunately the rest of their ser couldnt live up to it although i did enjoy the absense of their new LP.
shame they are breaking up though why they dint mention it at Leeds or Reading is a mystery. Well to me anyway.
i really like them
but the last two times i've seen them live - leeds and middlesbrough music live the sound has been atrocious - considering the leeds technicians are supposed to be the best in the business it was all top end, utter bollocks.
I agree with the black amnesias comments though, i hope they come back, Left isn't the album for them to quit on in my opinion - they are good deep down!
I saw them at Reading
they were pretty poor...i sang along to red white blue black and blood meridian, but my friend, who hadnt heard them before, claimed only to have heard distortion...
they have a few anthems, but their album tracks are sloppy shite...don't mind if they are over...
The sound
was APPALING for their set in the reading NME tent.
Not just bad, but absolutely terrible. Yet i still thought they put in a good performance.
Left
does grow on you, but i don't think they've ever reached the potential they have or had. Will be a shame if it's true.
It was Fine
where I was but our gang stood quite close to the stage on the right hand side.
It was good there although the sound in that tent was awful depending where you were standing.
Tapes N Tapes and Metric both suffered - Metric's drums sounded louder than everything else and made them sound very leaden.
There seemed to be far more people around in the tents (especially in early afternoon) this year (that's where those extra people went) so maybe the engineers got it wrong.
The HotS CDs have not
i thinks it must be true
cos broken social scene who came on afterwards kept saying that it was their last gig and saying they now split and were dedicating tracks to them and saying they'll be missed.
tis a pity
x
GUTTED!
I love this band. they don't have silly haircuts, any over the top gimmick or generally jump about like tossers (ala every band the NME seem to be promoting the now). They are the best modern musicians in Britain at the moment and to see them live is something special espescially in smaller venues where the sound could make your head fall off. If it's tru then surely it is just a break or Sam must continue as a soloist as his lyrics are sometimes pure genius.
www.halfwayhome.tk
Go there and you will find official statements from band members re. demise of band.
Rather sad, but they probably shouldn't have tried to make a second album entirely in the style of "The Red, the White...". It worked two or three times on 'Lost Riots' but it was never likely to sustain a full album without the longer tracks.
Record company pushing for 'poppier, more radio-friendly' maybe?


Hope of the States
In Photos: Noah & The Whale @ The Roundhouse, London
In Photos: Frightened Rabbit @ The Leadmill, Sheffield
In Photos: Wild Beasts @ KOKO, London
In Photos: Tallest Man on Earth @ Bush Hall, London
In Photos: Is Tropical @ The Lexington, London
In Photos: John Cale @ The Royal Festival Hall, London
Spotifriday #38 - This Week on DiS as a playlist
Spotifriday #37 - This Week on DiS as a playlist
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article