Right, it has to be settled. Which of these two 90's emo classics shall come out on top!?! You decide!

In the red corner we have... Diary by Sunny Day Real Estate
In the blue corner we have... Four Minute Mile by The Get Up Kids

Personally I think its a pretty close one, Diary has the more intricate and complex songwriting, and is generally more musically intersting, but Four Minute Mile is generally catchier as a whole and more consistent (though has nothing on there as good as Seven or In Circles), as well as being closer to a straight up pop-punk record.

So, what does everyone think?