Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
this has probably been done before
Worst: Season 9
best changes every time i rewatch it
because they really find their feet and it takes off in a big way
worst: season 2
Best: Season 5
Worst: Season 1 (though it has its charms). I would go for four as the worst because of Riley and the shit big bad, but it has a load of genuinely great standalone episodes.
Best season 3 worst season 7
but agree about Andrew being great
season 5 is a contender, I like season 1 as it is quintessential buffy, but I probably wouldn't choose to watch it over any other season.
didn't like season 7 as the big bad was too abstract
worst none, there was only one series
Best: Season 5, though 4 - 8 or so are on fairly equal footing.
Worst: Season 11 was pretty bad, though this last season was pretty awful too.
series 1, 2 or 5 - the best
series 4 & 6 - the worst