Name great albums 'miraculously' produced while the band was in turmoil.
Seems appropriate on the anniversary of 'Rumours', an album that is remarkable for being ever produced at all, given the state of the personal relationships within the band at the time (I think we all know the stories of band members being unable to be in the recording studio at the same time). Yet it's a band that gains so much of what is special about it by being a product of all that.
What other albums miraculously came to fruition during a time of serious strife or personal tragedy for the band in question and yet turned out to be stunners because they were enthused with the emotions of that period?
- Relevant artist taggings:
- None
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this


Correction - "an ALBUM that gains so much of what is special about it..."
Correction 2 - "...because they were REFLECTIVE of the emotions at that period."
God, I give up. I can't bloody write anymore.
Subtle - For Hero: For Fool
its an incredible album anyway, but recorded in the wake of a serious road accident that left one of the band quadriplegic it is even moreso, particularly on the last track on which said member did a lot of the percussion and structuring;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0xp0kmWkdE
between 3:00 and 6:00 always gives me goosebumps
Menomena
nngh
Menomena's Friend & Foe and Mines were both produced near the end of their original lineup. It was a widely known and accepted that Brent, Danny, and Justin had a LOT of hatred for each other, and barely spoke to each other when they didn't have to. And those two albums are fucking perfect.
The shitty thing is, Brent Knopf left to focus on Ramona Falls, and Menomena made a weak link of a record after that. It was GOOD, but...
i thought it was dreadful
mines was amazing though.
NOTHING...SOUNDS A...PPEALING
Moms is clearly not "dreadful"
But it isn't as good as their previous albums.
Tithe is a tremendous song, isn't it? When the bass and drums come in - sweet Jesus!
I thought Moms was great
But Mines is a masterpiece
I think Moms was really awesome
But Friend & Foe was a gem, and Mines was absolutely flawless. Mines is a tough act to follow. If Moms were their second record, I wouldn't have thought about it. But after those two records, it's hard to view it without thinking about it as a step back.
Maybe that's just 'cause I'm a fucking fanatic about them.
concur Mines masterpiece
Moms cracking though, they were great at Cargo last year, so happy i finally got to see them live
Controvertial, I know
But IATFBM will always be my favourite. The song-ideas are less developed, but as much as I love everything they've released, everything else has just seemed a bit blander.
dog man star?
Blood on the Tracks
Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating In Space
THE WHITE ALBUM and fucking ABBEY ROAD.
/thread
I was gonna say...
Let It Be
The Lost Riots (little bin it of deserved love for it on here recently)
was made in the midst/wake of guitarist Jimmi Lawrence's death.
Not sure how much influence it had on the album's 'message' to be honest, a lot of the revolution! come together! friends! brothers! stuff etc was there from the very beginning. But the fact that they managed to a) release something and b)that that something was so incredible is pretty impressive.
*little bit of
i thought the album was all written and done when he passed away, and he killed himself around the release date
an amazing album anyway
He killed himself in the studio the night after they finished recording, iirc
Such a sad story.
I think about 3/4 of it was done and dusted, you're right. Memory's a bit hazy of that couple of years.
It's nearly ten years old(!) now to be fair.
babyshambles down in albion
Yeah, he said GREAT albums
Battles - Gloss Drop
Not generally regarded as being as good as Mirrord, but still.
Saturday Night Wrist
I think it's great anyway.
Hmm I would have gone with Diamond Eyes
No one expected Deftones to make another album after the accident. Especially so soon afterwards.
Third/Sister Lovers
Spacemen 3
Playing with Fire.
Apparently Kember and Pierce couldn't even stand to be in the same room as each other by this point. The dicks.
BUT the album is fucking incredible, their best in my opinion.
Recurring as well
They couldn't stand to have their songs on the same side of the LP by that point.
maybe one of the stones ones at the end of the sixties
its a great idea for a thread actually, there are those albums like Big Stars Third that actually sound better due to the circumstances they were recorded in
Kevin Gilbert - The Shaming Of The True
The album was finished and released posthumously.
Damned shame too, as it's a bit of a sardonic masterpiece.
Guided By Voices - Propellor
No massive band issues like with Rumours or anything, but the band was getting so little recognition for their earlier albums that Bob decided to call it quits. He wanted to release one last album before that happened though, and tried to write his biggest, most powerful tracks yet and have them properly produced. The result was one of their most consistent/best loved albums, which included one of the all time greatest, and most triumphant, opening tracks ever
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eSd-80X-GEo
The Holy Bible?
apparently the band had a pretty nice time recording it
Richie's drinking was getting out of hand, but I think they've said they enjoyed the process a lot more than recording Gold Against the Soul, it was only really afterwards that Richie's health nosedived... I suppose if anything, Everything Must Go was probably the record that had the more to overcome...
The recording wasn't problematic but the band wasn't feeling too well either
Richey had his problems, Bradfield's mother had just been hospitalised, I think one of them was going through a break-up as well? Basically everything was going to hell in their personal lives and they vented it out in the music, the recording of which was fairly unproblematic.
Plus their manager/mentor Philip Hall had died, who had been pretty much their only ally in the music business at times
absolutely
I would suggest that Everything Must Go was a more unlikely prospect.
Pink Pink Pink Pink
Pink Moon
Eels - Electro Shock Blues
?
Never heard of that
Obviously I meant..
..that I never heard that the band wasn't getting along during that time (but isn't the band fundamentally just E? Unless you meant something else. I'm intrigued!
He wrote the album
following his sisters suicide and the discovery that his mother had terminal lung cancer (she died when he was touring the album).
M B V
Kid A
Was there much turmoil during the Kid A sessions?
I thought it was just Ed being pissed off because he wanted to play his guitar.
Thom had a breakdown, didn't he?
It was either 'Kid A' or 'OKC', or somewhere between the two or both.
Yeah
His breakdown during the OKC tour led to the change of direction and general attitude of Kid A
Loveless was turbulent, too, wasn't it?
Smashing Pumpkins
Though not so miraculously, cos Billy sees himself as SP.
the story of that Zwan album sounds full of turmoil even by Corgan's standards
though I've heard it's no so great (never actually heard it myself)
The album's not that bad actually
Not a classic, but some good songs on there. Probably some of the lighest, poppiest stuff Corgan has done, and pretty much the last time he released anything interesting. I think a lot of the Zwan turmoil came after the album was recorded, though.
I keep meaning to have a listen to it
because there's always a part of me that finds it funny that one of the reasons that they broke up was that David Pajo was having sex with the producer's girlfriend and refused to end it.
because?
ignore the word 'because'.
The first half's good
The second half takes a huge nosedive into mediocrity. Makes for a really nice 7-8 song EP of summery rock/pop.
The middle is the sweet spot
it starts off on the wrong foot as well
Slint - 'Spiderland'
Depending on which rumours you believe.
BRMC - Howl
Howl
What happened during that? The drummer had left by that point hadn't he?
St. Anger
er'ybody seen Sum Kinda Monster
Mogwai - Young Team (fights, etc)
Blur - Modern Life is Rubbish (think they were gonna get dropped)
Dinosaur Jr. - 'Bug'
Don't know for sure, but it seems obvious.
WHY? WHY DON'T YOU LIKE ME???????
Feeder- Comfort and Sound
http://drownedinsound.com/community/boards/music/4425033#r7322372
Abbey Road
Mumford & Sons - Babel
Besieged by haters on all sides, the pressure on Marcus and his merry band of folksters was almost too much. But they really silenced their doubters and came back with a classic. Top work lads!
If that's what passes for "classic" these days...
I think O.J. was ... you know
guilty all along?
knew it.
The Soft Bulletin
Notably because it was during Steven Drodz's heroin addiction
Didn't he
relapse again recently?
Nirvana - Greatest Hits
Impressive work to say Kurt was dead
Massive Attack - Mezzanine
I believe there were times when they literally wouldn't step foot in the same studio as one another during production; and of course Mushroom pretty much up and left the band when it was released (and as far as I know hasn't released anything since). 3D was the only original member on 100th Window. It took 8 years before he and Daddy G could work together again.
true
I read an interview during the time of the recordings; they would take it in turns to work on samples, loops etc. and do shifts basically on the music without seeing each other. An amazing album which sounds like the happy go lucky stoners of Blue Lines and Protection going mental. Which they were.
Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space
Written shortly after the breakup of Pierce and Kate Radley, where Pierce learnt that she'd been secretly married to Richard Ashcroft of the Verve since 1995.
Songs kind of speak for themselves.
The Verve - A Northern Soul
Band had split up for the first of three times during its making, correct? A Storm in Heaven is still their best album, but they were probably able to tolerate each other a lot more during that album's recording process.
Blur - Blur
Damon was a paranoid, coke-addled wreck whose relationship with Justine Frischmann was falling apart, Graham was a functioning alcoholic who hated the rest of the band, Alex was an obnoxious toff doing his best to be a cartoon cliche of everything that was wrong with britpop, and their last album had given them a level of fame none of them knew how to deal with & a musical direction none of them wanted to continue with coupled with a massive critical backlash. Then Damon decided to go on holiday to Iceland to sort his shit out...
What about Dave?
Dave can go fuck himself
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AkNvk2MgiCc
That Nardwuar guy is obnoxious
ABBA - The Visitors
Very much in the same vein of Rumours in terms of relationships etc, very frosty apparently, and they were also had major issues with the new digital recording technology.
I guess '16 Lovers Lane' by the Go-Betweens is the 'indie' Rumours too.
Came here to say 'The Visitors'
Greatest pop band of their era falling apart internally, meaning that their beautiful melodies and astounding understanding of chorus structures was used to underline absolute sorrow and heartbreak. Almost unbearably beautiful at times.
Shout for Strangeways, Here We Come too. Though apparently they all amicably knew that was going to be the end, it still has that echo of sorrow, especially towards the end of the album
Faith No More - The Real Thing & Angel Dust
Jim Martin was pretty much hated by the rest of the band from what I've read, yet 2 great albums.
I read somewhere that the reason they ended up covering songs like 'Easy'
was because Jim Martin was too impressed with himself about the 'War Pigs' cover they did.
Siamese Dream
This Is Hardcore.
The Byrds - Notorious Byrd Brothers
The original 5 piece band had dwindled down to just 2 members by the end of that album.
And it's still amazing. Their best in my opinion.
Rolling Stones - Their Satanic Majesties Request
Much maligned but I love it. I mean, how can you dislike Citadel or 2000 Light Years From Home??
Recorded during a period of drug busts, police/newspaper harrassment, imprisonment.
Or Sly & The Family Stone - There's A Riot Going On. Insane amounts of drugs (mainly coke and PCP), extreme paranoia, gansters as bodyguards, pet chimps attacking dogs (or vice versa), missed gigs, partying, recording vocals in bed, band members dropping out = a fantastic album.
She's A Rainbow too!
Mercury Rev - Deserter's Songs
Bands / Those funny little plans / That never work quite right
Pills n thrills
And bellyaches. As I assume all concerned were rightly fooked up.