Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
Which one do I get?
it is more consistent and has a wicked story running through it which ties up with a spine tingling last track.
Maybe because there's a bit too much 'freestyle ranting' on Separation Sunday which gets a bit wearying after a while. Almost Killed Me feels more like Boys and Girls... and Positive Jam and Knuckles might be my favourite Hold Steady songs, even though both are utterly ridiculous.
Seriously, i just can't choose between them, they're both great.
almost killed me is way better.
killer parties, knuckles, positive jam. other songs with titles that i can't remember. it's brilliant.
just get both.
but its nowhere near as good as seperation sunday