earlier on we were looking thorugh the drawers of a girl who was let go a few months ago and we found an unopen bottle of orange juice with a best before date of 4/2009

a girl i work with called mel wanted to chuck the bottle away but i argued that that would be wasteful and the drink will be fine.

so im going to take the juice home tonight and put it in the fridge and drink it when i fancy a nice glass of OJ.

mel says the juice wont be fine because its been in a 'clammy' drawer and they were alughing at me a bit and saying its gross.

who is right?