the case for "good bad":
"actually i really like them
obviously in a kitschy way, but if a girl was wearing them, and she was awesome, itd be like OMG AWESOME GIRL IN AWESOME SHOES"
the case for "bad bad":
"honestly, i know it's a cliché but a picture is worth a 1,000 words. those shoes have no redeeming features whatsoever. the colour, the shape, the unnecessary buckles, the gold pattern, the material... it's all 100% hideous. they're just grotesque. seriously."