I've never done one of these threads...

I'll start: My personally favourite is currently...

Cameo Antique

The playful curves, the shadow behind, it gives reminiscence of letterpress printing, and a simpler time in the wild west.

I'm also a big fan of Roadway (but in caps only): Simple, clear, smooth lines, I imagine it would be a font that Patrick Bateman would enjoy on a business card.

(Comic Sans is hereby banned from this thread)