The Beatles: A rambling post
50 years too late but I've been struck down with acute Beatlemania this week. I've just finished a marathon session of reading 'Revolution In The Head' whilst listening to the entire Beatles discography (yeh I've got eight weeks off work) and now I feel slightly institutionalised by my own obsessiveness - feel alarmingly like that kid in the 'curious incident..' book, so this post is me taking tentative steps back into the real world - a splurge of thoughts so I can go to bed with a clear head
#1 HOLY SHIT. From Love me Do to A Day In The Life in seven years. Transpose their career to now and if they split up today they would have formed in 2005. So like, when Arctic Monkeys were first releasing demos, when Bloc Party were last good. Throw in the fact that McCartney was 27 at the time of their split and it just makes my head spin
#2 Looking at their school photos almost brings to mind some kind of divinity - here's 100 normal lads from Liverpool, John Lennon amongst them, all grew up in decent enough suburbs. Except, hang on, he can toss off a song in less than an hour that will be treasured and pored over 60 years later. Oh and he can repeatedly do this over and over again for years, Until the point where something like 'Imagine' or 'In My Life' represents like 1/600th of his output. Give anyone else a lifetime and they would be nowhere near able to do that. Will any songs from 2012 be consistently heralded until 2062 and beyond? Where does such a gift originate?
#3 It's like you can't step far enough away from The Beatles to gain an objective insight into how important they were. We kind of exist in the space that they created, other bands gravitate in their orbit. Their body of work reminds me of Shakespeare's in some ways, its kinda the DNA of where we are now. Could that ever happen again?
#4 I cycled to Strawberry Fields yesterday and got talking to a childhood friend of Brian Epstein who was putting on an exhibition nearby (Epstein left him dozens of rare artefacts when he died) - I actually wound up going to the Cavern Club that night with this guy and a couple of friends to see 'The Cavern Beatles' (who were 10000x better than anything I imagined) - rarely have I witnessed first-hand such a diverse range of people from all over the world so unanimously joyful - like 60 year old Norwegian guys and groups of Spanish tourists as well as locals and groups of cruise-ship passengers from LA all completely losing their shit. Really, a remarkable evening.
#5 None of this leads to a satisfying 'conclusion' or anything, and I'm well aware that nothing I'm saying is new or original. I guess the sheer scale and weight of their brilliance only just hit me recently. All you can do really is simply 'enjoy the music' - but it somehow seems insiffucient. What they did seems too big to grasp and it frustrates me somehow!
Questions to consider anyway:
Would many of you guys consider them to be your 'favourite' band?
They've been culturally ubiquitous for our whole lives and we aren't really in a position to 'discover' them for ourselves; has this prevented you from gaining a personal appraisal of them?
What's your favourite song / album and why?
etc
cheers!
- Relevant artist taggings:
- arsequake »[x]
- Howling Willie Cunt »[x]
- Willy Custard & The Huff Poachers »[x]
- Cry of shits »[x]
- Garbage »[x]
- Troll »[x]
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this


Garbage
In first to say, this is a wonderful post and please do not troll this man.
I think your comment that they are 'culturally ubiquitous' is spot on.
I dare say I take them for granted, but I do utterly appreciate their genius and would have no qualms about saying they are and always will be the best band ever. Unless there is a fundamental shift in how we listen to music, I can't see any 'band' ever overtaking them.
stones were better
Would many of you guys consider them to be your 'favourite' band?
I don't consider the my favorite band but I recognize their talent. They were groundbreaking at their time.
From the hugely influential bands list I prefer Kraftwerk.
*I don't consider them
Not trolling here - I love The Beatles too - but with reference to your second point:
The fact that their songs are still treasured 60 years on is partly to do with their greatness, but mostly to do with their cultural context and the way the music industry worked. The apparent ephemerality of today's music shouldn't lead you to think there aren't any contemporary McCartneys & Lennons out there.
BTW favourite album Revolver (with Abbey Rd running a close second)
Songwriters of Lennon and McCartney's standard
probably only usually occur once in a sample of hundreds of millions of people and they had fucking TWO of them in one band. It's insane that they just happened to live near each other etc. And then Harrison wrote Something which is one of those classic songs that will be around forever and he was in The Beatles as well.
they made each other better to some extent
ooops hit enter...
anyway think that's certainly true but think they became that good only because of each other, Lennon's anger and drive combined with McCartney's melodic talent. You can see what they were missing in their careers afterwards (and I do like both of their solo stuff). George brought some adventurousness too.
It also helps they had the curiosity to try out loads of stuff and the opportunity and studio backing to do things before anyone else really had the shot, still astonishing they grabbed that chance with both hands.
and ringo...
well he...
was a much better drummer than often said but stopped revolver from being perfect with Yellow Submarine so :/
he IS a good drummer
just not exactly essential to the beatles
Songwriters of Lennon & McCartney's standard occur a hell of a lot more often than that
I agree it's rare that they pop up in the one band (along with a Harrison). But my point is, the really rare thing isn't the Beatles' peerless genius, or the coincidence of three great songwriters in the one band, but the fact that these things came together exactly in the right place and at the right time for the culture to receive them & deify them.
such a great enthusiastic post
don't consider them my favourite band but probably consider them the 'best'.
don't quite get your second question.
abbey road/ all my loving. abbey road just has so many amazing songs, all my loving is how ill always remember them.
Reading the post made me smile quite a lot :)
I'm a sucker for all sorts of lists stored up in my head, and I'm sure the Beatles are in my top 10 or 20 bands of all time. I have fallen in love with them all over again this year.
I agree with the second point in that, assuming most of us are 'introduced' to the Beatles at some point during our early childhood, it can take a while to shake off the aura surrounding the group and realise what makes their songs so special in the first place.
In terms of albums, Abbey Road is definitely my favourite. Best song for me at the moment is either 'Let It Be' or 'Happiness Is a Warm Gun'. But that answer changes a lot!