Sign In:
Login with Facebook

Shellac ATP... How was it for YOU?

I had a bloody marvellous time. First time at Camber and yeah the chalets are a bit dodgy and cold but I don't think it had a bearing on my weekend really.

+ Both of Shellac's performances were brilliant, I like the opening and closing the festival idea. Definitely glad I made the first one and had End of Radio to kick the whole thing off. They also just seem like a bloody nice bunch don't they?

+ I think my other favourite performances were Neurosis, Rachel Grimes, Oxbow (apart from the Israel pants bit) and The Ex & Brass Unbound (I was feeling completely flattened by Sunday night but they brought me back to life dancing).

+ Met Kim Deal and Niko from Oxbow who were both lovely.

- same gripes as everyone about lack of beer and food options but this was my first time in a chalet with a fridge and oven so it didn't really matter.

How did everyone else get on?

View NestedLinear
  • Relevant artist taggings:
  • None
  • very good

    friday broke me - too much alcohol - so i felt awful all weekend after that but had a great time anyways. our chalet was fairly OK by sunday night but was so cold until then, some douche left the window open before we checked in.

    favourite bands bla bla melt banana especially

  • Good to be back in Camber.

    The nearly 2 hour queue to get wristbands in the cold and missing most of Shellac on the first afternoon was bad. As was the woeful alcohol selection at Pontins.

    Favourite bands, in this order:

    1. Melt Banana
    2. The Ex
    3. Rachels
    4. Future of the Left
    5. Shellac.

    Overall a good solid ATP with flashes of inspiration: 6/10.

  • Pretty good!

    The chalets were ok and the electricity meter was stuck at 20p so didn't have to pay for that. I wouldn't say it was good to be back at Camber though, I liked it when there were better drinks and bigger bars so you didn't have to stand forever queueing. Mind you I didn't spend as much money and didn't get as drunk as usual because of it so I suppose that's good really.

    Also if there's one thing on at a time when people won't still be in bed you should have the one thing on in the big room so everyone can actually see them. Huge queue for Nina Nastasia that remained there the entire duration of the set pretty much. Gave up on that room after Rachel Grimes (AMAZING) on Sunday.

    The Ex were maybe the best.

    Kim Deal solo was great whadda voice. Charmingly nervous. Thought solo Cannonball was a potential disaster but it totally worked.

    Zeni Geva & KK Null solo set was really good. That sort of thing is great as a two piece if your drummer is Yoshida Tatsuya. What a guy. KK Null seems like a top bloke too. 'I present my solo project. If you only came to see Zeni Geva now is a good time to go to the toilet'.

    Melt Banana as a two piece weren't really any different! 'You can't replace that bassist, she's a machine!' My friend said. Well they've replaced her with an actual machine and it sounds the same.

    Buke & Gase might be the next sufjan newsome sensation. Verr good

    I liked the Cravats frontman reviewing the band's performance straight after the song. 'Hmm. Nearly flawless'.

    I liked Stnnng & Scrawl & Turing Machine on the Friday.

  • Top tips for those of us going next week?

    Always been to Butlins so not sure what to expect. Sounds like I need some warm pyjamas and a fuck load of booze, anything else?

    What is the alcohol selection actually like in the bars and do they actively stop you taking your own in?

  • i had a fucking blast. didnt think the chalet was THAT cold, although one plug socket per kitchen was a bit of a pain. some minor admin gripes aside, it was pretty near perfect for me.

    highlights: the ex, shellac, shannon wright, nina nastasia, uzeda, rachel grimes, red fang, mono, bottomless pit, three second kiss, the cravats.

  • Have to give a mention

    to Shannon Wright. She was as awesome as ever.

    thegoodmrbrodie this'd this
  • bar selection: generic lager, newcastle brown ale, guinness, generic cider. generic spirits. gets the job done. they didnt seem too bothered check bags or pockets. a well hidden flask will serve you well.

    other advice: fill in your forms before you get there - apparently that is what slowed down the entry on friday. you probably wont need to spend any money on electricity - no-one i know saw the meters go down in value. if you want to see something in the second room, get there in good time - that place fills up quick.

  • Take:

    - Pre-filled in forms + photo ID
    - Splitter plugs (there were only six plug points in the entire chalet, and that includes those powering the electric heaters)
    - Towels
    - Loo Roll
    - Sleeping bag/duvet
    - Washing up liquid
    - Sharp knife
    - Food and drink. Unlike Minehead, there are no massive supermarkets near the site.
    - Drink. The bars ran out of all beers but Carlsberg on the final day.
    - Drink. You'll need spirits to keep you warm.

    Don't bring:
    - Anything that needs to go in a freezer

    Do:
    Get there before 2pm on the Friday, if you can.

    SarcasticFringehead this'd this
  • Great festival, but...

    ...I think we've been a bit spoiled with Butlins tbh. I'd forgotten how much of an absolute and utter dump Camber is by comparison.

  • They actually ran out of everything bar Carlsberg by the Sunday night.

  • My first time in Camber

    So so so so bleak. I never even ventured outside during daylight. Couldn't face it. Imagine going on holiday there?

    The positive stuff is that several bands were absolutely exceptional (especially Melt Banana) and the general vibe was great fun. Everything being sort of in one building, claustrophobia/bottlenecks aside, meant I only really remembered I was in a Pontins when I went outside, whereas Minehead was all BURGER KING PIZZA HUT BIG TOP WOO.
    I liked as well the 2 stage mostly staggered lineup, plus the late night stuff (what I remember of it). Bit gutted about missing both Shellac shows thanks to arriving in the evening/leaving Sunday night but if it wasn't them it just would've been someone else so whatever.

    Not particularly happy with the chalet. OK it was old and cold, expected that, because Pontins. But a "5-berth" consisting of 1 tiny bedroom with 3 beds plus a sofa in the main room was a bit of a pisstake when we'd all punted in a grand or so altogether to be there. Thankfully some of our group got down early and phoned up an airbed order.

    But overall, ATP is ATP. Glad I went.

  • +ves

    Back in Camber. Hurrah!
    Nina Nastasia (wonderful set, so much better than the last time she played ATP)
    Buke and Gase (my pick of the weekend, probably)
    Shannon Wright
    Arcwelder
    Shellac, obviously
    Mono (despite the chatty crowd)
    Neurosis
    Prinzhorn Dance School
    Zeni Geva
    Future Of The Left
    The security guy who looked into our chalet, saw the lasers, lights, smoke machine, amp and mixing desk and offered be our bouncer.
    Walking all the way along the beach on Saturday morning and down to Rye Harbour

    -ves
    The lack of plug points
    The bar staff not knowing how to work along the bar to serve people
    Not enough staff on the bar
    Shit beer selection and running out of Newcastle Brown every evening and all beers bar Carlsberg by Sunday afternoon
    The amount of bands who just sounded like bad versions of Shellac
    Gay Witch Abortion not really being that out of the ordinary
    Missing the following: The Ex, Kim Deal, Kim Deal doing kareoke, Rachel Grimes, Red Fang

  • Oh yeah, if you're vegetarian, bring your own food.

    There is a stall selling Buddha Boxes, but that's it.

  • quick question

    about tickets/wristbands. did the wristbands get handed out when checking into the chalets (like in minehead) or was there a separate wristband exchange? how does it all work at camber sands?

  • well, 2 of us checked in to our chalet and did all the forms and got the keys

    and our 2 wristbands. the 3 other people in our chalet came later on, we had to leave their wristbands in an envelope with their names on which they picked up on arrival. wasn't too bad.

    we didn't show ID or anything but i'm sure others did.

  • they got handed out

    the people who arrived later had to go and get theirs from the check-in bit though. They actually put the wristbands on for you.

  • I'd be very surprised if they didn't change how they organised things,

    but they had a long queue outside where they checked ID, and then marked your forms, before allowing you to go into the lobby area and queue up to collect your wristbands.

    When you're in the lobby, make sure that you get into the right queue - they're divided into four groups by surname (of the booker). People seemed to be just milling into one group/queue, and there wasn't much organisation in there.

  • Oh yeah. That fucking hobby horse.

    Just, ATP, please find some way of destroying it, please.

    Battlecat this'd this
  • Yeah, good times, if not the greatest ATP ever

    somebody had put an old Reds line up in their window and I did feel a bit nostalgic for the breadth of acts you got with four programmed venues rather than two.

    As I understand it, Pontins is still in administration, so the fact the staff weren't very experienced/plentiful was due to them mostly being temps (because it's not opens for holidays). But I thought they were very nice, and security were positively saintlike next to the Minehead lot.

    A few too many bands who sound like Shellac, but actually the Saturday and Sunday line-ups were pretty diverse in their way. Nina Nastasia, Kim Deal, FOTL, The Ex, Shellac, Buke and Gase all highlights.

  • Brilliant!

    Music Highlights:

    Shellac
    Oxbow
    Prinzhorn Dance School
    Arcwelder
    Bottomless Pit
    Melt Banana
    Bear Claw
    Pinebender
    Future of the Left

    Was a bit disappointed with Mission Of Burma and Wire as love them on record but they weren't bad by any means, and really enjoyed everything else I saw.

    The second stage occasionally got too full and was annoying when you couldn't get in but don't really see what they could do about this... Security were overall great, didn't have any bad experiences, no unnecessary searching of people or dickhead attitudes, kept the crowds flowing.

    The sound was awesome on both stages, seriously every band sounded great, was a treat to see bands who would normal play small venues really work on bigger stages.

    As mentioned lack of beer choice was disappointing and they could have done with bringing some extra food in though the one Vegan choice was yummy. Also if you did go for any trash Pontins food it was pretty cheap.

    Managed to keep the Chalet warn and everything worked and was nice and clean. We had one extra space luckily as think it would be really crammed if full.

    Obviously there could have been a few improvements i.e. food and drink, but seeing as you could bring your own I think this is minor gripe. I was too busy trying to catch as many bands as possible so didn't spend much time in the chalet or doing anything else in Pontins so can't comment on that.

    Overall possibly my favourite ATP ever. I mean music wise it very much catered to my tastes so was always going to be fun but getting to see bands like Arcwelder sound so great on a large stage was really special.

    No one has been complaining about sound quality, bands running late or anything like that which goes to show how well things ran. A few problems with organisation elsewhere but I think ATP should be congratulated on putting on a brilliant festival.

  • Washing up liquid but also...

    Sponges/scourers of some sort and a teatowel, our chalet had neither of those.

  • aye the sound was mint

    especially for Neurosis, they sounded huuuge

    Spicer, JustJay, and crashingthrough this'd this
  • My first ATP so can't make comparison to other ATP's...

    Really pleased that I went despite not knowing quite a few of the bands in too much depth when making my decision to go. Melt Banana were amazing and the crowd was an absolute riot. But great to see some other acts which I'd never normally see and which I will explore more on record (Zeni Geva, Love in Elevator). Missed Buke & Gase but their performance seems to have gained a lot of acclaim. Rachel Grimes was great; perfect for a Sunday afternoon.

    Pontin's did look rather tatty, and I can't imagine staying there on holiday, but the chalets were ok for a few days stay. Do bring everything that Marckee mentions above as they are quite austere in terms of stuff provided. Electric meter didn't decline at all while I was there, so we just had the heater on the whole time (it was very cold). Security were fine, not heavy handed at all.

    Apart from that, big fan of the general ATP vibe. It felt small, compact, friendly, fun loving. Definitely thinking about going to the TV On The Radio one in May.

  • So they don't have

    bedding?
    a supermarket on site?
    nice ale bars?

    Gutted.

  • you can walk out of the venue with your glass ...

    ... and then walk back in with it without problem, particularly through the queen vic entrance. chalet pitstops = essential.

  • oh, and thoroughly agree with comments about security

    they were the best bunch atp have had for ages. didn't really see any dickhead officious behaviour which has marred some recent minehead ones.

  • There is bedding, but the chalets can be cold.

    And there are two supermarkets on site (plus a little shop over the road), but they're nowhere near as big or as well-stocked as the Minehead ones.

  • Thanks for this

    ?

  • If I have friends who don't have tickets but have arranged to get them on-site

    via the ATPeople Facebook group, are they going to have any trouble?

  • This was really really great.

    Actually liked CamberSands a lot more than I thought I would, and we just kept the heater on all weekend so it wasn't cold or anything, the actual venue bit really suited ATP as well, and if there was a queue for the downstairs stage you could just go round to the Queen Vic entrance. Nearly every band I saw was great, but especially The Ex + Brass Unbound, Future of the Left, Nina Nastasia, Rachel Grimes, Prinhorn Dance School, Melt Banana and Red Fang.

  • do the bands programme a tv channel?

    In the chalets like minehead?

  • thegoodmrbrodie this'd this
  • The Ex + Brass Unbound

    were my no.1 I think. Amazing combination, really fantastic for bringing out the affinities/convergences between two very types of music that maybe aren't immediately obvious. Or, idk, but those at least were my musings after about 8 beers.

    Bands-wise, I actually think *everything* was pretty great, maybe sans Gay Witch Abortion (a bit boring) and a couple of them Italian bands (a little meh, although I was kind of zoned out at that point).

    As for chalets, I had no real complaints. Were some much better than other, or are my standards really poor?

  • okay!

    chalet was hideously cold, but by the second day having left all the heaters on, it was quite pleasant.

    bumped into Marckee but not Yesiamaduck and Sarcastic Fringehead or any other DiSers. shame!

    had a weird encounter with some 'friendly' girls who might just have been terrible people being terrible.

    Buddha Boxes are so tasty.

    our table bossed the (interminable) book bingo. if they hadn't asked Danny to hold back, he would have got way more than five.

    finally seen Mr. Show. :D

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uco5Ed-5y2U

    :D :D :D

    Rachel Grimes and then Nina Nastasia with Grimesy and Helen Money were perfect on the Sunday morning. gentle and deeply affecting extended moments of calm.

    Neurosis had a really sparse crowd, FU BEDWETTERS. they were monsterously good, though. heaviosity.

    Oxbow full band AND orchestra? orchestra should have been higher in the mix, though. so great, though.

    so glad people digged The Ex. me and my pal Danny danced quite a bit to them.

    FoL freak-out at the end of their set was fun.

    Dead Rider were so worth checking out. like US Maple plus Suicide divided by Royal Trux. or something. 'It's quiet time' *crazy drumming* 'NOOOOOO'.

    I love KK Null. and his song title announcements. mini solo noise set yay but not nearly LOUD enough. Zeni Geva were cool but I was too tired to enjoy.

    Melt Banana were great and all, but it felt less spectacular with just programmed drums and bass.

    Turing Machine were unexpectedly fucking super fun. DFA does krautrock. so much energy.

    Cravats were great, avant jazzy noise punk with chubby aged droll northern frontchap.

    Bottomless Pit were really nice, top guitaring.

    poor mixes for Arcwelder and MoB, I reckon.

    should have watched some of Shannon Wright.

    Shellac were great both times. immaculate sound. love Bob.

    we walked back to Rye station because we failed in taxi booking, but it was a gorgeous walk. was chatting to my friend Arfie about Warp records and I started thinking about old times walking through fields as a teenager listening to 'Music Has The Right...'. really wonderful countryside. good for my soul or what have you.

  • Agree on the Grimes/Nastasia/Money combo as perfect Sunday morning* music

    I suspect such scheduling was to some degree just pragmatism as they had to tune a whole fuckin' grand piano, but it was brilliantly arranged nonethelesss.

    (*morning broadly defined)

  • I think I might have met some DiSers on the Saturday night briefly...

    Me and dan_thw were at someone's chalet (I was pretty stoned and near incapable of conversation at this point and didn't stick around for too long) and met some people he knew.

    The countryside's great around there, it does feel rather remote though. People said it was bleak but it's December and it's cold, if you go in May or June it'll be fine.

  • ah man...

    Decided to give Dead Rider a miss and have some recovery time at the chalet thought your description maeks them sound awesome. Agree about MoB but thoguht Arcwelder were one of the best sounding bands of the festival.

  • the time we left the chalet, blinking and grizzled

    I loved the Music for 18 Musicians influence on her pieces.

    and I always loved Nina...love her even more now. how about Albini's words in the booklet, who knew he was so emotionally tactile.

  • it was lovely once the clouds rolled in

    it felt like my halls at Huddersfield Uni, living off pizza.

    I bet I would have spotted Dan if he hadn't been recently shorn...

  • they were still great

    buuuut idk, the sound had this harsh and blunt feel...not in a good way. imho.

  • subject line and main post seperate

    living off pizza is rubbish and unlovely.

  • Didn't more people

    see Uzeda? Their pre-ATP show during the week was stunning, ridiculously under-rated band.

  • saw uzeda

    they were magnificent.

  • It was good.

    Funny to hear all the bitching from people who'd only ever been to Minehead.

    Still the best for actually seeing bands and still the worst for actually living there for a weekend but hey, ho. It's about the music more than anything else.

    Generally great line up.

    I think I preferred Nina Nastasia's stories to the musical interludes in between, except when she got Helen Money and Rachel Grimes on stage.

    Enjoyed Bear Claw. Enjoyed Helen Money a lot. Mission of Burma and Wire disappointed. Future of the Left weren't at their best but still a good show from them, although that new guy unbuttoning his trousers and feeling his dick was a bit much, really.

  • nice beach /

    Did anyone see the guitarist from neurosis head butt the microphone and start bleeding from his head? That was cool.

    The Ex with brass were so good, as were Turing Machine who I had absentmindedly assumed were an electronic group.

    The dunes and beach were nice in the sun, with had lots of bizarre buildings and a dead sheep (metal as fuck).

    Off site there is a super weird place called the Camber Café where you can get an okay breakfast if you can stand the weird pictures of clowns and patio doors. Round the corner is a much nicer place called Rye Bay café with free wi-fi and peroni.

    You say Pontins is bad but it does have its own Pound shop.

  • An enjoyable festival

    The great bits:-

    Mono closing Stage 1 on Friday night were a joy. Could’ve done with playing a song from one of their earlier records rather drawing the entire set from the last 2 records though.

    Kim Deals performance seemed to be pretty divisive amongst those who saw it. Personally I thought it was outstanding. Particularly the slow song she played off Title TK (“Off You” I think it’s called) and of course Cannonball.

    Nina Nastasia was class. Staying seated throughout and playing a set of largely slow songs worked wonders. Her ‘twinkie’ story could’ve maybe been cut by 30 or 40 minutes to squeeze in some more songs though.

    Rachel Grimes was mesmeric. Her beautiful smile alone lit up Stage 2. Coupled with her magnificent piano it was easily one of the festival highlights.

    The beach

    The shit bits:-

    Only two stages

    Very limited number of bar staff

    Too many bands sounding like Shellac. Nowhere near enough variety (despite the defensive claims made by ATP)

    Cold Chalet (by Sunday it was ok)

    Poor selection of drinks at the bar (and running out!)

    Overall I’d say going back to Camber is a negative thing, especially after the relative luxury we’ve experienced with Minehead. Personally, I wont be going back to ATP if they hold it there especially if I’m parting with £180. After the terrific value for money I felt from the last 5 or 6 ATPs I do feel slightly fleeced.

  • I'm not sure about this 'bands sounding too much like Shellac' thing.

    The Shellac sound is really a sort of blueprint for Albini's production and I'd say most people who are into Shellac are into *that* sort of sound, so when you buy a ticket to a festival curated by them you expect bands to have that aesthetic.

    Some didn't live up to expectation but I don't have a problem with bands sounding like Shellac per se, and I'm not sure that's a particularly valid criticism.

    I also think that compared to camping and the options at pretty much any other festival out there, ATP at Pontins is still a fuck load better in terms of accommodation. Obviously Reading and Glastonbury have many many more bands but if it's all about the music then at ATP you can pretty much be watching bands for 11 hours on the trot so then the state of the site isn't really a concern.

  • Giving me a laugh seeing all the Camber complaints

    I'd been to both sites, & seemed in a minority at not being happy about the return there, both on this board & amongst my friends. It was a dump then, sounds like it's a *bit* worse now.

  • Nah, it wasn't worse.

    I think some chalets still hadn't been refurbished. Ours had and it wasn't great but it did mean it had double glazing and heaters and was warm, and the electricity was free.

    So on that basis it was 'better' but they could have done more. The main venue hadn't changed one bit.

  • Agree with this

    Slightly lazy comparisons. A band like Bear Claw sounded more like Big'N than Shellac and similarly for other bands different comparisons came to mind.

  • Who does sound like Shellac?

    I can only really think of Uzeda and they were brilliant.
    (Love the faces their guitarist pulls)

    How can Wire have disappointed anyone???
    Absolutely utterly glorious noise for an hour.
    Total bliss.

  • Wire disappointed me.

    I only got to see 30 mins before I headed down for Melt Banana (even then I had to queue a bit which was annoying) but in those 30 mins they played Please Take but nothing I really recognised from the stuff I'd heard by them. Dunno, for me it didn't feel like a set of the punchier, punkier stuff Elastica ripped off, which is the kind of Wire tracks I like.

  • thought

    FOTL's set was the best i've seen them play over the years and probably the single standout set of the festival. really exhilarating.

  • Wire were a blissful dronefest

    ...for the greater part so I guess if you were after a set of hits you were in the wrong place. Great for me though!!!
    Blinding version of Map Ref though - I guess you went to Melt B - who I thought were okay.

    Don't agree at all about Myownflag - wish that they were! Much more grungey and Nirvana-lite for the most part to me...and a tad boring?

  • Oh yeah, I gave up on them after a couple of songs.

    Their opening track sounded like Cult of Personality by Living Colour when it started.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzdUy90vTuk

    Yeah, drones from Wire wasn't what I was after.

  • Hmm. Just didn't really work for me.

    There was good stuff there but not quite up there. I think I preferred the Lexington set I saw when the Kong guy was standing in. Really liked the bass sound now, though: They've managed to make it sound incredibly huge.

  • saw them support Pissed Jeans maybe four years ago

    they struck me as the living embodiment of the Local Band. as much as it's cool that you don't have to have a 'profile', so to speak, to get on the ATP bill, it completely mystifies me what Todd Trainer* sees in them above whatever else he happens to hear

    *according to an interview I just read

  • myownflag

    were really poor. they were more like bush than shellac or even nirvana. in fact they were a lot like bush. a lot.

    shes_so_high this'd this
  • I had a pretty good time

    Prinzhorn, Wire, Red Fang, Shellac, Shannon Wright, The Cravats, FOTL, The Ex all killed it. Not as good as last year's NBC thought. I kind of wish ATP would have a different curator for each day more often as I was getting a bit sick of serious white people with serious guitars by the end of this weekend.

    First time at Camber after going to 6 at Butlins - it is a truly awful and depressing place. It makes me very sad to think that people go on holiday there. Anyone who thinks Camber is better than Butlins is basically either mental, nostalgic or being a contrarian hipster. Literally the only 2 good things it has over Butlins is proximity to London and a nice beach. OK, and there's less walking as it's smaller. I suppose Camber gets extra points for managing to sell hot dogs without filling the venue with the smell of rancid arse. So that's 4 things.

    Shit stuff about Camber:

    - chalets freezing, damp and should probably be demolished soon
    - bedding was disgusting
    - reception too small to deal with loads of people arriving at once
    - beer running out and nowhere near enough bar staff
    - no proper supermarket nearby
    - not enough to do aside from watch bands
    - JUST LOOK AT THE FUCKING PLACE!

    Basically, they should move ATP to fucking Center Parcs or something.

  • Ichor this'd this
  • i had an awesome time

    first one at camber and sure, i missed the minehead chalets but the venues are better at camber. i like that the site is smaller too as i have a shit sense of direction and get lost a lot.

    Red Fang were amazing. i was really looking forward to seeing them and they didn't disappoint. cool guys too as i met one of them and the merch guy on friday night.

    wire and gay witch abortion were disappointing. shellac were awesome (both times). i'm kicking myself for not speaking to steve albini when we walked past him.

  • oh, and it was annoying that you can't drink alcohol in the arcade

    i didn't get to play the 2p machines, damn it.

  • no alcohol in the arcade?

    DENIED

  • Our chalet was fine..

    kept heaters on and was always warm...

    - no proper supermarket nearby

    Really? A negative to a festival is there was no proper Supermarket?! The Nisa provided the basics and you could bring stuff with you.

    - not enough to do aside from watch bands

    Not enough to do aside from watch bands? Its a 2 and a half day music festival, its not you have to spend whole days finding ways to occupy yourself. There was a cinema, swimming pool, mega crap crazy gold, a beach and castle to wonder around, an arcade, bingo, quizzes, DJs went on till 4-5 in the morning. Plus you can also just choose to chill with your friends drinking in a chalet or pub... I barley had enough to just relax a bit let alone do some of the other things.

    I agree they could do with maybe bringing in a bit more food and adding maybe some sort of Ale stall like at Butlins.

    I agree if you want to do other things Butlins is better, but that main stage in the food court area sometimes suffered from poor sound and not much atmosphere in the day.

  • there's a pool?

  • oh god that arcade

    the flashbacks......

  • You've got a point

    What I meant was that there were way too many male fronted guitar bands (a la Shellac) on the bill. They didn't necessarily all sound like Shellac but their overwhelming number gave the festival a lack of musical variety that I've never felt at an ATP before.

  • ah! great.

  • it was closed

  • Bob's stats, though

    45% with female members
    25% all female.

    I actually doubt it's been much different on other ATPs. I guess it depends on how many you've been to and particularly which ones there were. It's generally been a massive sausage-fest both on and off stage.

  • of course it was

  • it is december

    not really unusual

  • It was my nin

  • It was my ninth ATP

    Most of the other ones have had a clear distinction between the line ups on each day. I think splitting the curators between three artists should be compulsary.

  • not much love for

    STNNNG?

    was blown away by them.

    thought kim deal's set was cringingly amateurish but kinda lovely too.

    wire were very dull and shoddy.

  • I missed them on account of getting food.

    They were at a time on Friday when I think most people were just arriving and sorting themselves out or (like me) went to eat. Unfortunate given everyone who saw them said they lived up to their name. :(

  • Well the 2006 ones were absolute blinders in that sense.

    Although I remember the Sunday of each being a bit disappointing due to a lack of heavy rock compared to the ones before so I guess I like the one-theme feel more.

    With one curator I've noticed the theme tends to be pretty clear, apart from maybe Godspeed with their (excellent) Weird Al choice. :D Obviously it can depend on the band dynamic. Dinosaur Jr. in 2006 clearly felt like we had a J Mascis Stage and a Lou Barlow stage for much of it, but I felt like Shellac delivered on what I wanted, which was a bunch of bands that Shellac liked.

  • STNNNG!

    were VERY excellent - one of the best of the weekend - I was going to do a write up saying that but I am too busy being knackered.
    I bought an LP and I'm after more now!

    Prinzhorn Dance School were another band who were cracking...

    Really enjoyed The Membranes and The Cravats from the past?

    I missed Buke and Gase who I think I may have liked (although foot percussion? really? I think the voice may have grated too)

  • The bands were good, so cannot fault the festival

    however Potins many short coming were made all the clearer in the winter when the beach and good communal areas around the site aren't exactly popular choices.

    We got lucky and go to bust electric meter in our chalet so just kept the heating on all the time without the credit going down.

    Best bands I saw: Melt Banana, Red Fang, Future Of The Left, Rachel Grimes, Love In Elevator & Buke & Gase

  • Also I didn't enjoy the Kim Deal set very much and misse almost all the headliners

    FAIL

    Oxbow were really good as well (and The Membranes/Bottomless Pit) in fact the line up was all good/to great from what I saw with Kim Deal being the weakest set.

  • Plus guys guys guysd

    you HAVE to have ID on you (all of you) in order to get in. Saw a 40+ year old get ID'd and you all have to get your wristbands at the same time now

  • Also a special shout out to the Europeans in attendance

    Same group of people spotted moshing at EVERY single gig (within reason) including a half empty 2nd stage with enough room to swing a cow in between each person

    Also the tactile strike on the unfortunatecamera man in the pit for Melt Banana (no photo pits) was a personal festival highlight only if it meant yelling charge with 14 strangers

    I hadn't seen a mosh pit of any not at an ATP before, so this was a bit jarring.

    Also Pontins is really shitty in the winter, it's fine in the summer as I love the beach and communal areas between chalets. But it really offers nothing but a bar with no beer and an arcade without any functioning machines besides that.

  • Did you expect the line up to more varied though?

    I think Shellac picked exactly the sort of line up I expected. From the ATP's they have done before and the sort of bands members of the bands have been involved with over the years it was quite easy early on to get a sense of what the line up would be like. I understand where your coming from but seems your critisims is more to do with what you wanted the festival to be rather than what it was always going to be.

  • Was really pleasently surprised at how enjoyable Buke & Gase and The Membranes were

    they were 2 bands I was expecting to maybe see if I was around the stage at the time but turned out to be 2 highlights.

    Buke & Gase sounded pretty much nothing like the recording & were all the better for it. Think everyone I spoke to RE: Buke & Gase were taken back by how much they enjoyed it.

  • The was security?

    just seemed like friendly guys in jumpers to me. One of them even nodded his hat at me and went 'mornin' as I sat outside my chalet on a comedown with a spliff in one hand and lots of discarded Pontins tokens in the other. If that were Butlins I'd have had my head kicked in then reported to the police

  • I was fuming when Dan_THW broke our ashtray

    thought it would be listed as £50 or something (being able to smoke in Chalets is greatly appreciated btw)

  • Ah, maybe it was because I was all checked in by 1pm?

    I hear it got a bit busy shortly after

  • I don't get that line about mosh pits

    are you saying you've never seen a pit at ATP or never not seen a pit?

    there were pits at ATP vs. The Fans Pt. II for The Jesus Lizard and at Les Savy Fav/Battles/Caribou for No Age.

  • http://youtu.be/Bv6og-PvKAg

    special moment from rachel grimes and shannon wright. this is what makes ATP great.

  • I was over exagerating

    I have seen the odd pit crop up in the past and the Les Savy Fav one in 2008 is one of the biggest pits I've probably been in but nothing close to the scale and numbers we got this weekend.

  • nah, we got there early too

    around the same time, I reckon. no queues or anything. maybe some folks were just more reasonable?

  • oh, well fair enough

    it was almost all REAL WORKING MEN'S NOISE ROCK so that makes sense.

    wish I'd gone down the front for The Ex. looked like so much fun.

  • Was down the front for Melt Banana

    now that was quite the endurance test!

    Also add 'Scrawl' to my highlights, they were really good riot grrl punk and just looked so happy to even be there yet alone actually playing.

  • I like Scrawl

    regret sitting at the back for them, but I was distracted by the three girls trying to befriend me.

  • The lead vocalist broke out into tears during the set

    it was like Blur at Glastonbury accept on a much smaller scale and without the huge reunion tour raking in the simolians

  • I hope they stopped that

    They'd done so by the time I went in to get our stuff. Good thi.g too as the only thing I had like ID was my credit cards.

  • aww

    yeah, I was dead chuffed for all the unsung paragons of the indie rock underground past getting props/money.

  • I HAD FUN.

    YOU HAD FUN.
    HANNAH THE HOT BARMAID DIDN'T SEEM TO WANT TO HAVE FUN WITH ME IN A BED.
    I DIDN'T ACTUALLY HAVE ACCESS TO A BED.
    I FEAR, HOWEVER, THIS WAS NOT HER PRIMARY CONCERN.
    ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, I STILL HAD FUN.
    ATP = FUN.
    FUN.

  • fantastic weekend

    so glad it's back at Camber Sands - I'm not being a hipster or a contrarian (although there is possibly a little bit of nostalgia colouring my judgement, having been going to ATPs since the original Bowlie) ... I just think the atmosphere there is so much better - less people in less places means you bump into friends more often and everyone is happy, friendly and sociable and there are more chalet parties so you make plenty of new friends ... Butlins did grow on me a bit over the years, but it always felt like a festival in a shopping centre
    + loads of great bands/performances
    + winning the pop quiz and the top trumps
    + great karaoke on Sunday (Kim Deal, Nina Nastasia and woman from Uzeba performing a haunting rendition of Are You Lonesome Tonight?, followed by Carrie Weston doing an excellent and sultry Fever, followed by my mate performing The Real Slim Shady)
    + I was delighted at being IDed at reception

    liz1973 this'd this
  • DaddyorChips this'd this
  • Funniest moment of the festival...

    A really pissed Dan_thw going up to Jamie Summers in the pub (who was DJ'ing) to say hi, and accidentally spilling beer on the decks, which he then tried to clean up with his hand, making the record skip... cringe :D

  • I may be exaggerating but that crazy frog whack a mole

    almost certainly had the same piece missing on it way way way back in 2008

  • I beat someone at top trumps

    got myself a deluxe reissue of 'Electric Warrior', which isn't too shabby.

  • I was showing off my scratching skills

    Jamie_Summers got a couple of free apology drinks out of it so I'm sure he didn't mind.

    May or may not have turned to an incredulous Barry Hogan and said "WHOOPS, LOL" without knowing who he was.

  • what time?

    my boyfriend went about 10.30am saturday and it was closed

  • yeah we all enjoyed STNNNG

    kept seeing the singer about all weekend too.

  • best pit was either Taraf de Haidouks or Omar Souleyman

    I remember coming out of the Omar Souleyman pit and watching Mr Cool Ice Omar Souleyman as multiple crowdsurfers sailed over the barrier. Didn't take his sunglasses off, didn't look remotely surprised, didn't give a shit. Love you Omar.

  • I remember Negative Approach too

    when Thurstin Moore was wielding a chair (maybe a table I can't remember) and trying to look like a badass

  • and the Stooges one

    in which Nate Young shouted 'FUCKIN STOOGES MAN' in my face

    basically loads of good pits

  • Does the main stage have a photo pit...?

    Asking for a friend.

  • well done to you, sir

    I got the Rolling Stones comp, which saved me buying it just for the two new tracks

  • missed that ATP

    but I'm glad to hear it. were there also people near the back hair-windmilling and/or air-guitaring?

  • :DDDDD

    vamos this'd this
  • congrats!

    special thanks to the stars of the Marvel universe.

  • yes it was

    you could tell people had been waiting for it for a long time.

  • awww man

    I haven't been to nearly enough ATPs.

  • I got the impression that the ID check wasn't all that serious. Seemed to me that as long as you had something you were fine. All I had was an expired university staff card which they didn't even look at to validate the photo. There again, I am 35.

  • Yup, both stages do, but only for those with photo passes,

    and only for the first three songs of a band's set (unless you're one of the ATP film guys, when you can stay on afterwards).

  • he was always

    on his own and checking his phone. so eventually, on the 50th time of seeing him stood on his own we made him come for a drink with us. he was lovely, polite, quiet, drank his drinks, thanked us for our company and then left alone once more, checking his phone. strange, awesome fella...strange, awesome band.

  • :')

  • Buke and Gase are amazing

    So excited to see them tonight and at this weekend's ATP. Such a weird, awesome band, and lovely people too.

  • They're a two-piece now.

    It appears you can replace a drummer and bassist with a MacBook Pro.

    They were immense. I looked up to the doors that led back to the Queen Vic during their set and the glass was all misted by sweat. Loads of people were pressed against the doors waiting to get in. It basically looked like this:

    http://files.scary-movies.de/2012/04/Shaun-Of-The-Dead-DVD-Cover.jpg

  • Damn! :D

    I wish you'd said, "ALRIGHT, WEE MAN?"

  • Didn't know they'd become a two-piece.

    It's kind of weird, but I guess if they were still as fun as everyone's saying they were, it doesn't matter.

  • Whilst I appreciated them being on the smaller stage as I was right up front

    I still didn't understand the logic of putting one of the most popular bands on the smaller stage

  • It felt topsy turvy a lot of the time.

    I think maybe it's simply that everyone who came wanted to see all the bands they put on because the line up was so strong. I guess flackcaptain was right in that sense, that there wasn't such a mix of bands, presuming a mix means a lot more stuff that your fans struggle to get into. But yeah, it seemed like everyone downstairs was insanely 'big'.

  • I had a great time

    I didn't see as many bands as I desired, due to Stage 2 being rammed or clashes and my friends mostly being annoying weirdos who wanted to play the puggy machines instead of watch bands as well as being hard to rally for awesome stuff.

    What I did see was great, though! These especially: Neurosis were huge, Melt Banana was insane, Mission of Burma was triumphant, Red Fang ruled (totally needed some galloping metal right when they were on), and Shellac was Shellac. And other stuff!

    Did not like Buke & Gase at all though. I thought I was losing my mind while they were on because it sounded like they were all playing different songs from each other. idk.

    Pontins is also pretty bleak, my word. I'd go back there in the summer, but no more winter ATPs - and my chalet was RIGHT NEXT to the venue this time.

  • he looks like one of our chalet mates

    one time when we passed him i drunkenly shouted 'chris' (friend's name) at him...to which he replied 'yes'. turns out not only do they look similar but they have the same name. it was funnier than this sounds. or maybe you had to be there (and drunk).

  • Exactly the same happened at ATP Tokyo

    Melt-Banana, Envy etc. on the smaller stage, hundreds queueing to get in.

  • Had a great weekend

    Camber sands is brilliant. It's horses for courses i suppose, but i don't think minehead compares really.

    Shellac were excellent, as performers and curators. Little touches like getting everyone to come for the starters each day, opening and closing the festival, playing great music.

    Really enjoyed shannon wright, uzeda, rachel grimes, three second kiss, the first half-hour of bottomless pit, turing machine, loads of other stuff. The ex and brass unbound were amazing.

    Buddha bowls! Pretty much perfect festival food, had one three days in a row.

    Yeah, great weekend.

  • Nearly forgot!

    Got to watch raising arizona at the camber sands memorial hall. It was cold and a bit weird to be there with one other guy and a security guard.

  • :D

    Spectacular.

  • Felt a bit bad for the security guy, he said he was staying there til 2am!

    He thought a few people might be turning up for zombieland, but i dunno...

View NestedLinear

Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this