Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
Yes, slightly old news but meh
I can't decide if this is good or bad
I still can't decide whether to like Porcupine Tree or not. It's not bad sounding music, but what's the point. There are more technical bands. There are more emotional bands. They're not really the best at anything they do. They're just somewhere in the middle, waiting.
er, an interesting choice of label for them.
Explain your derision, sir.
Surely you either like it or don't like it. If you'd said "I can't decide if I like it" (indicating, perhaps, that further listening was required), then I'd understand. But making a decision on whether to enjoy something based on exterior factors seems a bit odd. It's like saying "I can't decide whether to like this cake or not." Just eat it and find out!
"Sure you either like it or don't like it".
I haven't decided yet.
It's a response. Not a considered decision. It's the use of the word "to" that confuses me. Do you mean "I can't decide IF I like it"?
I think you're trying to get a rise out of me.
RR have been branching out recently. PT are a banker though. RR can't go wrong with it. it's the new bands they shouldn't bother with.