Bought this today and finished it in one sitting. I think it's pretty good, got some good ideas, awesome artwork, I think it struggles a little bit though when trying to compress the idea of a mass brawl into small boxes. I also think it suffers because it doesn't resolve itself properly, I don't really understand what's changed so much at the end if Spidey and Cage et al are still renegades? ALSO it doesn't resolve what's happened to The Punisher, who to be fair was clearly the most sane (and not insane as Cap puts it) and badass character in the novel, but maybe that's intentional. Still, loved the artwork and the general idea, so 7/10.
Now on to Maus and the Southland Tales Prequel Saga (3 for 2 on graphic novels in Borders, innit).