Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
Which one wins?
I'm thinking its between III and IV.
And I think IV just steals it.
how can a record with stuff like Immigrant Song, Celebration Day or Tangerine fail???
slightly weakens it in comparison to led zep IV's flawless collection to songs
an utterly brilliant album though obviously
I think its probably the highlight of III!
Physical Graffitti is the best overall tho...
IV is probably my least favorite Zep album out of them all. Graffiti is my fave.
the sheer amount that's packed into it.
First half of III is great, and has Since I've Been Loving You which is probably my favourite LZ song. I'm not so keen on their folky side.
IV is also amazing and is probably the album where they manage fit in all their different styles in the most consistent fashion, but has never grabbed me in the same way II did.
I is too much of a typical 60's blues rip-off, but, again, 2 or 3 great songs, namely 'Babe I'm Gonna Leave You'.