Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
surely every 30 something woman in the country wants to see him back in the band? It would look odd with him back in there- he's too big to be a boyband member I think.
and Gary, we love Gary, OK thats in song writing terms, I am pure hetrosexual
But I'm sure a series of Summer shows would go down a storm.
I think the billing could get quite messy though which would be a problem.
If they made an effort and incorporated Robbie into the new material and also arranged a few Robbie classics for the two T's then I'm sure the screaming fans would get their moneys worth.
take that have proved themselves to be a great pop act again, and have done it without the 'big name' of robbie. given the dynamic that they seem to have is working really well, both in terms of appeal and creativity, shirley bringing robbie back into the group with his ego (in whatever state it is) would be a mistake. i'm against it.
mark was always the best one anyway.
Rob the nob was at his height playing some big or something and Take That hadn't reformed. He was dead cocky throughout the gig saying things like "this song is for four blokes sat at home".
I'd love them to offer him a place in the group then go "actually no, you twat"