Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
Have a great day.
Great montage, that.
And I don't say that lightly.
I think you're probably right but I still don't think it's quite perfect. Pixar have still yet to nail a proper villain I think and I think their two best (Wall-E and Up) have suffered a bit in their final thirds because of this.
only slightly better than the stupidly overrated The Incredibles.
the big at the end of Monsters where Sully goes through the door and you just hear a "...kitty?" is just so totally :'))))))))))
I think it's probably the most wonderfully inventive of their films but it doesn't pack the emotional punch of Up or show the same ambition as the opening act of Wall-E (which is undoubtedly their best moment)
but not quite right. Monsters Inc is terrific: no.2 for me
but Up does things other animated flicks aspire to but don't achieve. Let me qualify that - it does things other *films* aspire to but don't achieve.
I'm gonna guess, um, Scagden?
Like Wall-E, it has an absolutely incredible beginning, but then fades. Wall-E fades slightly, Up fades much worse. Wouldn't even make my top 5 Pixar.
The opening montage is wonderful, the final emotional reveal with the book, likewise. But the talking dogs and gangly bird and so on and so on... what?
maybe. And i kind of want to disagree with even that tho i can't decide what I'd say was the best instead...
I was pretty scared at first but the trailer looked really good.
I'll make up my own mind.
is one of those scottish accents that's real, but sounds utterly fake. really worried about it.
with the same series of notes
It was the same for his Lost work a lot.
(See also: Nathan Johnson's score for The Brother's Bloom)
you are duncan jenkins and i claim my five pounds
Finding Nemo>Monsters Inc>Up>Ratatouille>Toy Story 1-3(cop-out but they're all similar quality)>Wall E>The Incredibles>A Bugs Life>Cars
They're all brilliant except for Cars, which is passable and A Bugs Life which is just very good.
I don't give a shit about Cars 2 and neither should you. I'd put money on it being OK though.
Jessie is the most annoying Pixar character by a long, long way.
by a long way. I liked the first and third.
wasn't aware there was a DiS standard :)
i've never seen up
but my friend made me watch it and omg <3
But How to Train Your Dragon is amazing.
and the scene where the balloons get released and his house takes off caused me to grin like probably no other film scene ever has. It just looked incredible.
All the colours. Super stuff
The Incredibles 9
Finding Nemo 8.8
Monsters Inc 8.5
Toy Story 1 8.5
Toy Story 3 8.3
Toy Story 2 8.2
A Bug's Life 7.5
Cars 2 6.8
No thank YOU.
I've been doing c_i_c's diamond press-up work out sessions daily son. I'm like orsonwellesrabbit or steroids...
man, i miss orsonwellesrabbit