Sign In:
18654
Type: Album Release date: 23/10/2006
Your Rating:

The debut mini-album from hotly-tipped London quartet Battle is a fairly decent effort, but it’s not enough to suggest a long, glittering career might lie ahead.

The problem with Back To Earth is that it’s painfully derivative and, in the final analysis, rather unremarkable. The seven tracks roll by in a 24-minute bluster of tense, energetic guitars and passionate yet melodic vocal lines, but there’s nothing to suggest that any of the songs will persist in the memory, nor, sadly, any indication that Battle have anything more left in the creative tank to offer.

Frontman Jason Bavanandan’s vocals most closely resemble the breathy Englishness of Jarvis Cocker, yet in truth his band sound like a hotchpotch of any number of indie outfits du jour - the influence of Bloc Party in particular looms rather too large. In the main, Bavanandan’s lyrics are pretty uninspired, and for every occasional nice turn of phrase, such as the opening track’s eponymous “wicked owl”, there’s a clanger, such as “I’d never leave the house / Make no mistake, I’d be housebound”.

‘I Never Stopped’ exhibits the potential to have been the best track on the record, with the band attempting to leave behind their established blueprint and submit to all-out pop, but it just never takes off. Final track ‘Easy To Listen To’ is a similarly unsatisfying stab at breaking the mould. Aiming for the big, apocalyptic finish, it rings far too hollow.

At best, Back To Earth suggests that Battle might provide a decent enough 30 minutes of live entertainment, but they’re going to have to up their game considerably if forthcoming debut full-length Break The Banks is not going to quickly consign them to the ranks of indie mediocrity.

Yep.

Battle have better songs, a few anyway, but when I heard they were releasing a mini-album after being around for so long already, I wondered what the point was, and when I saw the tracklisting I was even more confused. If you're going to make a mini-album, you need to get to the point fairly quickly. Quite why you'd release a mini-album of some of your least spectacular and MOR offering is beyond me.

Shame.

What have they been doing for the last 18 months?!

I saw these play in Leeds ages ago and thought they were fairly dull, Bloc Party copyists at the time. Then I heard this, and I feel exactly the same. The difference is, BP's songs have substance to back up the style; the same isn't true for Battle.

i heard bits of this

and it sounded like they had one good sound but only one good sound. not really the depth to earn a purchase, eh.

well

its only a fiver in fopp, theres 2 or 3 songs to justify spending that...

Thats a load of Rubbish

This album doesn't sound remotely like Bloc Party- that comparison ceased to mean anything a long time ago. Bloc Party have lots of dull copyists but Battle are a very original band. One of the best things about them is that they've managed to remain apart from the angular dross that's characterised British indie music recently. Lots of genres are bravely and sincerely referenced on this record- from post-punk to Motown to 80's AOR (not MOR!)- but they maintain their own sound.
Battle write genuine pop songs with epic scope.

indeed

saw em live and they were muchos repetitive.. i like a few songs but they lacked variation. i was bored by the third song but i did appreciate the singers spasmatic dancing...

most disappointing purchase

of the last 12 months. if i hadn't bought it off itunes, id have taken it back. il refrain fromn saying its shit, just not for me. at all.

i really really

like this...

Yeah me too

Its short, sweet and plenty energetic/danceable/fun. I like the breathless vocals aswell, bring on the full-length album.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon