This isn't a hate thread, I generally think Pitchfork are on the mark with their revews. Nobody has to listen to what they say, but I think a lot of people feel a slight twinge of annoyance when they put down a great record or artist, so what are your examples?
Basically I think they've been harsh on Bjork since the millenium, though I can't find reviews of either Post or Homogenic (they placed them in their best albums of te 1990s list). Vespertine had begrudging praise with a 7.2 score...but that was pretty much the high point. Go on rateyourmusic.com, see how much people like Bjork.