Both bands you have to ignore a lot of their later albums.
I think early Manics is in a similar league with early Oasis (or an even bigger league, although you can equally argue it's the other way round) and their later albums are in a similar league too.
I think it's quite a good question as those two bands are rarely mentioned together, despite being of a similar ilk.
Still touring apparently as well.
It's either Menswear vs Gay Dad
or Jive Bunny vs Whigfield