I stumbled across Deja Entendu by Brand New the other week thanks to my flatmate, and have become quite taken with it. What other albums are in a similar vein that I should hunt down and check out?
PS: Today I listened to Under the Cork Tree by Fall Out Boy for the first time today, and also found myself enjoying it. Make of that what you will.
(I've taken a slightly deconstructionalist view and decided that since all signifying words are subjective, and the two words of the thread title doubly so, it was was safer to use quotation marks.)