BEST ALBUM OF ALL TIME
I'm sure this has been done before, but it's fun. So tell me..
you're going away somewhere for a long time, let's call it an 18 month solo voyage to Mars, you're allowed to bring ONE album with you - what is it?
I'm talking an genre, any decade, anything.
- Relevant artist taggings:
- None
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this


Hmmm, probably Kid A
Dunno, I reckon whatever album I took, after 18 months of solid listening I'd probably get tired of it.
The Bends
I never get tired of it and it never fails to leave me in awe. It's not the album that I play the most but it's the one that means the most, like I can only listen to it in certain situations.
.
I'm quite interested in how certain albums can complement/enhance a particular mood, but it's made all the more interesting by the fact that it can be so different person-to-person.
What sort of situations would you listen to The Bends in then?
It's usually...
When I'm in a sort of reflective mood or something is really bothering me it just chills me out and really enlightens me in someway. But I suppose different people have different ways for everything really.
The Bends has the greatest two notes in any piece of music. Ever.
In the title track, at 3:00. Those two piano hits are the most emotional two notes ever.
what a pretentious crock of shit.
^
seconded
Err...
what?
I'd take a guitar...
...and play everything I wanted to hear. Sorry for circumventing your question.
You're joking right?
Siamese Dream
Fact!
Probably 'I could live in hope'
Sorry to be totally predictable
but OK Computer for me
^me too.its perfect
The Lemonheads
It's A Shame About Ray
Greatest album of all time.
Short Music For Short People
Dog Fashion Disco - Adultery
Every track is brilliant, a lot of them have catchy moments, yet at times it's the most confusing messed up album I've ever heard. There's just so much to appreciate about it.
I must concur with OK Computer
but I may swap it for Young Team. They're about level for me.
Alexisonfire's debut
closely followed by The Blue Album
The Blue Album
Not the greatest album of all time but I've listened to it at least once a week for the past...oooh...twelve years - so I reckon it'd serve me well on my voyage.
i have to listen t it
at least 4 times a week, as well as Pinkerton
It cannot get old
Person Pitch would sound pretty good in space
The Soft Bulletin
straight up. This time in the right thread!
You Forgot It In People
hissing fauna, are you the destroyer?
works well in any mood
good choice
plus there's so much going on you can just keep listening to it over and over again. I had it playing almost non-stop for a week.
are you some kind of sex maniac?
I find it only works in a horny type mood
Would take me a long time to decide if it was for real but
probably Tool - Aenima, I just never seem to get tired of it, love every bit of it.
I'm surpised I thought I'd be the only one.
I think there are albums I listen to alot more now but I've been listening to it for a good 8 or 9 years now and I'm not bored of it. So It's the safest bet!
yay!
I thought I might get some stick for my choice, but I'm with you, got it the moment it came out (can you believe that was 1996?!) and still give it a few spins a year!
In fact I've got two copies of the CD, I originally bought the one with the lenticular cover but that got nicked in a burglary in 1999, replaced with the normal one but bought the lenticular one again on eBay a few years ago. I'm such a fanboy!
amnesiac
Ziggy Stardust, innit?
YLT
ATNTIIO
maybe.
or Burzum 'Filosofem'
Both have bits of rage and bits of serenity.
White Album
Might as well take a double and my favourite. Clearly no the best album though.
Hot Damn! by Every Time I Die
Never ever ever gets boring.
TOMYMISTRESSTHEBRIDGE
Source Tags & Codes
The Beatles - 'The Best Of'
What I came in here to say :D
probably ire works
i lov
>:(
i love how varied it is
So tough
There's 3 in contention for me; Guided By Voices - Human Amusements at Hourly Rates (hits, but still brilliant), Manics - Holy Bible, and I'll add another to the list for The Bends.
Interpol - Turn On The Bright Lights
The Blue Album trails narrowly.
I hate these questions.
But probably iForward, Russia!- Life Processes
But I'd stick At the Drive-In- Relationship of Command and Fugazi- End Hits and maybe Mogwai- Happy Songs in between my arse cheeks before I got into my spacesuit.
Lifted
probably. Because it's like listening to music AND reading a book. But if I were allowed to take a book then probably Duke Ellington Live in Paris 1959, because it reminds me of home, and it'd transport me to another time, another place.
I don't know about for an 18 month period
but as an album, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is pretty much perfect
Predictable yes, but true I think
Either Forever Changes or No Kill No Beep Beep (depending on my particular mood)
with OK Computer and Trout Mask Replica hovering in the background.
Beethoven's ninth conducted by Wilhelm Furtwängler
The recording from Berlin 1942 (performed for Hitler's birthday, with the Nazi high command in attendance).
Sod your indie nonsense.
69 Love Songs
Not only is it my favourite album but there's plenty of material there so less chance of boredom creeping in.
Odelay
Has something for every mood I could ever be in. Beck brings it on every song.
Favourite album ever is Loveless so it may be that
However looking at other people's posts, 69 love songs is a nice idea, as it's very long and less boredom, plus a nice topic if you're on your lonesome for a long while.
tough question
brand new -deja entendu or () by sigur ros i reckon() would sound better than brand new in space
My one disc 20 track aphex twin drukqs playlist
It has everything: reflective piano ballads, intense & schizophrenic epics, uplifting but effortless mess-around skits, ambient pieces that take me to somewhere else, songs to make me reluctantly cry, a purity and beauty unlike anything else, and about 5 of my favourite songs ever. Honestly if every other album I own was to dissolve into dust right now except that one I wouldn't mind.
Disintegration by the Cure
Pretty long too which helps!
No album is going to stay interesting to me for more than a week and albums I'm already familiar with, will have less life span...
...so the prospect of having only one album to listen to for 18 months is terrifying.
Still, if I were only allowed to have one album and that would be the last album I'd hear for 18 months I guess it would be 'Dark Side Of The Moon' - suits the environment too.
for space travel?
prolly ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space
This is a toughie
My favourite album is 'AS the Roots Undo' by Circle Takes the Square but... I think I'd go insane if I heard it more that once a day. Too. Much. Intensity. Too. Much. Emotion.
For the interstellar journey scenario I'd go for Stars of the lid 'Their Refinement...' because it's long and I could just chill out and watch the stars go by forever. I don't think I'd ever get bored of that.
Actually, has anyone got a space rocket they could lend me?
Another vote for Amnesiac
Another vote for Turn On The Bright Lights.
Perhaps The Velvet Underground and Nico.
Also, perhaps My Bloody Valentine-Loveless.
Now 55
or something like that.
Black Monk Time by The Monks
Perfection!
Mew - Frengers
I don't think I'll ever tire of it, and I still maintain that it's the best record ever made.
I guess I really HAD to choose...
I think I'd go with...
TOOL - Aenima
What's with Interpol?
I don't get the Interpol love...
I'd take R Kelly's 'Trapped in the Closet - The complete series on MP3'. Not sure if it would work without the videos though.
no such thing... sorry.
everyone into position - oceansizeeeeeee
Spiderland - Slint
well, its the one i listen too most. Or happy songs for happy people by the gwai.
The Mars Volta - Deloused in the Comatorium
I just think it's the most exciting piece of music that's ever, ever been written. I could listen to it endlessly.
Kid A or Revolver
I think I'd get bored sooner with Revolver, so probably Kid A.
..
Then again, the music on Kid A might make me feel more isolated so I'm still not sure.
take a friend with you who'd choose Kid A and you take Revolver. Ta da!
any album I took would drive me into insanity,
so I guess the one album I would want saturated into my brain permanently is "The Queen is Dead" - The Smiths.
or, I could just acquiesce and go with "The Bends" as well... although I think it would make me miss planet Earth too much.
but by the way -
the question "best album OF ALL TIME" is ridiculous. and too absolute to be possible.
Pink Floyd - piper at the gates of dawn.
If I could only listen to one voice for rest of time it would have to be Syd.