I don't care what you think of their bland, meat and potatoes, coffee table... *looks at Pitchfork*... by-numbers indie, I think they are an absolutely fantastic band.
Enough of that. What are your favourite songs?
Everything's Not Lost
God Put A Smile Upon Your Face
Also, has anyone seen them live? If you like them, and you haven't, you really should. They're probably the best live band I've seen. 'Amazing' doesn't do them justice.