My Mad Fat Diary
Could've been shit. Was a bit try hard (but I think that's a combo of out bring the first episode, and me being at the upper end of the target demographic). Turned out to be watchable with some genuinely good bits.
Your thoughts?
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this

I enjoyed it
would have liked a bit more proper 90s detail, not just Blur and Oasis references. But I liked how the characters were all well developed, not just obvious cliches. But it's true I think, isn't it? Which would explain that.
I found the bit with the slide really dramatic/touching.
Yeah, it's based on a semi-autobiographical book.
I liked it a lot, especially the shifts in tone.
Were there references to Menswe@r?
none yet
all in good time, though
What is/was it?
it's an E4 teen comedy drama
bad title, but it's about a girl with mental health/eating issues making friends after coming out of hospital in the mid-90s.
Thnaks!
Sounds interesting enough.
good to see Newt from holyoaks get some more work
was alright, only 6 episodes long though
oh yeah, I didn't recognise him!
most British series are 6 episodes long, that's fine by me.
then why does it seem like Miranda is on all the time
:(
oh gosh, i loved him
does it contain
a)authoritarian mental health services
b)patient refusal/failure to comply with medication
c)numerous other boring cliches when making any film/tv show about mental health services
not yet
not in the first episode!
the mental health professionals were one sexy one and one eccentric but kind and helpful one.
I really liked the bit where
she commandeered the jukebox and put on Sabotage.
that worked on two levels.
in terms of the story itself. and also as barometer to measure the programme by. or is that just one level?
yeah, I was worried it was just going to be Girls and Boys or something
but it was a genuinely great surprise when she put that on.
yes although
the "it's alright for the mainstream" comment made me cringe a bit...possibly because I would have said something similar in my teens.
In the opening scene she is outside the mental hospital (actually a library)
and a 2001 Ford Mondeo drives past. These people shouldn't be allowed to make tv.
There's no easy or PC way of saying this
But as someone who's had mental health issues and been in love with Britpop, I think I might quite like this show.
Thing is, it might make me a bit depressed being old enough to remember all the cultural references on a "retro" series. At least with This is England I could keep everything at arm's length
Quick question.
I didn't watch it, but by the sounds of it it seems like the only good bits in this programme were the music references. Is this true or is it actually worth watching because its funny/well written etc?
The references are great
But they aren't compulsory to make it a good watch. It seems to have taken quite a lot of elements of recent E4 teen dramas and comedies (Skins, Inbetweeners, i guess even This is England?) but added a sense of realism.
Quite enjoyed episode 2
overall it's far less predictable than I was expecting.
I really like the programme
but during episode two I started to realise they've made absolutely fuck-all effort to set it in the mid-90s, and it's annoying me. The story's great, and the acting's great, but aside from the music and the fact they're not using mobile phones, the period detail is crap!
This is basically the first period drama I've seen where I fully remember the period and was the same age as the characters in it. But everyone's wearing clothes which might as well be now, no-one's got curtains, the glasses Archie wears are cool for now but definitely aren't 90s ones, and no-one in the pub is smoking! (They should have let me do the costume and set design obvs).
Nobody's got curtains?
Fuck this half-arsed show. Is there at least one character with an undercut?
NO
and no-one with short hair but a stiff gelled bit spiked up at the front. And no-one wearing one of those roll-neck jumpers from Burton with one stripe across the chest like Ross from Friends would wear. Basically no-one is dressed like Ross from Friends.
I wish the programme looked like this
http://joeyapps.files.wordpress.com/2012/05/deller.png?w=479
(that's a Jeremy Deller artwork but all my photos from the 90s are exactly the same)
Remember 24 hour party people?
I really loved the way they didn't attempt to get the period right so he's driving in his battered period car up to Piccadilly station, surrounded by modern vehicles.
In fact, doesn't he do a piece to camera on a modern bridge or something?
24 Hour Party People also features a bit where Bez comes down from a spaceship
I don't think realism was one of Winterbottom's main concerns.
Worth reading:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2013/jan/21/mad-fat-diary-rae-earl-childhood-mental-health
This is definitely holding it's own.
Thought the party episode was done really well.
I like the way that you can't tell whether the mates are gonna turn out to be reliable when needed or whether they're gonna flake. (Well, there's a definite tendency toward feel-good endings, but they've nonetheless captured the uncertainty thing, I think).
I presume I'm toward the upper end of the target demographic, but I expect it's fairly essential viewing among schoolkids.
k. turns out i've repeated what was written in the op. consistency ftw.
is this not a kids programme?
this ended yesterday
anyone stick with it?
series two is happening apparently
I've not seen yesterday's episode yet,
but I think it's been terrific.
Tix is probably my favourite character. I got pretty upset at last week's show.
I'll say nothing til then