Think maybe it was Pavement for me, most recently. I'd heard them, of course, but about a year ago I was reminded here. Bought Crooked Rain/CR played it, and said to myself, You Must Own Them All. Though, technically, I still don't have Weston. Trail of Dead, too.

Established (semi-established) Bands that Inspired 'I Gotta Have All Their Records'!

Name the record that tipped you, and whether this fervor was indeed justified. And I shall larf myself silly at the person who claims they bought The Real New Fall LP (and bought the whole Fall catelog)...or wish to rob said person's bank account. ;-)