Boards
I don't like The Unicorns
Or any of their super borig college-rock-esque brethern.
Neutral Milk Hotel?
Yawn.
Deathcab?
Double yawn.
Pavement, now there's a band.
But a;; those sub sub sub bands.
THE SHINS - FUCK OFF.
Or any of their super borig college-rock-esque brethern.
Neutral Milk Hotel?
Yawn.
Deathcab?
Double yawn.
Pavement, now there's a band.
But a;; those sub sub sub bands.
THE SHINS - FUCK OFF.
I'm with you on the Shins sort of
.
Is that post
supposed to have any continuity to it?
Unicorns?
I've only got this rather sub-par ep... but not heard their supposedly great Who'll Cut Your Hair When Your Dead (?) album. So I'm gonna hold off on judgement.
NMH. Well, I certainly don't think Aeroplane is near as good as some. I'm just gonna say I see your point.
Deathcab. Agreed. I sorta put them in the whiney emo "I'm wish I was as good as Bright Eyes" category.
Pavement. Uhm... FUCK YEAH!
The Shins. I got their albums... and I'd rather listen to them than say Belle & Sebastian... but not as much as New Pornos. I give them a mild thumbs up. The problem is when I play "indie" radio stations every band sound like weaker versions of The Shins which kinda lessens my feeling for them.
I'm a little unclear how you decided to lump these bands together. But fuck it, I should talk.
I like none of these bands.
Event Pavement.
That said Pavement are without a doubt one of the great while the other bands are just derivative...
I also find The Unicorns
tiresome.
Whenever my girlfriend puts them on the stereo I have to put my headphones in.
^
i love
neutral milk hotel, but i can get behind the rest of this statement.
disagree on NMH big time
i would think you'd love them. really.
death cab are superboring
the shins: not consistent and the latest album doesnt make me want to relisten to it much. but when good; lovely.
I agree
I can't be bothered to give any reasons, but I dislike all of those bands.
I'd agee with the motion as posited.
NMH is ok, but not worth the cultist bumming that the album gets.
deathcab really sont have anything to do with NMH
unicorns are quite nice
NMH are brilliant, even if i dont love them as much as some people
deathcab are occassioanally quite nice poprock
pavement are pretty great
"occassioanally quite nice poprock "WAITING ROOM MUSIC FOR HELL.
*"
*=
I agree with you on the Shins
they have one or two good songs, but apart from that they are pretty yawn-worthy and dull.
Death Cab just suck.
I'm with you.
Apart from on The Shins. I think their melodies are some of the best I'll ever hear. I think they have more than 'one or two' good songs.
It's not like it's hard for you to just ignore those bands
unless you live in the USA. Their songs very rarely get played on the radio and TV. So, why bother with the the hate thread?
Personally I love Death Cab and the Shins. Between them they have a wealth of brilliant pop songs with great lyrics.
BECAUSE I WANTED TO.
oops caps lock.
anti-band-threads are harmless you limp-wristed christian-positivity $0phi4ch3rryX(L)(L)(L) love merchant
I'm kinda with you
on Deathcab. Not really the others.
Pavement are just great.
hmm
i like all of those bands. well, i'm not that keen on the unicorns and i found islands quite boring live when i saw them, but the rest are somewhere between alright and dead good.
so there.
massive disagreement on everything.
apart from pavement being amazing, because you can't really dispute this.
Not sure the link between Death Cab and NMH...
I'm quite surprised you don't like Neutral Milk Hotel actually.
Unicorns I don't love as much as everyone else, but they're still great.
I <3 Death Cab too. And The Shins are lovely.
I like the polarising effect of this thread.
yeah
i was totally polarised wasnt i.
i totally said YEAH YOURE RIGHT or OMG HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT!??!?!?!??!?!?!?!
get over yourself, marmite face
Other people posted too and were polarised.
Get over yourself spunky poojob.
Breaking News
Junplanet are spliting just now !
Champagne !
do you dislike our music too?
why?
Lyle dislikes everything except synth-drone from Birmingham.
dislike is a bit strong...
but Junkplanet's music doesn't touch me at all !
Still
I would love to see you play !
didnt i read somewhere
that junkplanet sounded like the kaiser chiefs? itd be a shame if they split.
i like the unicorns, and NMH.
boring college rock bands like pavement and Fog are less good though. each to their own i suppose.
Fog!
you did NOT just go there!
i WENT there
theyre a bit dull really, is there anywhere else i shouldnt go? im feeling adventurous...
You're sooooo wrong.
Pavement and Fog are fucking amazing pearly towers of music.
Everything in my original post is bland American blah music.
im sooooo not.
when i saw fog live they were really shit, in a quite unremarkable and unimaginative college rock-way, listening to their myspace just now isnt doing much to change my opinion.
i dont mind pavement so much, theyre a bit overrated but what isnt i suppose?
i think its a bit unfair calling those other bands (none of whom bear that much resemblance to each other imo) boring college rock and not taking into account that you like even more boring college rock.
that said
far be it from me to deny your right to make such stands against supposed musical mediocrity, thats democracy for you.
Mediocre is the perfect word for
DCFD, Shins and NMH.
Pavement's worst album shits on their absolute best.
And for why fog are actually genius, listen to 10th Avenue Freakout. Specifically, the closing trilogy, starting with The Poor Fella.
Turn it up loud.
NMH are not mediocre
So shut up.
DCFC are mediocre now
but they used to be great. And I still love The Shins.
And I prefer both to Pavement. Pull the bones out of that one.
You're mental?
you said NMH are mediocre!
Pfffffffffffffffffft.
They are.
you've really convinced me there
like someone says below, theres no real link between the bands youre slating, other than that theyre american, nor do you really have anything to say about them other than "i dont like them", which given the stuff you appear to like begs the question, so what?
So what?
So what that you don't think their similar?
They patently are.
have you ever
noticed your argumentative style seems (on the evidence of this thread) to always result in you saying 'it is because i said so'?
have you actually listened to in the aeroplane over the sea?
as far as i can tell (and id be delighted to be proved wrong) you havent actually given any reason why you dont like these bands other than their being 'college rock esque'.
furthermore, given that you like pedestrian rubbish like fog 'boring college rock esque' seems a touch unjust as a criticism really, people in glass houses and all that...
i havent really listened to anything
after transatlanticism.
i really like all the bands brainlove mentioned at the top. But pavement are the one i listen to most often.
i think pavement have more depth, and stand up to repeated listens a bit better than any of the other four.
im not saying i like pavement best thoug
i like Deathcab best out of those bands. it's just i never listen to them anymore.
A pretty sure sign of non-greatness, no?
yeah i think pavement are better
it's just i like deathcab more.
I like all the bands you mention
except Deathcab, who can do one.
Pavement
easily the worst band mentioned
All the other bands are ..erm, debatable
Pavement is not debatable. There is no ambiguity with Pavement. There should be no question mark near Pavement. If I was your mother I'd rinse your mouth out with soap!
I like them
I just like the other bands more, well actually dont rate the shins or deathcab that much, oh well i'll put it down to this thread being the place for incorrect statements
well, if we're doing this...
1. NMH
2. Death Cab
3. Pavement
4. Shins
5. Unicorns
Ranges from really good to amazing
^indeed
^i think probably this
although i have a soft spot for the unicorns which means i love them the most.
I'm with you John.
Totally. I'm not even that big a Pavement fan, oh well perhaps I wasn't cut out for this indie stuff...
nah you're safe
those bands are indie for people who don't want an alternative, they just want pop bands that less people have heard of.
Now, we fight.
Dukes up.
Actually, in truth
I can see where Pavement might be an acquired taste... which is why I used them as an example on that new chick's thread "instant gratification".
I just think Pavement (although I was instantly gratified!) is worth "acquiring" a taste for.
I'm sorta surprised at J_B not being in the Aeroplane-is-the-greatest-thing-ever camp. No, not "sorta", I am... totally surprised. ;)
Quite apart from whether they are good...
I fail to see what the Unicorns, NMH and deathcab have to do with each other. 'College-rock-esq' = Rrrrrreal specific
Here's my guess:
He went to Patrick Wolf/Bishi, drank a lot, was totally amazed (I dunno about Bishi, but PW has that effect)... and said Rule Brittania! and fuck these REM rip-off Americans.... Am I right?
bit silly really
i mean, patrick wolf is probably the nadir of drippy faux meaningful 6th form music, and thats acceptable and somehow commendable, yet neutral milk hotel arent?
I don't like Patrick Wolf any more.
yeah, they're not at all similair
unicorns rule-icorns.
I'm not a fan of the otherz.
I'm tempted to say The Unicorns > Pavement
Infact, I'm gonna. yeah.
Pavement are great and all but I think if you put one of their albums and the Unicorns album in front of me and told me to pick one to listen to, I'd choose the Unicorns every time.
Jellybones! JELLYBONES! JELLEEEEEEBONNNNES!
^2nded
the unicorns album is perfect
Thier one good song.
Nah
Sea Ghost
Les Os
I Was Born
All awesome. :)
I think I deleted the album apart from Jellybones actually.
and ready to die
best album closer ever
I really don't like Death Cab
and not too fussed about the rest. Certainly don't hate them but do find them all a bit dull.
But not Pavement right
You can't not like
Neutral Milk Hotel!
I see no reason to lump them in with the shins and deathcab and the unicorns. they're all college rock bands of varying quality.
NMH, in terms of the sheer quality of the songwriting are unique. 'Aeroplane over the sea' is like the album equivalent of Mullholland drive and his melodies and singing are just so beautiful.
I would stake my reputation on betting that you've never listened to it properly as an album, on your own, start to finish, whilst not thinking about your laundry or other things - which anyone who loves it will tell is the way it works best.
I'd bet your main experience of them is hearing 'Holland 1945' in clubs on a semi-regular basis.
'aeroplane' is on a par with Ys lyrically in terms of sheer density and richness of language. i think it's utterly stunning.
you're a fool. if this forum had karma I'd smite you. your kudos rating is 0.
yr mum
seriously though
have you really given NMH a proper chance and come to the conclusion you think it's a bit shit? obviously i don't know you personally, but it seems so unlikely.
the unicorns are the only band from that list i'd give 10/10
for their album.
you are knob
hardly
news !
fuck off lyle
just joking
John !
YOU are knob.
How do you like THAT apple.
the unicorns are farrrr from boring
you're probably not listening properly
Yes
listen with your ears for once, god. Although I agree, with the exception of NMH who you can't lump in with the rest of em.
Even a cloth eared buffoon who doesn't really like them such as myself can hear that they are a lot better.
you can't lump the unicorns either
really, i can understand how the rest of those bands could be dull though.
Bollocks.
Cram it up your arse
Brain-fool.
Get bent bottom taster.
but you like the unicorns?
hi!
you have no ears!
cheerio.
I used to really like The Unicorns and NMH a few years ago
But now i can't listen to either without being sick.
Boring shite boring shite boring shite