Where to go after Moon Safari?

I've just given Virgin Suicides a little spin and it's ok, but not songy enough (obvs cos it's a soundtrack).

Where's best, and which to avoid?

Last night a bunch of us were talking about albums that you have always listened to regardless of the phase you're going through and I realised that since hearing Moon Safari about 6 years ago for the first time, it's been in my top 10 permanently.