Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
Many years in and still totally and utter <3
If so, it is amazing beyond words!
Only album by them I ever listen to.
I think he is referring to the no S thing.
I though you might have meant something else.
melon has too many duds.
plus Siamese dream is grittier...or something
For me it goes
Siamease Dream>Gish>Mellon Chollie>Adore>Machina 2>Machina>American Gothic>Zeitgeist
With the first 3 being classics, Adore being good.. both Machinas being mostly average with American Gothic being okay and Zeitgeist maybe having 2 songs which arent totally poor.
I have a massive soft spot for Corgan's petulant whine in general.
they are both 10/10 though.
Mellon Collie above Siamese Dream, because MC doesn't have Mayonaise on it.
Gish > Pisces Iscariot > Siamese Dream > MC&TIS > Ava Adore > MACHINE I > MACHINA II > Zeitgeist.
The slow and steady decline of William Corgan, Jr.
First four are all brilliant though, and Ava Adore and MACHINA I have their moments.
and great as Pisces Iscariot is, I couldn't put it above SD, MC or even Adore.
Plus, I'd have to rate Machina II much more highly; the most underrated thing they did, I reckon.
are my fave SP records. Melcon Collie felt a little too bloated for me...althought it did have some moments. Pisces Iscariot is also underrated.
Mellon Collie isn’t consistent enough, and Gish is too raw. The others just aren’t as good.
That's The Way (My Love Is) and maybe Tarantula or itunes or wherever, and avoid the rest of it like the plague.
Yup. Totally. Fucking brilliant.