whats the longest time you've spent crying after finishing a book?
i suppose we can do this with films too...
i've just got a hold of myself after about twenty minutes of sobbing, not including the welling up regular sobs every few minutes of the last 40/50 pages of this book, at one point i couldn't actually focus on the words because my eyes were fogging up with tears too much.
books with genuinly happy (but really good) endings please
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this

which book was it?
and i can only remember crying at a book once in recent memory, and i had pulled myself together by the end.
The Three Little Pigs
"And they all lived happily ever after"
I've never ever cried at a book. I welled up when Blackburn Rovers beat Spurs (I think) in the Rumbelows Cup a few years back. I'm not even a Rovers fan.
I've never cried after or during a book/film
I've never really got passed the lump-in-throat stage. The last thing I read (and coincidentally the last film I saw) where I really didn't want to leave the characters behind was Let The Right One In.
where have i heard 'let the right one in' mentioned a few times recently?
brief synopsis please?
amazon reviews are dangerous 'a very poignant book, i found the deatch of the lead character really moving' etc
...
Let the right one in is the story of a lonely little boy (who needs a bloody haircut) who makes friends with a lonely little girl who is a vampire. Bloody hijinks ensue.
oh yes
it was made into a film recently wasn't it?
have you seen it?
i think i'll look for the book next time i go to the library
I didn't think the book was that great.
The film was excellent, but the book was a bit clunky, and hit standard thriller fare for periods - although I guess it could have been the translation. All 'in my opinion', of course. I was quite glad when I'd finished it.
The last entertainment related boo was the Harry Patch programme on BBC2
I spent basically the whole program welling up and then walking into the kitchen to calm down. then coming back only to get up again 5 minutes later! For some reason it was just profoundly moving
...
Aw...
If I was you I probably would have reacted in a similar way to the ending of His Dark Materials. As it is, I just went and got something to eat while fantasising about riding an armoured bear.
When I finished The Dark Tower books, I laughed for about 45 minutes though. Best ending ever.
i still haven't actually finished his dark materials
i read the first book when i was ten and i absolutely adored it but halfway through the second book i got distracted and just never got around to reading it again, i have all the books in a box somewhere though, they are on my list of things to read.
Book three is just overlong and pretty boring.
I don't know what it is about authors losing it on trilogies. Robin Hobb did with the Farseer too. I think they idolise Mervyn Peake but seem to forget he saw horrible things and went mad which explains why it happened to him.
19 years.
The Bible was just too funny.
i really wanted to make a fake account called palestine_palestine and call you a cunt
but i couldnt be bothered. far too much effort for too little gain.
I've never cried about something in a book or film.
Sometimes there's been moments that are so shocking, so powerful or so moving that I feel like all the air has been robbed of my lungs and I'm hanging in a state of catatonic shock, unable to turn the page/look away from the screen, or that the only physical reaction I can muster is a brief, stoic nod like the fat black guy in Prince's video for 'Purple Rain'. But that's it.
I guess the last time I felt like that was when I was reading Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows and Dobby died. I was completely stunned when it was revealed the wee guy got a knife to the chest and just stared at the page for a while, then when Harry was digging his grave I gave a stoic nod and thought "You know, Harry, you're not that big a cunt after all".
ok so steve cant read this thread now
NO SPOILERS PLEASE
i will kill anyone (by boiling to death in a barrel of hot shit)who spoils anything im about to read
i didn't even mention what book i was reading in case anyone got any idea's about the ending and it ruined(un)said book for them.
shame on you popti, SHAME
is it the time travellers wife?
That was my thought.
Not that it really upset me but I'm a man.
It's not my fault that I just assume everyone read Deathly Hallows within the first two days of its release.
I didn't read it until like four months after it was realeased.
Can you believe it? I was on the road and in a rough patch at the time of its release and wanted to wait til I was more settled. So I actually held off on reading a book until I was in a different state.
what book was it? i love a good cry at a book or film
quite annoying with books though when you cant see the page for tears.
longest ive ever spend crying is probably well over an hour, actually, i think i remember crying myself to sleep a few times over books or movies. usually true stories.
I didn't cry
but I was unable to speak for about an hour after reading The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas.
have you seen the film?
not yet..
it's on my wishlist though.
Is it difficult to watch?
its a good film, enjoyable. tense.
I saw the film first and then read the book after so for me it wasn't
if you can get past the very annoying cut glass english accents then it's pretty good and the ending is still very very strong
this was one of the ones i cried my heart out at!!!!! snap
GS3 to thread.
not a book/film
but the first time I'd cried in 3 years was watching the last ever episode of Six Feet Under. It's just the best ending to anything I've ever seen. but I've never cried at a book.
The dream sequence with the horse in Crime and Punishment
has me blubbing like a baby every time.
Books rarely make me sob, normally just shed a tear then move on but that and possibly Time Traveller's Wife got to me.
And as for poems; A Marriage by R S Thomas.
The last Harry Potter but that was more of an end of an era type thing
Time Traveller's Wife. Not many have made me cry that much. I just watched The English Patient. That was really sad, but now I want a desert romance.
I could not agree more with this, especially the R.S Thomas
'a sorrow too deep for words' x
I had a good 20 minutes once.
The book was about this friendly wolf. I was 11. I was gay.
1
i almost cried but then remembered only girls do that shit
2
Goodnight Mr Tom
read it when I was about 10, depressed me for about a week
I felt a little sympathy
when Christian Bale died in Harsh Times, but that is an acting master-class. Didn't cry though, never cried at a film or a book.
Directly, probably Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
about 7 hours of absolute constant crying, and a two or three of weeks of at least a couple of hours a day.
Quite a few manga series have resulted in a few hours. ASoIaF has made me cry a lot, and probably gets the most hours, though nearly all the crying is due to frustration.
Tokyo Babylon and X/1999 combined
probably get pretty equal with Harry Potter actually.
Absolutely unbelievable.
Fuck off and leave her alone.
?
Did anyone read the epilogue to the Deathly Hallows?
I felt more like vomiting than crying.
Not really
Mainly because the pages were so soaked by that point and my eyes had about 5% of their usual visibility.
Harry has like five thousand kids
and one of them is named Albus Severus Potter or something like that.
The Road made me cry a bit
And the film Grave of the Fireflies made me cry for at least five minutes.
imagine if this thread was by GS3
I think that there would be a bit of confusion regarding
the homophones of 'tears'.
hey man, don't try and lay that on me
i love the gays
3
I got all teary-eyed at the end of A Confederacy of Dunces
but I was in public so I soon pulled myself together. This doesn't often happen, but that book is such an odd, strange journey - and even more so in the context of its strange history and posthumous publishing.
Hopefully anyone who's read it will know what I mean.
I love you
wonderful
wonderful book.
Don't think I've ever cried at a book.
The yellow flowers bit in One Hundred Years of Solitude is probably the most affecting thing out of all the things I've read, but even that didn't get the tear-ducts going. I have cried at a poem though. 'Pigtail' by Tadeusz Ròzewicz. That one had me shedding a tear or two.
which book was it that made you cry?
the last book that made me tear up was Cormac McCarthy's The Road.
Years after finished
the Complete Sherlock Holmes Collection. I don't know how to explain this though.
I don't cry easily at books.
I think I probably cried the longest after Catch-22, but it wasn't a huge cry. The biggest cry I've had at a book was in the middle of Catch-22, or possibly the last HP.
the last harry potter
made me sob my heart out at the end. my whol family came into the living room to find me in floods of tears. then i read the epiloge and it annoyed me soo much. the book would have been better without it.
Forward the Foundation
Isaac Asiimov basically describing the death of the main character while he himself was dying. Brought a lump to the throat, that did.
Not cried at a book
but in a massively little-frilly-girlish turn of events, the penultimate bit of Jude The Obscure in the old church had me a bit soppy.
My most embarrassing crying moment was the age of 7 or something.
When I got totally upset over the ending of Silent Running.
So, The Time Travellers wife was the answer, right?
Cripes...
im trying to not spoil it for people theo, cheers
and what do you mean cripes?
it really got to me because im in love, i wasn't just thinking of the characters in the book.
I'm not sure that's spoiling the end...
I dunno, I just didn't think it was that sad a book. I don't think it's about being in love, it just seems to be a book that women go wildly sad over and men get a bit bored with in the second half.
I think if she'd written the second half without the constant feeling of dread hanging in the air I could have been less upset.
i thought it lost steam in the second half but picked up again
in the last 100 or so pages.
how is it not about being in love? it's about other things, yes, but it IS very much about being in love.
though that wasn't the point i was making anyway. i was saying as a reader who is in love, i found the book even more upsetting than i think i would have, had i not been in love.
End of
The Brothers Karamzov made me well up quite a lot. Specifically the denouement of Iluysha and the sympathy of calling a child an "old fellow".
I wanted to cry when I was reading Story Of The Eye
probably a different sort of 'upset' to what you're describing though. Nearly cried reading The Time Of Our Singing by Richard Powers, and The Road inevitably too.
*shudders*
there are parts of that book I wish I could forget...
Sons And Lovers
came pretty close.
Sad stuff.
for some reason
i didnt feel anything for 'the road' it was a good book. just didnt feel that emotionally attached.
I think the last time i cried at a film was Lion King when the dad dies.