Boards
Debut vs discography
From this day forth you can only listen to either a band's debut OR their discography less their debut. Which do you pick?
Pavement - debut for me
From this day forth you can only listen to either a band's debut OR their discography less their debut. Which do you pick?
Pavement - debut for me
Most of the class of 2003/4/5
The Libertines
Franz Ferdinand
BLOC PARTY
The Pipettes
the strokes
television - both debut
Interpol- discography
.....
nah, I'm just kidding. HAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
Wu Tang Clan - debuts
Howling Bells
The Doors
Aphex Twin
Beirut
Ryan Adams
Jesus and Mary Chain
Doves
Kate Bush
Supergrass
Arcade Fire (pains me to lose Sprawl 2)
Beck - discography
Elliott Smith
Sufjan Stevens
The Horrors
Super Furry Animals
The Pogues
Tom Waits
Jane's Addiction
Faith No More
Smashing Pumpkins (bye bye Rhinoceros & Siva, sobs)
The Beatles
Stones
The Radioheads
some bands are like Sophie's Choice
Talking Heads for one. "don't take my babyyyy."
The Mars Volta
I'd take the discography over Deloused, no regrets whatsoever.
Really?
I would do the complete opposite ta. Although if I was on a desert island that would be a different matter, I'd go more for volume of music in that case.
Don't get me wrong, I love Deloused but...
it's definitely the album of theirs that I return to the least. In many respects, it feels like Deloused was made by a different band to the music that came subsequently and I think I prefer the band they became with Frances the Mute through to the Bedlam in Goliath...
Bedlam In Goliath
is their best album. Not the most popular opinion but it is the one what I have.
Blur
I'd take Leisure and leave the rest. Cheers.
yo la tengo
discography bit of a no brainer though. same applies for belle and sebastian and pavement. wowee zowee is their finest hour in my book, followed by crcr.
I LOVE WOWEE ZOWEE SO MUCH
Not as much as CRCR though.
Discog:
Trail of Dead
Alice In Chains
Death Cab
Explosions in the Sky
Fucked Up
Fugazi
Kyuss
M83
Mogwai
Sigur Ros
Spiritualised
SFA
More debuts
Massive Attack
Portishead
Tricky
Portishead is a tough call on that one for me
Debuts:
Nirvana
The Wedding Present
X
Wire (yes I know the rest is amazing, but Pink Flag is plenty enough for me)
Bad Brains
Discography:
Boredoms
Sonic Youth
Broken Social Scene
The Cure
Cocteau Twins
Spoon
You are aware that 'Bleach' was Nirvana's debut, right?
#justchecking
Radiohead - debut
I was just about to post this.
You stole my glory :(
Mansun
a million times Mansun.
debut obviously
Yeah but Six is the best
Nas
:(
DIscography - Sloan
debut: mull historical society
discography: flamin' groovies
debut: quicksilver messenger service
discography: The Fall
debut: contortions
Modest Mouse
It's a tragedy losing "Custom Concern" and "Talking Shit About a Pretty Sunset", but I can live because I have Moon & Antarctica and Lonesome Crowded West.
So few bands where I'd take the debut
mostly ones I loved when I was younger
Arctic Monkeys
Maximo Park
The Strokes
Art Brut
The New Pornographers
Archers of Loaf
Galaxie 500
Mazzy Star
Suede
maybe R.E.M. actually!
Hell no funkycow!
There's too much good stuff in the rest of the Pavement catalogue to give up. I just can't do it, but then again never hear Summer Babe, Zurich is Stained or Two States again... argh. So hard, why you make me choose? No, I'm right - if it was Crooked Rain then maybe I'd take your ultimatum but I'm sticking with everything but the debut.
summer babe's on westing so that's fine
phew!
this life without Slanted is looking a lot better already.
Motion Suggests Itself
there's a tune
no here or in the mouth a desert?