Sum 41 All Killer No Filler / Music Forum // Drowned In Sound

Sum 41 - all killer no filler

yes_ [Edit] [Delete] 76 replies 16:41, 7 March '07

Best pop punk album

Discuss

View Nested Linear

actually nah

does this look infected? might be better. I cant decide.

yes_ | 7 Mar '07, 16:43 | X
- does this look infected
  
  is waaaaaaaaaaay better
  
  LordLuciusBanter @yes_ | 7 Mar '07, 17:29 | X
Probably Not THE Best

But certainly one of. Most of the songs are what pop punk bands tend to forget, write them SHORT and write them CATCHY

NudeRonin | 7 Mar '07, 16:43 | X
nope

i would say enema of the state or dude ranch are better, so is nimrod.

sharp_yet_blunt | 7 Mar '07, 16:45 | X
- blink 182
  
  die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die die
  
  guntrip @sharp_yet_blunt | 7 Mar '07, 16:47 | X
  - i havent heard that one
    
    what album is it on?
    
    sharp_yet_blunt @guntrip | 7 Mar '07, 16:48 | X
    - the one
      
      with songs about boobies on it.
      
      guntrip @sharp_yet_blunt | 7 Mar '07, 16:55 | X
  - no YOU die
    
    i love blink. they have brought me much joy. do you wanna take that away from me?
    
    sophiacherryx @guntrip | 7 Mar '07, 17:52 | X
    - i guess
      
      i do.
      
      guntrip @sophiacherryx | 7 Mar '07, 19:06 | X
Dookie

By about 20 million gazillion miles.

colonol_k | 7 Mar '07, 16:49 | X
Big bag of Pants

Thats, A Big Bag of unwashed y's.

respec

FBC2 | 7 Mar '07, 16:50 | X
best album: enema of the state.

best single: The Ballad of Chasey Laine.

Thom_fa | 7 Mar '07, 16:58 | X
The best pop punk album...

is the Buzzcocks singles compilation.

Sum 41 were liked by so many idiots at school, that's all I can remmeber of them.

tom_from_sparks | 7 Mar '07, 17:03 | X
- Definitely
  
  well said
  
  Singles Going Steady: perfection
  
  doctornovocalcords @tom_from_sparks | 7 Mar '07, 18:02 | X
- i was going to say this
  
  but i would have admitted i was being a wanker by posting it
  
  um, rancids And Out Come The Wolves?
  
  alcxxk @tom_from_sparks | 8 Mar '07, 01:11 | X
How good is fat lip?

"The doctor said my mom shouldave had an abortion!"
*echoes*
"abortion... abortion... abortion"

yes_ | 7 Mar '07, 17:05 | X
- so good.
  
  ha!
  
  sarkyfox @yes_ | 7 Mar '07, 17:08 | X
I love this album.

You may be right.

IrishMagpie | 7 Mar '07, 17:10 | X
- Does This Look Infected is also good..
  
  but it kinda paved the way for Sum 41 becoming serious, and therefore shit.
  
  Blink 182 made the same mistake eventually.
  
  IrishMagpie @IrishMagpie | 7 Mar '07, 17:11 | X
  - Yeah
    
    Actually, does this look infected is my favourite.
    Perfect balance between pop punk and being "serious"
    
    yes_ @IrishMagpie | 7 Mar '07, 17:18 | X
  - The last Blink album was
    
    ace!!!
    
    fullerov @IrishMagpie | 7 Mar '07, 17:32 | X
    - ^this
      
      I wouldn't say it was particularly 'poppy', though.
      
      waterwings @fullerov | 7 Mar '07, 17:37 | X
      - Pop genius, surely?
        
        loque @waterwings | 7 Mar '07, 22:57 | X
        
        Well, sort of, yes.
        
        Granted, their last album still had 'pop sensibilies' (horrible phrase), although they seemed to go beyond that and expand their sound.
        
        waterwings @loque | 7 Mar '07, 23:30 | X
its better than does this look infected

sophiacherryx | 7 Mar '07, 17:52 | X
no

millencolin - pennybridge pioneers

bobj | 7 Mar '07, 18:36 | X
- best/worst lyrics ever
  
  on that one.
  
  mug_mug_mug @bobj | 7 Mar '07, 19:37 | X
i love true pop-punk

alkaline trio
green day
'...is a real boy' - say anything
'your favoUrite weapon' - brand new
'mutiny!' - set your goals
captain everything!
my dad joe (lolz)
lifetime
the descendents
the buzzcocks

Effloresce_Sean | 7 Mar '07, 19:36 | X
- yes.
  
  mostly. Don't forget Mr T Experience and the Exploding Hearts.
  
  mug_mug_mug @Effloresce_Sean | 7 Mar '07, 19:38 | X
  - yes!
    
    a lot of lookout stuff actually. there's a lot of stuff i have obviously forgotten.
    
    Effloresce_Sean @mug_mug_mug | 7 Mar '07, 19:40 | X
- some good bands
  
  in that list.
  
  Not all Pop-Punk by the strictest definition.
  
  Good to see someone else likes Say Anything though
  
  fullerov @Effloresce_Sean | 7 Mar '07, 22:51 | X
  - they are genius
    
    ex_cynic @fullerov | 7 Mar '07, 22:54 | X
    - Yes.
      
      Yes they are.
      
      My Pop-Punk List
      
      Blink 182
      Green Day
      The Descendents
      Buzzcocks
      Alkaline Trio (Debatable)
      Home Grown
      Fall Out Boy
      Cute Is What We Aim For
      The Movielife (some of it anyway)
      Brand New (YFW era)
      Rufio
      The Ataris
      
      fullerov @ex_cynic | 7 Mar '07, 23:05 | X
      - My List:
        
        Green Day
        Blink 182
        Fenix Tx
        Autopilot Off
        Me First And The Gimme Gimmes
        Straight Outta Junior High
        MxPx
        Midtown
        Descendents
        
        uncy_chris @fullerov | 8 Mar '07, 10:51 | X
- u missed out punchline
  
  and midtown
  and i dont really think you can class brand new as pop punk
  
  sophiacherryx @Effloresce_Sean | 7 Mar '07, 22:54 | X
  - You could
    
    on their debut.
    
    fullerov @sophiacherryx | 7 Mar '07, 22:56 | X
    - Hmmm i guess
      
      but they were still kinda emo-y and a bit too rocky.
      
      sophiacherryx @fullerov | 8 Mar '07, 01:53 | X
      - it's got so many classic pop-punk hallmarks, though!
        
        the slighty cringing lyrics about girls, the standard final acoustic song about friends, the fact 90% of the songs have a half-time "rock out" breakdown, the not-fully-developed waily vocals...
        
        pop-punktastic
        
        Effloresce_Sean @sophiacherryx | 8 Mar '07, 02:03 | X
..

Bouncing Souls - How I Spent My Summer Vacation

Anything by The Lawrence Arms.

shucks | 7 Mar '07, 19:43 | X
- Hmm
  
  Lifetime aren't pop-punk, surely
  
  Fallout_at_the_Boy @shucks | 7 Mar '07, 19:47 | X
  - yes!
    
    i saw the souls last month as well. tut for forgetting that.
    
    and of course lifetime are pop-punk. all their songs are poppy as hell. they're no heavier than anything the descendents put out.
    
    Effloresce_Sean @Fallout_at_the_Boy | 7 Mar '07, 19:51 | X
    - :)
      
      Bouncing Souls are fucking great. 'Gone' might well be one of the most perfect pop-punk songs ever.
      
      shucks @Effloresce_Sean | 7 Mar '07, 19:59 | X
      - Hooray!
        
        Good call on How I spent my Summer Vacation, superb album.
        
        Descendents - Milo Goes to College is IMO the definitive pop punk album. Others off the top of my head... Ahhh I have to go listen to the Descendents now :D
        
        Millencolin - Pennybridge Pioneers
        Audio Karate - Space Camp
        NUFAN - Leche Con Carne
        MXPX - Lie in General
        Ataris - San Dimas
        
        chuckbarris @shucks | 7 Mar '07, 20:29 | X
        
        my mate has mxpx tattoo.
        
        he regrets it, and he should.
        
        Effloresce_Sean @chuckbarris | 7 Mar '07, 20:55 | X
        
        aaaaarurghhghh
        
        love audio karate, nintendo 89 is the just SUCH A choon
        
        bobj @chuckbarris | 7 Mar '07, 21:02 | X
        
        Audio Karate = Awesome
        
        Am I right in assuming the album is bland?
        
        Fallout_at_the_Boy @bobj | 8 Mar '07, 01:51 | X
troublegum

by far

Hpipe | 7 Mar '07, 22:39 | X
- Nahhhhh
  
  If you're talking NFG, they peaked with their S/T album.
  
  chuckbarris @Prawnee | 7 Mar '07, 22:53 | X
  - and by the way
    
    thats not saying much
    
    chuckbarris @chuckbarris | 7 Mar '07, 22:53 | X
  - YUP YUP
    
    Kayleia @chuckbarris | 8 Mar '07, 09:18 | X
- Nah nah naaaaah.
  
  Top 3 'punk-pop' albums:-
  
  1) Blink 182 - 'Blink 182'
  2) The Movielife - 'This Time Next Year'
  3) Green Day - 'Nimrod'
  
  Special mention to Alkaline Trio - 'From Here To Infirmary'.
  
  To be quite honest, I find a lot of the other stuff in this genre pretty unlistenable.
  
  waterwings | 7 Mar '07, 23:34 | X
  - no oen has mentioned the first two alkaline trio albums. they aren't debatable. just forget 'crimson
    
    although i did forget 'this time next year'. gutted.
    
    Effloresce_Sean @waterwings | 8 Mar '07, 00:20 | X
    - Any Alkaline Trio effort...
      
      After 'From Here...' has been pretty bog standard. This thread has made me go back to a lot of old stuff I own...
      
      I want more Descendents love. 'Hope' is just amazing as a song. Just, amazing.
      
      chuckbarris @Effloresce_Sean | 8 Mar '07, 09:34 | X
- Hm.
  
  Could go on for hours with this one, suffice to say that I'd listen to Blink 182 over Sum 41 any day... unless it's Blink's last album, which was bloody awful.
  
  onesixfive | 8 Mar '07, 07:04 | X
  - ha youre WRONG
    
    alcxxk @onesixfive | 8 Mar '07, 08:52 | X
  - Completely wrong.
    
    waterwings @onesixfive | 8 Mar '07, 11:15 | X
- Wrong
  
  New Found Glory - New found Glory
  
  It's one of my favourites of all time... ahem.
  
  Kayleia | 8 Mar '07, 09:17 | X
  - I saw them many moons ago...
    
    Supported by RX Bandits and Fenix TX. God that was a long time ago... The first 4-5 tracks off the S/T are ridiculously good.
    
    chuckbarris @Kayleia | 8 Mar '07, 09:35 | X
    - So they are
      
      claybaby @chuckbarris | 8 Mar '07, 10:22 | X
- I'm gonna go home and listen to this tonight
  
  I forgot how much I used to love it.
  
  I saw them off the back of this album. they were awesome.
  
  fat lip = instant happiness
  
  chunty | 8 Mar '07, 10:21 | X
  - really?
    
    I thought they were bloody awful when I saw them touring "all killer..."
    
    shucks @chunty | 8 Mar '07, 11:49 | X
    - well I remember them being awesome
      
      I was in a high state of excitement though at being at a gig I'd actually chosen to go to.
      
      I remember bizzy-D being tiny and squeaky.
      
      chunty @shucks | 8 Mar '07, 14:01 | X
      - hmm...
        
        don't get me wrong, I'd wanted to see them, but I just thought they were terrible. Reel Big Fish were supporting I seem to remember; they were ace.
        
        shucks @chunty | 8 Mar '07, 14:22 | X
        
        I remember them being ace too
        
        You're probably right. I was just really excited to be there. they could have got up there and done a jig and I would've still been happy!! Now I'm much more critical of gigs I go to...
        
        chunty @shucks | 8 Mar '07, 14:25 | X
        
        I think the highlight
        
        was the drummer's singing during Pain for Pleasure and the dude from RBF playing guitar during one of their songs. Did you see the other support band, Wilt?
        
        shucks @chunty | 8 Mar '07, 14:34 | X
        
        I think I did....I don't remember it seems liek forever ago
        
        I don't think I was that impressed.
        
        I crowd-surfed for the first time at that gig. actually that's the only time I've done it, now I just find it annoying. god I'm getting old.
        
        wasn't there fire and drumsticks? or am I confusing reality with my dreams again?!
        
        chunty @shucks | 8 Mar '07, 15:28 | X
        
        I can't remember....
        
        sounds a bit like Green Day = fire + drumsticks. hmmm....it does ring a vague bell though.
        
        shucks @chunty | 8 Mar '07, 15:36 | X
- Pop punk is for
  
  CHUMPS. Yeah, you heard me right
  
  dove_from_above | 8 Mar '07, 11:33 | X
  - YOU'RE the chump
    
    pfft. loser.
    
    sophiacherryx @dove_from_above | 8 Mar '07, 12:35 | X
    - Best Pop Punk Albums
      
      Mr T Experience - Our Bodies Our Selves
      The Rezillos - Can't Stand The Rezillos
      The Descendents - Everything Sucks
      
      Other pop punk bands I like include The Groovie Ghoulies, NOFX, The Queers and probably some others.
      
      johnny_goatboy @sophiacherryx | 8 Mar '07, 14:08 | X
      - I wouldn't class
        
        NOFX as Pop Punk, although I kind of see where you're coming from.
        
        But on the subject: NOFX - Punk in Drublic / Lagwagon - Trashed.
        
        Oh. Yes.
        
        chuckbarris @johnny_goatboy | 8 Mar '07, 14:54 | X
        
        I'd say
        
        NoFX were more skate punk. Ahhh Lagwagon! :D
        
        "Just another Satttuuurrrdaaayyyy!!!"
        
        shucks @chuckbarris | 8 Mar '07, 14:58 | X
        
        Drive, drive, drive, drive, drive, drive...
        
        The intro to 'Stokin the Neighbours' is just ridiculous. Joey Cape is a don (Y)
        
        chuckbarris @shucks | 8 Mar '07, 15:00 | X

View Nested Linear

« Back to Music forum

Boards